Roger Waters - The Wall (Live in Berlin)

Rating:
Summary: Better in some places than others
Review: The movie is better in some places than in others the terrible job on comfortably numb, but one of my turns stands out as being really really good. I would buy it, but this is NOT Pink Floyd.

Rating:
Summary: Astounding
Review: I paid about $10.00 for this concert and while I was watching/listening I felt I should be paying $10.00 monthly payments! Technical... I love concert videos I designed and built a dedicated home theater with 26 drivers , 800 watts, soon adding another 550 watts and a lcd tv with a 17 foot screen, diagonal, need I say more! Buy this video concert the audio is perfect! Roger Waters is a genius.

Rating:
Summary: A real classic
Review: We think this is so great that we only bring it out in special occasions, as not to wear out the video. Please notify us if this ever comes out on DVD. We'll be able to play it all the time.

Rating:
Summary: IT SUCKED!!
Review: I really hated it...Van Morrison really gaked out Comfortably Numb, ..what WAS Roger Waters thinking when he 'cast' this? The Scorpions and Bryan Adams weren't bad, but all in all... a thumbs down. Floyd was at their best when they were all together. No doubt about that.

Rating:
Summary: great stage, bad choice of musicians
Review: the stage in the video is great and the music is still great, but having O'Conner , Lauper, the Scorpians, and anyone else sing the music of Pink Floyd is a bad idea. I'm surprised that Waters's ego allowed someone else to sing a Floyd song. I would have given the video five stars if Roger had invited even one ex-band mate but that was his ego in the way again. Great stage, great music, bad choice of singers.

Rating:
Summary: A Great Masterpiece
Review: Roger Waters has demonstrated once again his ability to put on a spectacular show in such little time. And proves once again that he does not need the help of the so called Pink Floyd out there right now. In fact Roger is truly the one and only Pink. SHINE ON ROGER!

Rating:
Summary: Great New Verions of Old Classics
Review: Sinead O'Connor doing Mother is incredible.. as is the version of Hey You.. The whole damn concert was terrific too

Rating:
Summary: "Genius, Pure Genius!"
Review: I have been amazed with the whole pink floyd saga since the era when this video came out. It is Roger's most comprehensive look at The Wall. The meticulous detail that went into the whole project makes for one splendid work. The massive wall that is constructed is breathtaking, and when "The Trial" scene begins and the wall comes down it'll send chills up your spine. This truly is one of the finest works of art I have ever seen. It thus proves Roger truly is the mastermind behind the Floyd. It's a must have for the avid collecter, and I would also reccomend it to anyone interested in good music in general.

Rating:
Summary: Genius! Pure Genius!
Review: This tape is possibly my favorite video, I've watched it four times in the past three days, it's that good! Roger Waters and the cast put on an excellent show, especially the trial sequence. If you don't like Pink Floyd, nor do you understand the sick and twisted nature of Roger Waters, then I would say this video isn't for you. All through the concert there is the construction of a huge wall, and at the end there is the symbolic tearing down of it. It's a six-star concert all the way and you'll want to watch it again and again!

Rating:
Summary: It is a hell of a lot better than Pulse.
Review: Roger Waters put on the best show. It is great all except for Shaned O'Conner (I think that's how you spell her name) I'm not a fan . I liked it alot better than Pulse although Pink Floyd still puts on one hell of a show, Roger Waters puts on a better one. Anyway I give it four stars opps I mean five stars. It's my dream to go to a Roger Waters concert . Hopefully with Pink Floyd, but I doubt that will ever happen. I think you should buy it...it's worth the money.