Rating: 
Summary: what is the hell is this?
Review: I have listened to pink floyd ever since I was 9 years old and all I can say about this concert is that it was just to make some cash.I also think that cyndi lauper destroyed another brick in the wall part 2 by turning it into a pop song and we all know that bryan adams wasn't even supposed to be there.so to all the loyal pink floyd fans:DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME WITH THIS STUPID CONCERT AND JUST SEE THE ORIGINAL FILM,WHICH IS ALOT BETTER AND NONE OF THE SONGS ARE SCREWED UP BY IDIOTIC POP STARS!!!
Rating:
Summary: Just who the hell does he think he is?
Review: Roger Waters has an ego on him like no one else. They were right when they called him a megalomaniac!
Rating: 
Summary: super might be belittling! a great remake! purely waters!
Review: It's very hard to clam up ur feeling here;however, u have to realize that this is waters not floyd! please stop the comparisons! i personally think it's a great remake,well put! different!change is good! the instrumental solos r marvelously played with an extra touch! with the short time waters had to set it up! i think it's one of the best shows i have ever seen!with a nice finale! again it's waters so don't expect floyd! some people think waters is pink! in a way he is!the driving force!now he's solo! so accept him for what he is! as a pointer to all who have not seen him on stage, u don't know what ur missing! would really make u ponder who pink is?he's touring again so check him out!waters writing's definately unique unlike any other, where u'd see loads of effort put into his work!just right! as jeff beck said "waters' is a great director and song- writer" and u'll see that in berlin- the wall! check "amused to death"as well!
Rating: 
Summary: You are there!
Review: Puts perspective upon one of the many amazing events of our times. As a long-time 'listener' of Mr. Morrison and former purveyor of modern living through chemistry, the "Comfortably Numb" piece nearly sent me 'Jonesin'. I mean 'Moon Dance' was good, but....However, after a few 'rewinds', I thoroughly enjoyed Van and his gang of troubadours. A must see, gotta get it!
Rating:
Summary: I absolutely loved it.
Review: Having so many good artist participating just goes to prove how much Roger Waters and Pink Floyd music is loved.
Rating:
Summary: Excellent Concept!
Review: Look for all of you that don't know Roger Waters and his contributions to the band, you don't know anything about Roger. This was based on his hatred of the war, the cold war, and the war that took his father. If you truly love Floyd and Roger, you will find out everything there is to find out about the band and its history, and stop making uninformed decisions.
Rating:
Summary: I'm sorry but this sucks!!!
Review: Every song on this album sounds like total garbage and Roger should be ashamed he ever resurrected the Wall without Dave and co. Why the hell would Roger pick such stupid guest performers? Cyndi Lauper, Sinead, Van...come'on!If you really want a live Wall show go looking for videos from the original Wall tours. Many videos that were professionally recorded by the band themselves are out there. Depending on where you get it from, the picture quality will vary but it'll still be far more entertaining than this release.
Rating:
Summary: I was there, AWESOME!!!
Review: July 21st 1990. While spending a two year army tour in Germany, I was fortunate enough to make it to this concert. I would have to say that this concert was better in person than on video. Although the video was great.
Rating:
Summary: all good points
Review: although Floyd will never again be... Roger is still the greatest songwriter ever, and Dave is the greatest musician, This video is Rogers interpretation of something Dave and crew would see differently, but the concept was Rogers to begin with, and he did a fairly good job of portraying the feeling here. But musically it really, really needed Dave, Nick, and Rick!!!!!!
Rating: 
Summary: Better casting possible...
Review: I know Floyd better than anyone I personally know. While Roger does great work, some of the other singers mess this up. Comfortably Numb was destroyed, in my mind, by Van M. Brian Adams, however, kicks with What Shall We Do Now? (AKA Empty Spaces). Maybe if Numb was not butchered, I would give this a 4.5 rating.
| 
