The Scarlet Letter

Rating:
Summary: Wonderful film
Review: The Scarlett Letter has a little something for everyone. I am a longtime fan of Gary Oldman and as usual his portrayal of Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale was outstanding. Although I haven't historically been a huge fan of Demi Moore, I thought that she did an excellent performance as well. While I have seen other criticisms that it did not adhere closely to the novel, I found that to be a plus because you could read so many things into this movie such as understanding how the conflict between the settlers and natives may have been largely a communication issue. You also get what I feel to be a good understanding of the rigidity of the culture of those times which I am sure was largely the original intent of Hawthorne's novel. Overall, a great movie and one of insight to many aspects of human nature.

Rating:
Summary: If youre studying for a test don't watch this film to review
Review: I feel sick to my stomach!!!
and i really like this cast (Oldman, Moore, Duvall)... the actors have my respect
But this film... I am almost speechless. I would not say that the book The Scarlett Letter is my favorite, however it is a classic and therefore must be respected... right?
I am aparently wrong. This movie is a mockery of what Hawthorne intended (that can be easily seen - just from the movie's tag line) and insults the art of page to screen adaptation... this movie does deserve one star purely b/c it made me laugh... Pearl is narrating??? Does this even take place during the same period of time??? Who is that slave woman???
It could be that I am confused but I just finished the book

Rating:
Summary: The Worst Film Ever?
Review: I am teaching this book for A Level and sh owed the video to the class. They were helpless with laughter in places!

The film bears only a slender resemblance to the novel, and as for Demi Moore! Who told the girl she could act?

Even the usually good Robert Duvall was rubbish, although the way his character had been re-written was completely different to the book. And Gary Oldman must surely regret appearing in such tripe.

Considering that HAwthorne is a well-respected American writer, I am surprised Hollywood made such a pig's ear of one of his novels.

Carolyn Devine

Rating:
Summary: Jealous of Demi
Review: Although this movie did get some bad reviews, I honestly enjoyed it and have watched it many times. Although I am not a great fan of Demi Moore, I must say she did a fantastic job portraying Hester Prynne. It was probably a rare occurrence during the Puritan days that women were so head strong and rebellious that it made me cheer her on! Robert Duvall played her husband who was half insane after being captured and tortured by the Indians, I thought he also gave a great performance. And finally, ahhh what can I say about Gary Oldman? He is definetly one of my favorite actors and I would watch anything he is in. His vulnerability, angst and love for Hester was perfectly acted by this incredible talented person. I am not sure if the director of this movie intended to use symbolism in the story, but I gather the cardinal represented lust, something forbidden? And my last point is my jealousy of Demi. Jealous of her being able to act with Gary Oldman and the barn scene! Seriously, this is a really good movie and worth seeing.

Rating:
Summary: Bad fit for Demi Moore
Review: I recently watched this movie, hoping to see a quality rendition of Hawthorne's classic novel, but I was disappointed with Moore's performance. I'm used to seeing Moore in action roles such as G.I. Jane and Charlie's Angels II, so it just didn't see like a good fit for her to be playing a stuffy Puritan. I couldn't take her role seriously in the Scarlett Letter, particularly with her accent. I just about gagged in one scene where she says, "Reverend Dimmesdale, I must apologize for my forthrighteousness on Sabbath last..." Um, does that mean, "I'm sorry I was so blunt last Sunday"?

This movie would be so much better to watch with a different acress.

Rating:
Summary: What a Waste of My TIME!!
Review: This movie was absolutely horrible. There's not a better word to describe this so call movie. There are many problems with this film.
Let's start with the acting. Demi Moore has no business acting! She couldn't act to save her Life. The others are ok, but Moore being the main character absolutely ruined the film. Why can't these Hollywood people get a real actress instead of a celebrity personality is beyond me.
Second, the plot was so idiotic. The book actually has meaning, and contrary to other people beliefs, this is an extremely profound book. This film's plot lacks any meaning or nuances.
To Butcher a classis like this is unforgivable. Should have been -5 stars
P.S. Demi Moore needs acting lessons.