Rating: 
Summary: It is a good movie about the south's point of view but...
Review: Gone With the Wind is a classical movie of the 1939's, the theme is about of the civilization of the south and their peaceful life style. A life of a rural plantation life that is trying to survive and protect their culture against the evils of the industrial revolution and enjoy life of luxury without the pollution of the industrial machines and their riff raffs; the history and the view that the south portrays in this movie is all about what they gained and lost because of the civil war and reconstruction. Of course the portrayal is not a 100% historically accurate and the movie downplay to mention too much about the cruelty of slavery and how the racial discrimination, which was lowly presented (lets be serious 1939, lack of cultural understanding makes sense not many would dare to talk about it in the silver screen), was view by the free blacks and slaves of the south that had to endure for many years before the idea of freedom was accepted and before the civil rights movements, but yes it is there, not bad neither nice. One of the problems with the movie if that it focus on the lost of the glorious south but doesn't mention or fully explains the consequences of such life style, the price of slavery and plantation life and how it happened or how all the issue of slavery and anti-slavery began; it lacks explanation of slavery, the good and the bad sides of it (when you study history you notice this things) to fully educate the public, that the issue of slavery is a human issue and that the southerners and the northerners are guilty of it because they were too human and too ignorant of our modern views (they cannot be blamed but that is not justification for anyone), maybe is me but I love historical accuracy in movies. This movie is a good (but not the best) portrayal of the south's point of view, it will differs with the north's or with any ones but given the understandings of how the southerners view slavery, not because of arrogance or ignorance but because of the lack of cultural understanding and modern enlightenment. For anyone who wants to know more about slavery one should read "The Wages of Whiteness" by David R. Roediger to know why white southerners (and also northerners, no one is innocent) lacked common sense about slavery and the faults of their ancestors and first settlers, a deeper understanding of white identity and the disasters that followed by 'psychological wage', also there is a lack of understanding of the house servants and their important central role in plantation life which is not fully explained in the movie, their role are important that is why I recommend reading "Ar'n't I a Woman?" by Deborah Gray White and read the chapter about Mammies. I don't blame the south's slavery issue; one who studies the past must not blame but understand without pointing the finger; the issue of slavery was not the south's problem but also an issue of the north, it was a national issue which is not view or explain in the movie. I think is time to look hard and beyond the lines and words and find the issue of slavery was not a state or individual or social fault but a historical and cultural issue waiting to become a ugly issue in American history but there are also interesting things one can learn about slavery and the human will if is willing to open and carefully look. The movie is a good tool to understand the south's life style and what they were trying to protect, the Jeffersonian ideals of a agricultural economy and private property, but the explanation is only half backed, for those who want to learn more look at these books that I mentioned.
Rating: 
Summary: Defending a Period Piece
Review: GWTW truly is an amazing film that remains among the greatest American films to date, vividly depicting a time of great change from the southern perspective. This film has been widely citicized for failing to depict slavery in an accurate manner; for largely ignoring the perspective of the slaves, the brutality of the master/slave relationship, and for leaving the charcters of the slaves either undeveloped or as very simple. I would be more inclined to say that GWTW is a period piece that develops a perspective of the "Old South" that is part of an idealized historical memory as opposed to being true to history. I would say that the film is accurate at least in the sense that it showed how the role of the slaves changed little after the war. It should be remembered that when this film was made the roles of slaves were stereotyped, and that people weren't watching the film for the accuracy of race relations. I am not trying to pardon the obvious innacuracies of the film, nor am I saying that the viewer should ignore these things, but I am saying that if you dwell on the film's fallacies you will be missing out in a great piece of American cinematic history.
Rating: 
Summary: Find a nice comfy couch in front of a good tv and get ready!
Review: I deem this, the original soap opera, man it has EVERYTHING! Pampered Princess, doomed love affair, tragedy after tragedy, after tragedy, even a spineless jellyfish i.e. Ashley. There are so many reasons to watch this film; Some of the best character development ever, gorgeous sets and scenery, the costuming is wonderful as well. And so many memorable lines, most people know them even if they haven't seen the movie! And nobody can deliver an icy stare the way Vivian/Scarlett can! Watch it once, and you'll know why it's considered one of, if not the BEST film of all time!
Rating:
Summary: Margaret Mitchell . . . the jewel of Georgia
Review: The effort that went into all aspects of this movie is astounding and although it is over 60 years old this movie continues to be one of my favorite movies. I don't know of any story that can even come close to Gone with the Wind and the video was not a disappointment at all. Oscar award winning Vivien Leigh delivers a such a wonderful performance and Clark Gable plays his cool charming self. The costumes are wonderful and the scenery unbelievable. Watch this great classic... but read the book first. :)
Rating:
Summary: One of the greatest movies!
Review: I am 13 years old and enjoyed this movie very much! It is a classic romance and drama. I would have prefered a better ending, such as in "Scarlett". (GWTW was better than Scarlett by the way.)But I found this movie very interesting, and the southern belle dresses are adorable! I decided to give it five stars because it is well worth the aprox. 4 hrs.
Rating:
Summary: Fantastic
Review: I've loved this movie for as long as I could appreciate it and still believe it is one of the best movies of all time. Vivien Leigh portrays Scarlett flawlessly- just the right blend of volatility, beauty, and vulnerability. Clark Gable is dashing and perfect for the role of Rhett. The chemistry between him and Vivian is incredible. For the hopeless romantic, this is the movie to see! The only objection is the ending; it seems to leave many things unfinished and unsaid. Luckily, Alexandra Ripley does a magnificent sequel that ties up everything- I won't give away the ending in case you haven't read it! But please do!
Rating:
Summary: Classic romance!!!
Review: The most classic romantic story ever!! I love this movie from beginning to end... every single minute of this extremely long movie. Since I first saw it as a teenager, I've been watching it at least once a year. I absolutely love it! Why? I can't quite explain. Scarlet is nothing more than a spoiled brat, but I can't help cheering for her at every frame. Rhett deserves so much better, though he was not always the perfect gentleman you find at the end of the movie, but I still want to watch them get together and see all the fireworks! This is about a time of change... it's not about slavery, like many others believe. If you can get past that difficult subject and look at the movie as it was meant to be... a tale of two people, who belong together... but their personalities, desires, and ideals of what is proper continues to tear them apart. Then when it looks like they will finally be happy... an unthinkable act will again pull them from each other.
Rating:
Summary: Simply a Classic!
Review: GWTW is the epitome of the film world. It encompasses legendary actors and actresses, a timeless historical rendition of Civil War times, lavish sets, extraordinary costumes, and it is based on a best-seller novel. The hunt for an actress to play Scarlett captured world-wide attention and it finally went to the most perfect woman-- Vivien Leigh. Overall, the film is a masterpiece that will never be topped. Many have suggested that Titanic is comparable . . . but even that falls short. Many of criticized GWTW for being one-sided and racist. However, many of those who say this fail to realize that this film was released in 1939. On a whole, racism and discrimination were still rampant in those days. I firmly believe, though, that the film stays away from unnecessary words or insinuations. True, the film does stay true to the novel and depicts slavery as more as a friendly insitutition. In many cases, slavery was not friendly, but rather a punishing and horrific thing bestowed onto Africans. GWTW merely depicts those few who did feel familial to their owners. Though this film does span over many hours, it is intriguing and involving. I have watched this film numerous of times, in and out of the theater. Everytime I watch it, I cry and I laugh. GWTW's characters are legendary and they stay with you for longer than the film lasts. I HIGHLY recommend this film.
Rating:
Summary: One of the Greatest Movies Ever Made!
Review: This must be one of the best movies ever made, in the best year Hollywood ever had. Gone With the Wind is simply superb! It has some of the best acting ever placed on film. Vivien Leigh is the perfect chioce for Scarlett, the Southern Bell who has never experienced any pain worse than a sunburn! And Clark Gable is wonderful as Rhett Butler, the only man Scarlett ever truely loves. Many of the hardships of the Civil War, and duties of women during this trying time. This is the story of a women's coming to terms with life and maturing, and the war that forced her to do so. This is simply a wonderful movie, if you simply "...give a damn!"
Rating:
Summary: Words Cannot Describe
Review: I have loved this movie since I can remember. Vivien Leigh gives an absolutely outstanding performance as Scarlett O'Hara. Yes, she's selfish, conceited, and at times cruel, but she had such a determination and strength that at least a little bit of all of us, whether we realize it or not, is somewhat fond of her. Then we have Clark Gable, who was stolen of an Oscar, as Rhett Butler, the witty, sharp man who is Scarlett's perfect match. Brilliant performance. Olivia de Haviland is sweet and shy and wonderful as Melanie, and Leslie Howard does a great job as Ashley. Everyone in this movie gives their souls into their characters, and the result is a marvelous piece of cinema. Definitely one of my favorite movies of all time. Though it is lengthy, not a minute is boring. 10+ stars. As for those complaining that it's racist: Whether you want to admit it or not, slavery happened. This movie is told from the South's point of view, and the South WAS racist. It did happen. So, next time you have four hours to kill, grab some popcorn, and watch Gone with the Wind. Enjoy!
|
