<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: One out of three ain't.........too bad
Review: After I read the other glowing reviews on here I had to own this video. HOWEVER, after watching the three shorts on bluegrass and life in the '60s, I was disappointed, overall. The first video of Mr. Holcomb and the eastern KY country life painted what you would expect of Appalachian folks....poorly clothed, poorly educated, great banjo and guitar pickers. Being from KY, we are a little touchy on the stereotypical overall-clad, cigarette-smoking portrayal of our people. There were some high spots on the first short, though. The playing of Mr. Holcomb on his front porch is quite impressive, the views of the landscape are fetching, and they do, in fact, make you want to come home to these Ky mountains. The second short, on Dillard Chandler, was a disappointment. The portions that show his dwelling and his solo interpretations of the mountain music without any instrumentation are impressive, but when we follow him into town to get a bite to eat and pursue women.....a little off topic and disturbing. What did those scenes have to do with his music? The third short, on the two Carters, Maybelle and Sara, was quite good. We get a nice history on the Carters and get to hear the girls pick and sing three or four tunes. This one was well-done and rather delightful, if you are into the history and the nostalgia of where some of this music came from. Overall, I give it two stars, primarily on the weakness of the second short.
Rating: 
Summary: best film i ever seen about the early developement of bluegr
Review: I heard about this video in "bluegrass unlimited" where it was advertised. A friend brought it home from a visit to the states, and I borrowed it and kept it for ½ year. I saw it twice in 14 days and kept coming back for more wiewings. I knew that I had to have it. It is a must for everyone who loves bluegrass and old time music.
Rating:
Summary: A Journey into the Past, into the future, music people wow
Review: I've seen this about 5 times since it came out in the late 1960sd, all three viedos. I've even dined with the film maker and heard a couple of the people in it perform live. BUY THIS, OWN THIS, PLAY THIS, REMEMBER THIS. This is now 40 years old, and it shows old people hanging on to culture that would have died had it not been for the folk revival and people like John Cohen who made these films. There are actually three films here: one on Roscoe Holcomb the geat banjo, harmonica, and guitar player and singer, one on Dillard Chandler, a ballad singer, and one a reunion of the Maybelle and Sarah Carter. The films about Holcomb and Dillard splice in scenes of their real life working, not having work, of the hard times that hit the coal fields and the mountains in Kennedy's America. It also speaks of a life probably gone, that some of us don't miss because of its miseries, but is part of our struggle. The log shack with newspapers on the wall, the white holy roller church scenes that remind me of haitian half-voodo, half Afro-Christians, playing music on the front porch while someone buck dances. But the world is creeping in. The Roscoe's grandchild is trying to do the Chubby Checker's twist to Roscoe's banjo playing. Dillard tries to sing his balleds in a beer parlor but they want the Nashville Juke Box honky tonk, we do see Bill Monroe and the gang on the steps of the Hazard County city hall--and what did this have to do with the bloody strikes asnd union wars going on then!!!!!--preserving part of this. However, this is not bluegrass, but prebluegrass, in Chandler's case really pre pre bluegrass, you see him and his peers singing songs that belong in the 14, 15, or 16 centuries.
This is real music performed in the real world by real people. Even if you don't like old time country music, this is worth the money for what it shows about a community and a world in struggle. Even if this is foreign to you, this is the real America many of our grandparents and great grand parents lived in. The struggle is where the music comes from. More on the Carters in a separate note.
Rating:
Summary: A Journey into the Past, into the future, music people wow
Review: I've seen this about 5 times since it came out in the late 1960sd, all three viedos. I've even dined with the film maker and hear a couple of the people in it perform live. BUY THIS, OWN THIS, PLAY THIS, REMEMBER THIS. This is now 40 years old, and it shows old people hanging on to culture that would have died had it not been for the folk revival and people like John Cohen who made these films. There are actually three one on Roscoe Holcolb the geat banjo, harmonica, and guitar player and singer, one on Chandler Dillar, a ballad singer, and one a reunion of the Maybelle and Sarah Carter. Tjhe films about Holcomb and Dillar splice in scenes of their real life working, not having work, of the hard times that hit the coal fields and the mountains in Kennedy's america, ofa life probably gone, that some of us don't miss because of its miseries, but is part of our struggle. The log shack with newspapers on the wall, the white holy roller church scenes that remind me of haitian half-voodo, half Afro-Christians, oplaying music on the front porch while someone buck dances. But the world is creeping in. The Roscoe's grandchild is trying to do the Chubby Checker's twist to his banjar playing. Dillard tries to sing his ballets ina beer parlor but they want the Nashville Juke Box honky tonk, we do see Bill Monroe and the gang on the steps of the Hazard County city hall--and what did this have to do with the bloody strikes asnd union wars going on then!!!!!--preserving part of this. However, this is not bluegrass, but prebluegrass, in Chandler's case really pre pre bluegrass, you see him and his peers singing songs that belong in the 14, 15, or 16 centuries.
This is real music performed in the real world by real people. Even if you dont like old time country music, this is worth the money for what it shows about a community and a world in struggle. Even if this is foreign to you, this is the real America many of our grandparents and great grand parents lived in. The struggle is where the music comes from. More on the carters in a separate note.
Rating:
Summary: A Journey into the Past, into the future, music people wow
Review: I've seen this about 5 times since it came out in the late 1960sd, all three viedos. I've even dined with the film maker and heard a couple of the people in it perform live. BUY THIS, OWN THIS, PLAY THIS, REMEMBER THIS. This is now 40 years old, and it shows old people hanging on to culture that would have died had it not been for the folk revival and people like John Cohen who made these films. There are actually three films here: one on Roscoe Holcomb the geat banjo, harmonica, and guitar player and singer, one on Dillard Chandler, a ballad singer, and one a reunion of the Maybelle and Sarah Carter. The films about Holcomb and Dillard splice in scenes of their real life working, not having work, of the hard times that hit the coal fields and the mountains in Kennedy's America. It also speaks of a life probably gone, that some of us don't miss because of its miseries, but is part of our struggle. The log shack with newspapers on the wall, the white holy roller church scenes that remind me of haitian half-voodo, half Afro-Christians, playing music on the front porch while someone buck dances. But the world is creeping in. The Roscoe's grandchild is trying to do the Chubby Checker's twist to Roscoe's banjo playing. Dillard tries to sing his balleds in a beer parlor but they want the Nashville Juke Box honky tonk, we do see Bill Monroe and the gang on the steps of the Hazard County city hall--and what did this have to do with the bloody strikes asnd union wars going on then!!!!!--preserving part of this. However, this is not bluegrass, but prebluegrass, in Chandler's case really pre pre bluegrass, you see him and his peers singing songs that belong in the 14, 15, or 16 centuries.
This is real music performed in the real world by real people. Even if you don't like old time country music, this is worth the money for what it shows about a community and a world in struggle. Even if this is foreign to you, this is the real America many of our grandparents and great grand parents lived in. The struggle is where the music comes from. More on the Carters in a separate note.
Rating:
Summary: sara and maybelle and maybelle and sara wow
Review: This is a set of three films, one on dillar chandler, one on Roscoe Holcomb, and the last a reunion in Virginia of Maybelle and Sara Carter, two sisters in law who were the real musical stars of the carter family. They are drawn together again after starting out in the late 20s with the late AOP.
They play 3 or 4 songs, and you hear more of their early work. You seem them relating together musically, personally. If you are into the history, the music the culture, even if it is only lately with the new books on the Carters or on Ralph Peer, this is interesing, real people real expression. What an intimate thing playing music is after decades. Shiot in the early 1960s, you see the decade or two they had spent apart being covered over. You see delight, but also professionalism. They aren't back porch entertainers but folks who sold millions of records who ranged from New York City to Mexico perfoprming.
I was really thrilled to see Maybelle playing not just the regular carter style, but doing The Cannon Ball, a Blues orinted finger pick tune that she still smoked.
This video is well worth about 10 times the price.
Rating:
Summary: sara and maybelle and maybelle and sara wow
Review: This is a set of three films, one on Dillard Chandler, one on Roscoe Holcomb, and the last a reunion in Virginia of Maybelle and Sara Carter, two sisters in law and cousins as well who were the musical stars of the Original Carter Family. They are drawn together again after starting out in the late 20s with the late A.P. and separating when Sara went off to live in Northern California with her second husband. They play 3 or 4 songs, and you hear more of their early work. You seem them relating together musically, personally. If you are into the history, the music the culture, even if it is only lately with the new books on the Carters or on Ralph Peer, this is interesing, real people real expression. What an intimate thing playing music is after decades. Shot in the early 1960s, you see the decade or two they had spent apart being covered over. You see delight, but also professionalism. They aren't back porch entertainers but folks who sold millions of records who ranged from New York City to Mexico perfoprming. In fact, both Maybelle and Sara were known as perfectionists in the studio. In Maybelle's part this helped her become the person who really got Chet Atkins into the paying side of country music when she hired him. No one else but Maybelle understood and went along with Chester's desires to redo every take until it was gotten right, or to rerecord a 30 minutes radio program (the only way to do it before tape was available) because of one wrong note. I was really thrilled to see Maybelle playing not just the regular Carter style, but doing The Cannon Ball, a Blues orinted finger picked tune that she still smoked.
This video is well worth about 10 times the price.
<< 1 >>
|
