Rating: 
Summary: save ur money 4 the next '6 DISC SET'
Review: actually im just trying to layout an alternatives for you guys. to make it clearer to you all,this is NOT G.LUCAS DEFINITIVE OR PREFERED DVD SET'.all together there're 3 version of this movies:the originals(which lucas stated wont be release at all),the special edition(the 1 in display now and at the time of their rerelease,none of the crew visualise them as a DVD format)& the deluxe/director/ultimate edition{or whatever it will call} which added more redos featuring brief footage of Hayden,Portman & etc. into these favorite movies.obviously trying to put them(these movies)on the same league with the prequels in terms of actors and quality(special effects).So for u guys who've waited so long,this SE version is really the cure. as for me,because i have a whole list of movies to buy and trying to get a lot sense of value from my money..I'll wait for the next one.trying not to buy the same thing twice(lord of the rings is a different matter,u know what i mean)and in the meantime,i just watch this series from my VCR. PS:4 stars because i love these 3 movies best.
Rating: 
Summary: Great films, sleazy merchandising tactics
Review: This is the Star Wars Special Editions on DVD. Unlike typical Director's Cuts, the Special Editions include many altered original scenes rather than merely additional footage. In other words, these are not the original A New Hope, Empire Strikes Back, or Return of the Jedi, although this is intentionally non-obvious from the packaging and marketing.The original three Star Wars films are great. This marketing campaign is not. It is worth noting that aside from a few rare laserdiscs, Lucas has intentionally refused to release the original films in any permanent form. His attempts to pass off this DVD set as the original is vile enough, but also merely assures in a few years that he will likely release an 'original' Star Wars DVD set for another round of gouging. Be advised.
Rating: 
Summary: George Lucas doesn't care about our memories
Review: There's a lot of nonsense here about George Lucas's "right" to say which version we should buy, or "It's ok that the Special Editions are the only ones released because..". None of us, I'm sure, could care less that G.Lucas tinkers with his films, as long as we have the option of seeing the originals too. The anger being directed at this release is justified insofar as it is not simply because it is the SE versions, but because we are told that this will be the ONLY version he will ever release again. Had the Originals been available I would have bought both (as a Star Wars fan from day 1) but in the absence of the originals, I won't touch the SE versions ever again (I have them on Laserdisc, once is enough). The alleged 'deterioration' of the original film negatives as a defence for Lucas' claims is preposterous - 95% of the SE versions are restored from these same film elements, do you really believe that the remaining portion is the only part affected, or isn't worth saving? THX certified transfers to Laserdisc were done as recently as 1993-95, there is no fundamental problem with the original negatives. Changes were made to narrative & dialogue also, will he claim the original audio was lost too? These are NOT the versions which won the awards. These are NOT the versions that I remember seeing as a child. These are NOT the versions I & millions of others spent a significant chunk of our childhoods recreating with toys that contributed to Mr. Lucas bank balance. What George Lucas seems oblivious to, are the reasons people buy movies on home formats like DVD. Most of us have already seen a movie before we buy it on DVD - the DVD is bought so we can 're-experience' what we saw in the theatre. It's a living souvenir.
I, & millions of others, saw these films from 1977-1983. I want the souvenir from that era, & so do they. By all means George, digitally alter your films. Insert Homer Simpson as the Emperor, and replace every Stormtrooper with Ewoks for all I care - but end the arrogance and the endless profiteering from your (hitherto) loyal lifelong fans and GIVE US THE ORIGINAL VERSIONS TOO.
Rating: 
Summary: It's like this...
Review: Picture the original trilogy as a wonderfully rich and moist, homemade chocolate cake with sweet homemade frosting; like mom used to make. (As for me, I've been moved out of the house for quite a while now, so I don't enjoy that much anymore.)
Now... imagine the enhanced trilogy as a cheap off-brand cake mix. Yes it is STILL cake, and you can STILL eat it. But there's a part you(taste buds) that is left feeling unsatisfied and dissapointed because what you just experienced is definitely not what you remember or hoped for. The enhanced versions are dissapointing, yet when you look at all the crappy movies being made these days, the new trilogy still beats many of them. As for original StarWars fans, this enhanced trilogy just wont cut it.
For one, the originals were perfect just the way they were. Secondly, among other misfortunes, the added animations were HORRIBLE- they looked like cartoons. ex. in A New Hope -Han walking/talking with giant 'blob-o-graphics'. Yeah, I know Lucas wanted that scene, but it was done very badly. I'll be waiting impatiently for the originals (I can dream can't I...) thanks for reading -Rob
Rating: 
Summary: CHOICE, GEORGE, PLEASE!
Review: Listen, I need the original trilogy. I've had it. Release both. Spielberg did it, Universal did it, why can't Lucas do it? I mean I've seen two movies on one disc. Come, on. This is bogus. Luc-*ss, I hate you. And God forbid, hire a good screenwriter and Irvin Kershner for Episode III. I guess it's too late now. I'll never again see "Star Wars" "The Empire Strikes Back" or "Return of the Jedi" the way I did in the 70's and 80's. I better kiss it good-bye, thanks to you, Luc-*ss.
Rating:
Summary: What is everyone whining about?
Review: Star Wars episodes 4 through 6 are finally going to be released on DVD. Everyone is acting like little sissies becuase these are the special editions? When I watch the original versions I can't tell much difference between them and the special editions, except for a cleaner picture and a tiny bit of new music. If you don't like it then stick to your old crappy VHS movies. I've been waiting for these to come out on DVD for years and i'll be happy to buy this nice set. And anyone that doesn't like episodes 1 and 2 need to be shot. Episodes 1 and 2 were excellent movies, the best movies of any kind to come out in the last 10 years. Stop your whining little b@tches and get a life.
Rating:
Summary: Problems with the Star Wars DVD
Review: From what we've been told by StarWars.Com this DVD will be of the 1997 special edition versions. The problems with this release of StarWars on DVD is that it contains only the special edition of the film, and it is a flawed version at best.
I will buy this DVD set, but I am not happy about it. When I saw the special editions of the films in 1997 I was very unhappy with StarWars 4 (A New Hope), (...). I was expecting more from the special edition too. Knowing way too much about the films missing footage, I was disapointed that there wasn't any of the cut sceens with Luke and Biggs at the start of the film.
Empire Stikes Back changes were okay, but I would have liked to seen the Wampa sceen inside of the Rebal base. I would have also liked to have seen how C3PO got torn apart.
Return's only major changes were at the end of the film. The edition of celebrations across the galaxy was goofy.
To tell the truth, I'd to see this DVD set contain 3 versions of the films. The un-modified editions, the 1997 editions and a new mix that fixes the problems with a Star Wars 4 and maybe adds a few new sceens here and there. My guess is that there will be a version on DVD, or HD-DVD, like this in the future and I will be suckered into buying it too.
Rating:
Summary: Best DVD's Ever
Review: When the Star Wars trilogy arrives on DVD on September 21, the digitally remastered and restored films will be accompanied by over 10 hours of bonus material that goes inside the making of these classic movies.
Each film resides on its own disc, with sharp, pristene imagery restored and remastered by Lowry Digital Images, and the rich sound experience of the saga presented in Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround EX. The films also include new commentary tracks, featuring insights from George Lucas, director Irvin Kershner, actress Carrie Fisher, sound designer Ben Burtt, and Industrial Light & Magic's Dennis Muren. The fourth disc is packed with bonus material, the most notable being Empire of Dreams: The Story of the Star Wars Trilogy. This two-and-a-half hour documentary traces the evolution of the saga, from a low-budget labor-of-love space saga to the movie phenomenon that defied the odds and reinvented the rules. This comprehensive documentary features all new interviews with George Lucas and more than 40 members of the cast and crew from the original trilogy, as well as a host of filmmakers and media personalities. Empire of Dreams includes some never-before-seen behind-the-scenes footage from the making of the three films. Other material on the fourth disc includes: Episode III Behind the Scenes Preview: The Return of Darth Vader: Finally, Star Wars: Episode III will reveal just how Anakin Skywalker became Darth Vader, the most iconic villain in film history. In this exclusive preview, George Lucas discusses Anakin's descent, with a first look at the new Vader costume forged for Episode III. Also, experience how Hayden Christensen and Ewan McGregor have prepared for the epic lightsaber battle that has been anticipated for more than two decades: the climactic showdown between Anakin and Obi-Wan Kenobi. The Birth of the Lightsaber: Its unforgettable hum and scintillating glow are instantly recognizable around the world. Now, viewers will discover the origins of this elegant weapon from a more civilized age in this documentary devoted to the lightsaber. The Characters of Star Wars: An in-depth look at how favorite characters came to be, featuring rare concept art, behind-the-scenes footage and interviews with George Lucas and the cast and crew who shaped the screen's favorite heroes. The Force Is With Them: The Legacy of Star Wars: Star Wars opened up a galaxy of possibilities to a generation of filmmakers and creative talents. Hear from some of the most notable filmmakers of our time about how influential the Star Wars movies have been to their lives. Star Wars Battlefront Trailer and Playable Demo: The fourth disc will offer a trailer featuring an exciting look at the upcoming Star Wars Battlefront video game from LucasArts, along with a special demo for Xbox users that lets players fight the Battle of Endor as a Rebel or Imperial soldier and drive AT-STs, ride speeder bikes and use different weapons to lead their side to victory. The full version of Star Wars Battlefront will also be released Sept. 21 for the PlayStation 2, Xbox, and PC. Star Wars: Episode III Making the Game Preview: Video-game players will be able to experience the stunning Jedi action of Episode III themselves in the new Star Wars: Episode III game, due out in Spring 2005 for the PlayStation 2 and Xbox. This special feature shows how game developers at LucasArts worked behind-the-scenes and on the set to create the most authentic Jedi experience ever. Original Trailers and TV Spots: The original theatrical teaser, launch and re-release trailers for each film, plus TV spots, are featured on the DVD. Never-Before-Seen Production Gallery: Delve into an unseen corners of the Lucasfilm Archives with exclusive photos from the making of the trilogy, with hundreds of rare behind-the-scene images. Posters and Print Campaigns: The original releases of the Star Wars films came at a time when international campaigns produced a wealth of intriguing, alternative poster art. Explore a collection of theatrical posters from around the world. Exclusive DVD-ROM Content: The Star Wars Trilogy DVDs are keys that unlock exclusive content available only through a special DVD-ROM website.
Rating:
Summary: Nice, but wait for the Star Wars Saga DVD set
Review: I fail to understand Lucas' motivations for releasing these on DVD now, with no doubt a year to go on the full Star Wars Saga DVD set. Unless it's all about marketing, smooching the fans' boohineys by dropping this in their midst with a cleverly placed preview of his upcoming theatrical release of Episode III. The smart thing would have been to release the original theatrical versions of these now and the full Saga next year. Lord knows, I'd certainly buy both if that were the case. But, since it isn't I guess I'll be waiting one more year...
Rating:
Summary: Great Movies, Great Memories, Know-it-all criticisms
Review: These movies are spectacular. Everyone knows they are. Many people a writing reviews criticizing Lucas, and there are other forums to do that. What's worse, they're criticizing him before the entire storyline is finished. For now, watch the movies, enjoy the adventure, and stop whining.
| 
