Rating: 
Summary: The Only Review that Matters
Review: Alright whats the problem. Episode I was a great Star Wars movie. By itself though it would get 3 stars. The critics talk about the acting in the movie and how it was awful, but what do you expect. Jake Loyd who was Anakin acted like a kid, which is what he was supposed to be! His acting is just fine. If they had the kid from The Sixth Sense playing Anakin I think that the acting would be overdramatic and a bit silly. The jedi were just fine in their acting too! They weren't all loud and crazy, which is good since it would be weird having Jedi act as if they were some superhereo on an ego trip. They acted as if they were under control and in charge of their emotions. Thats how Jedi are supposed to act! Jar Jar is fine once you see the movie at least 4 times. It is hard to understand what he is saying some of the time. When the next two episodes are made all of the critics will watch all 6 movies and realize that Episode I is a great beginning. I am a TRUE Star Wars fan and this movie had Star Wras written all over it! I can't wait for Episode II. Oh yeah, the special effects, especially the light saber battle are spectacular. But enough of me. Go see it and you be the judge. And remeber just enjoy the movie, don't ruin the experiance by trying to pick it apart. May The Force Be With You!
Rating: 
Summary: A Star Wars flick...sort of...
Review: Alright, if you really dig the Star Wars films, you've probably already seen this one. If you have not, but have seen the originals, then I have these words for you: It's just not the same. Between the making of Jedi and Phantom Menace, Lucas lost something (I personally think it's his mind). He just isn't as good a story teller. The places we visit in the film (Naboo, Tatooine, and Coruscant) are simply not as richly described by elements of the film as they are in the first three films. Lucas basically leaves it to a few wide shots to show us what Coruscant is like, and obviously uses our knowledge about Tatooine from the original films as a crutch, an excuse not to explore the desert planet more fully in this one. Naboo is explored, but the annoyance factor of Jar Jar Binks keeps the enjoyment of even those scenes which really could have made the movie great at a low level. All in all, it could have been much better. I hope they do better with the next one.
Rating: 
Summary: sweetnass
Review: Alright..this movie is great. It lacks some essential star wars things like a classic star battle and such but it has one unbeatable thing. The lightsaber fight with Darth Maul, obi wan and qui gon. If you haven't seen it you must. The rest of the movie is good as well but the lightsaber fight is just...WOW!
Rating:
Summary: Superb production values and an entertaining story
Review: Although Episode 1 has been frequently put down, it compares favorably to the original Star Wars episodes (4-6). The Phantom Menace manages to couch victory for the bad guy (Darth Sidious who maneuvers Senator Palpatine into power) within a story which provides a superficial victory for the good guys. Unlike the original Star Wars movies, Episode 1 has several storylines running in parallel, and not all is what it appears on the surface. It was unfortunate enough to be come at the end of 17 years of expectations of millions of fans. On its own merits it combines a fast-paced adventure with stunningly original scenes, settings, and characters. The podrace is a terrific mixture of sight and sound, and the final duel with Darth Maul is beautifully choreographed and executed. While Jar Jar Binks' antics are jarringly childish against the backdrop of the rest of the movie, he's only a minor annoyance for most, and younger kids find him entertaining.The DVD itself is loaded with extras, including a thorough behind-the-scenes documentary which is worth seeing more than once just to get an idea of the work that went into the movie. The audio commentary is interesting, but not the best I've heard.
Rating:
Summary: As Entertaining As Star Wars Ever Was, But Still Lacking
Review: Although I don't share the "this movie sucks" opinion that others share, I must say "Episode 1" lived up to my expectations of a movie coming out of my favorite triology of films in the history of filmmaking. Well what can I say, its got the reflecting light of the original trilogy, its got fun and fast action scenes. Killer special effects. But the character development is a lil poor (but what does that matter anyway). Overall, a fun entertaining experience as long as people stop comparing it to the original "Star Wars" and the better sci-fi release in 1999 "The Matrix".
Rating:
Summary: A good place to start
Review: Although I haven't seen the original Star Wars movie in a while, I think this story fits nicely into the beginning. My only complaint as to it's beginnings is it still doesn't tell us how and when the Jedi academy came into being. That I would have liked to know...but...oh well. Episode One basically begins to show the fall of the trade routes and the rise of the Dark Lord, whom we know will become Anakin's 'Dark Side' mentor. And Anakin will, of course, be coaxed into the dark side and become Darth Vader. Right now, Anakin is a cute little boy, innocent and forthright. He wins a Pod race for the Jedi protecting the princess whom will become Anakin's lover/wife and give birth to Princess Lea and Luke Skywalker. The actress who plays this role (The Princess) seemed a bit stiff to me. I hope her role in the future movies relaxes a bit and falls into place. The movie was exciting and loaded with CGI shots...maybe too many shots. One of the main characters, Jar Jar Binks, is completely CGI and I found that a little disconcerting. With today's make up possibilities and blue screens, I believe an actor could've handled that role (I mean, look at Planet of the Apes!). Also, I have to wonder when --- or if --- we'll see an early Han Solo or Chewie. Although these characters didn't come into play in the original Star Wars until later, I think most fans would enjoy seeing these individuals humble (or not so humble) beginnings. The choice for the future 'Emperor' was ghoulish and nicely done (he's a real slime-bag playing the role of savior...perfect!). Obi-One was also well casted. And him taking on Anakin to train as a Jedi once Obi-One's master was killed by Darth Maul was well executed (gives some real meat and potatoes to the legend of Obi-One). We'll have to see how the next movie stacks up in the series. This one I'd give a B+. Well executed with too much CGI.
Rating:
Summary: Lightsaber battles save the movie....oh...and podracers
Review: Although I will admit I was rather dissapointed with the movie, being a STARWARS fan, one's duty is to find good in flaws, so....according to divine rebel order comanded, I did. LIGHTSABER BATTLES and PODRACES saved the movie for me....at least the second time I saw it in the movie theatre. Anyway, I strongly believe that the trilogy is a million times better than this lame introduction to the series. Nevertheless, I do recommend to any "anti starwars fan" to keep a good 100m from any cinema playing the movie so as to avoid any mishap.
Rating:
Summary: All Your Base Are Belong To Us
Review: Although it's been a long time in coming, Epsiode I has finally made it onto DVD and we can only hope that originial triology will follow soon. The quality (sound, picture, etc) is simply amazing. It makes the experience of watching such a fine film even more enjoyable. If you haven't had the chance, watch the DVD on a complete surround sound system and see if you can hear the difference. Its quite spectacular. Anyone who has anything truly negative to say about this film isn't a true Star Wars fan, and probably wouldn't be bothered to buy the VHS in the first place.
Rating:
Summary: An all-around fun movie to watch.
Review: Although the acting (or lack there-of) of one particular character stands out in this film, (Anakin) this film will be remembered as one that people can watch over and over again. Except, of course, for Jar-Jar Binks.
Anyway, the plot is so amazingly simple, the movie is just timeless, like the other STAR WARS. Because there is no real ending to the story, no one can spoil it for you, therefore, it never gets old. I think Lucas did a great job at making a movie that people of all ages can watch and enjoy. If you have children, and do not own this movie, buy it! They will love it, and you won't want to smash it against the wall after they watch it for the 80th time.
Rating:
Summary: Good film , poor quality VHS
Review: Although the acting was alittle "stiff", I thought this was an exciting movie with outstanding CG (Computer Graphics). Unfortunately when G. Lucas transfered it to VHS standard format (the cheap version) some of the film quality is lost. I was one of several individuals who noticed the quality difference. I had to purchase the wide screen collector's edition to find a much beter, VHS version. I still do not under stand why this film, the Star Wars Trilogy, and Indiana Jones Trilogy are not available on DVD?
|
