<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: Attention to "Detail" is required
Review: A very interesting and most welcome response from Kate Michell (or is that Mychell?). I would think an apology for those who have already bought this book must be a first. I was not able to add further comments before 1 May because I was abroad. All I can say at this stage is that I was reviewing the book that is published and not the one that is going to be published. In that review I said, "This book has the potential to be an excellent guide but somebody needs to go back to the proof reading stage, remove the glaring errors, double check all the facts and update the surface photography before we can put our faith into this product." Those comments stand and you really must pay attention to the small detail - for example my name is "Middleton" not Myddleton! Sincerely. NM
Rating: 
Summary: Response to review by Ned Myddleton
Review: As the editor of a new, fully revised edition of this title that is currently in process, I would like to say that New Holland Publishers have been made fully aware of the errors contained in this book, and apologise sincerely to readers of the exisiting edition. The revised edition has been worked on throughly by Jack Jackson, the renowned author of numerous other diving books that have received 5-star reviews by Amazon readers, and shall be available in bookshops at the end of the year. I would also like to thank Ned Myddleton for his specific comments, and would like to assure him that these had been picked up on and that they have been corrected. However, if Ned would like to send any further corrections to myself (kate@nhpub.co.uk) then please do so over the next two weeks (until May 1). Kate Michell (Senior Editor, New Holland Publishers)
Rating:
Summary: Very Disappointing
Review: If I was judging this book purely on the underwater photographs, I would have no hesitation in giving a 5 Star rating. Without that standard of photography, the book would not have received any stars at all.
I ordered this book because I needed to know more about certain areas of the Egyptian Red Sea I was due to visit. Since then, I have conducted professional assignments to three different regions and each time I found the book to be of limited value. This is purely a reference book and, with 52 pages devoted to the principle sites of Israel, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Sudan and Eritrea combined and a full 64 pages devoted to Egypt, I began to wonder about how much original information I would find in this book... The answer was "Not a lot!"
The layout is generally very good but, for those photographs that are captioned, descriptions such as "A wave breaking on a healthy reef of stony corals" (Stony Corals! What are they?) or "Divers exploring the wreck of a cruising yacht in the Deep South" (a yacht, incidentally, that is not mentioned anywhere else in the entire book!), left me somewhat bemused.
The book is packed with the sort of information one needs to know. Unfortunately, I soon found myself mistrusting almost everything written. All writers and their publishers have a duty of care towards the reader and it is vitally important that the "general information" on such topics as Culture, Religion, Climate, Visas etc is correct. It is also important that the Diving information is accurate and well-researched. Because this element of the book (and after all, it is a "Diving Guide!") is lacking in so many areas, it brings into question the accuracy of all the information given.
Take for example the Sudanese shipwreck described as the "Labanzo." For the record the correct name is "Levanzo" - a vessel built in 1901 and lost in 1940. The book also contains that perennial favourite the "Sarah H" in Egypt. When this shipwreck was first discovered in the 1970's her true identity was unknown and the finders promptly named her after their own diving guide Sarah Hillel. The ship's real name is, of course, the "Kingston" - something that has been known to Divers with a knowledge of the area for something like 10 years before this book was published...
On the "Up" side, I did find the vast majority of the underwater images to be quite outstanding - almost all of which are by Alex Misiewicz - whose work I have long admired. Sadly, many of the surface shots appear to be very old and out-of date and the only photograph attributed to the author is one of a camel...
This book has the potential to be an excellent guide but somebody needs to go back to the proof reading stage, remove the glaring errors, double check all the facts and update the surface photography before we can put our faith into this product. As I said "Very Disappointing."
NM
Rating:
Summary: Very Disappointing
Review: If I was judging this book purely on the underwater photographs, I would have no hesitation in giving a 5 Star rating. Without that standard of photography, the book would not have received any stars at all. I ordered this book because I needed to know more about certain areas of the Egyptian Red Sea I was due to visit. Since then, I have conducted professional assignments to three different regions and each time I found the book to be of limited value. This is purely a reference book and, with 52 pages devoted to the principle sites of Israel, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Sudan and Eritrea combined and a full 64 pages devoted to Egypt, I began to wonder about how much original information I would find in this book... The answer was "Not a lot!" The layout is generally very good but, for those photographs that are captioned, descriptions such as "A wave breaking on a healthy reef of stony corals" (Stony Corals! What are they?) or "Divers exploring the wreck of a cruising yacht in the Deep South" (a yacht, incidentally, that is not mentioned anywhere else in the entire book!), left me somewhat bemused. The book is packed with the sort of information one needs to know. Unfortunately, I soon found myself mistrusting almost everything written. All writers and their publishers have a duty of care towards the reader and it is vitally important that the "general information" on such topics as Culture, Religion, Climate, Visas etc is correct. It is also important that the Diving information is accurate and well-researched. Because this element of the book (and after all, it is a "Diving Guide!") is lacking in so many areas, it brings into question the accuracy of all the information given. Take for example the Sudanese shipwreck described as the "Labanzo." For the record the correct name is "Levanzo" - a vessel built in 1901 and lost in 1940. The book also contains that perennial favourite the "Sarah H" in Egypt. When this shipwreck was first discovered in the 1970's her true identity was unknown and the finders promptly named her after their own diving guide Sarah Hillel. The ship's real name is, of course, the "Kingston" - something that has been known to Divers with a knowledge of the area for something like 10 years before this book was published... On the "Up" side, I did find the vast majority of the underwater images to be quite outstanding - almost all of which are by Alex Misiewicz - whose work I have long admired. Sadly, many of the surface shots appear to be very old and out-of date and the only photograph attributed to the author is one of a camel... This book has the potential to be an excellent guide but somebody needs to go back to the proof reading stage, remove the glaring errors, double check all the facts and update the surface photography before we can put our faith into this product. As I said "Very Disappointing."
<< 1 >>
| 
