<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: This is a wonderful, thoughtful book!
Review: Crystal Desert is the kind of book that stays with you. It is a very interesting read. David Campbell is a marvelous writer.
Rating: 
Summary: Quite a topic
Review: It would be hard for this book to be uninteresting, covering as it does the natural history and present teeming life, as well as the everyday life of a human community, in this remote area. My only objection is the use of some scientific biology words which may be common enough among scientists but which are curveballs for us lay folk. Otherwise it's a fine read. This really made me picture myself there, and want to visit Antarctica, and appreciate its role in the world environment.
Rating:
Summary: Good, but the author isn't big on introspection
Review: Since I've visited Antarctica, and enjoyed its haunting, indifferent beauty as well as the spectacular wildlife, I was interested in reading an account of someone who had lived, studied, and conducted research there. Campbell's strength is writing about the science, the wildlife, the extremes of weather and of living in a difficult place. His weakness is his utter lack of self-analysis. He berates the tourists who come to this place (does he think he owns the Antarctic area himself?), and laments the loss of microscopic and macroscopic life that is lost when the loutish tourist dares step on the fragile landscape, yet he is blissfully unaware of the far greater damage he does to the ecosystem when he powers up the hills to work on the weatherstation, and when he pulls up marine creatures and watches them burst, dying, under his microscope. I guess anything is fair game when done under the guise of 'science', but woe be to the ordinary person who dares to learn about one of the farthest reaches of the planet.
Rating:
Summary: Quite a topic
Review: The Crystal Desert is an excellent exposition of just about everything you ever wanted to know about Antartica. It covers history, wildlife (from microbiology to whales), geology, scenery, life on Antarctic bases, and the present day politics of the continent. It also has a wonderful bibliography for those who want to know more, and is written by an author with a real gift for evoking a landscape which few of us will ever see.
Rating:
Summary: The best scientific travel book I have read
Review: The Crystal Desert is an excellent exposition of just about everything you ever wanted to know about Antartica. It covers history, wildlife (from microbiology to whales), geology, scenery, life on Antarctic bases, and the present day politics of the continent. It also has a wonderful bibliography for those who want to know more, and is written by an author with a real gift for evoking a landscape which few of us will ever see.
Rating:
Summary: Good non-fiction about Antarctica
Review: There's much to be learned about the most inhopsitable place on the face of our planet and this book is a good source for that. Also recommend Bob Mayer's ETERNITY BASE, a work of fiction centered around Antarctica.
Rating:
Summary: Superbly written and lovely presentation of natural history
Review: This book is elegantly descriptive of the history, both natural and anthropogenic, of one of the last true frontiers - Antarctica. Dr. Campbell presents an interesting history of Antarctica before the human invasion as well as after, which provides the reader with a better understanding of the environment in Antarctica.
Rating: 
Summary: Not About Antarctica
Review: This was a disappointing read, mainly because it isn't about Antarctica, but about King George Island. Like writing a book about North America from research conducted on Cuba. Yes, Cuba is part of North America, but... If you want information on Antarctica, look elsewhere. Why he named it "Crystal Desert" is beyond me because there is NOTHING on the ice cap. Secondly, Campbell, who may or may not be a competent biologist, spends far to much time grinding his environmental axe. For some reason, he thinks he and other academicians are the only people with the right to go to Antarctica, making numerous disparaging comments about tourism throughout the text. Moreover, he seems to have a major problem with males - be they human, sperm whale, or elephant seal, espousing traits such as "machismo" and other derogatory human emotions to these animals simply because they are larger than the females. And finally, he spends the entire final third of the book expounding on the horrors of the seal and whale hunts that decimated the populations of these magnificant animals. Unfortunate, definately. But the book is supposed to be about Antarctica - not a treatise on over-sealing and over-whaling by people from another period in time. It does have some good descriptions of Admiralty Bay on King George Island - mainly from a biological perspective, but overall, it was a waste of time.
Rating:
Summary: Not About Antarctica
Review: This was a disappointing read, mainly because it isn't about Antarctica, but about King George Island. Like writing a book about North America from research conducted on Cuba. Yes, Cuba is part of North America, but... If you want information on Antarctica, look elsewhere. Why he named it "Crystal Desert" is beyond me because there is NOTHING on the ice cap. Secondly, Campbell, who may or may not be a competent biologist, spends far to much time grinding his environmental axe. For some reason, he thinks he and other academicians are the only people with the right to go to Antarctica, making numerous disparaging comments about tourism throughout the text. Moreover, he seems to have a major problem with males - be they human, sperm whale, or elephant seal, espousing traits such as "machismo" and other derogatory human emotions to these animals simply because they are larger than the females. And finally, he spends the entire final third of the book expounding on the horrors of the seal and whale hunts that decimated the populations of these magnificant animals. Unfortunate, definately. But the book is supposed to be about Antarctica - not a treatise on over-sealing and over-whaling by people from another period in time. It does have some good descriptions of Admiralty Bay on King George Island - mainly from a biological perspective, but overall, it was a waste of time.
<< 1 >>
|
