Rating: Summary: Great book for parents to share with teens Review: This is the sort of book which gives the "socialsciences" a bad name. It is basically just arm-chair chitchat,one shrink recounting some encounters she has had with some patients,and what appears to have happened. It's not bad science because it'snot even science.I noted with alarm that the author (female) hadapparently still not made up her mind whether masturbation wasOK. This book went in the trash right away.
Rating: Summary: Personal anecdotes only Review: This is the sort of book which gives the "socialsciences" a bad name. It is basically just arm-chair chitchat,one shrink recounting some encounters she has had with some patients,and what appears to have happened. It's not bad science because it'snot even science. I noted with alarm that the author (female) hadapparently still not made up her mind whether masturbation wasOK. This book went in the trash right away.
Rating: Summary: Same old sensationalism and denial Review: Unfortunately, this kind of book--the therapist generalizes his/her most disturbed teenage client cases into a dire commentary on all youth--is becoming an epidemic. This book is not a useful basis for understanding young people. Rather, it is part of the professional sensationalism and denial that helps make America one of the riskiest Western nations to live in. First of all, Dr. Ponton is both unfair and unscientific. Suppose I culled some lurid cases of psychotherapists' sexually exploiting patients and compiled them into a book, "The Sex Lives of Psychiatrists." Such a book might depict modern therapists as uniquely dangerous perverts the rest of us should fear. Would that be accurate or fair? No. It would be an example of what social scientists term as fallacious "selection bias:" a grossly unfair smear on an entire group based on the misdeeds of a few of its most disturbed number. Now, Dr. Ponton, and readers and reviewers who seem to worship this kind of book as "realism:" how is what she does to teenagers any different? Second, Dr. Ponton's comments on youth sexuality are blatantly inaccurate. She claims that today's teenagers "are taking greater risks" with sex than past generations. Not true. The latest National Center for Health Statistics data shows that teens today are less likely to get pregnant, less likely have babies or abortions, and less likely to contract STDs today than teens of 25 to 30 years ago. Further, teens who do get pregnant tend to be older (more are 18 or 19, rather than 12-17) today than back then. Third, she blames the easy targets such as media images of sex and innate teenage risk-taking for adolescent sexual problems. What evasion. Surely, in her work in HIV treatment, Dr. Ponton noticed that HIV-positive youths are not a cross-section of the average teenage population, but overwhelmingly are extremely poor, usually homeless prostitutes forced into "survival sex" with adult clients to obtain money, food, shelter, and protection. It's depressing that in the few instances in which Dr. Ponton's book relates adult sexual abuses, solicitations, and harassments toward youths, those who seem eager to believe any debauchery among teenagers dismiss and deny them. The fact is that exhaustive clinical testing has found HIV infection rates on college campuses are almost zero and, among teens in general, are very low. However, HIV-positive levels run as high as one in six destitute runaway and homeless youths, which is why HIV is dozens of times more common among African American teen girls than among the more privileged, mostly white youths Dr. Ponton sees. Unhealthy adult sexual behaviors and rampant youth poverty (not race)--and not "teenage risk taking"--are the markers of high rates of unwanted pregnancy, sexually-transmitted disease, and AIDS among the most vulnerable fraction of young people. When are professionals such as Dr. Ponton going to face their responsibility to stop selling books with popular, salacious kid-sex tales and unwarranted fears about "youth today," and instead confront readers and policy makers with the unpopular, real risks our adult society imposes on its young people?
Rating: Summary: Focusing on the Negative Review: What is it these days with authors, and society in general associating teens having sex with pregnancy, STD's and harrasment. Teenagers these days aren't as naive as you think! I know I remember everything essential in those Health classes and what my parents taught me. After learning that every action has a consequence, they should also tell you that it is an enjoyable experience! No wonder half the girls out there are freaked out of their mind when the three letter word is brought up in any conversation!
Rating: Summary: Great book for parents to share with teens Review: When I read Dr. Ponton's book, the stories of her patients were so close to my actual experiences as a teen that I was thrilled someone had finaly "gotten it". I plan to give this book to my parents and my 16 year-old sister, and strongly recommend it to teens and parents to be used as a tool for more open communtication about some often difficult isses. The writing was simple, frank, and not too clincal. To anyone who is a teen or cares about a teen it will be an easy and engaging read.
|