Darkness at Noon

Rating:
Summary: love
Review: i wish this book would never have ended. it was one of the best books i've ever read.

Rating:
Summary: Koestler's book is a shoddy piece of CIA propaganda
Review: A caricature wrapped in a parody wrapped in a novelette. This trashy novel is just a piece of Cold War propaganda. It presents a ludicrous caricature of history, a simple-minded moralism. Koestler claims that all communists are all bad because they believe that 'The ends justify the means'. But doesn't George Bush believe this? Doesn't Blair? Don't you sometimes? It all depends on the circumstances, and no simple dogma will do the job - you actually have to think beneath the idiot slogans.
It's no surprise that General Franco at the end of the war freed Koestler from his jails, when he killed without trial so many decent Republicans and their supporters. Franco could see that Koestler was going to be more use to him alive than dead, and this book indeed proves that Koestler was an asset to the forces of reaction. Remember that Koestler composed this anti-communist screed when the communists of the Soviet Union were defeating 70% of Hitler's divisions, and that these same communists were saving us all from Hitler's extermination camps.

Rating:
Summary: "The end justifies the means" ??? :(
Review: "The characters in this book are fictitious. The historical circumstances which determined their actions are real. The life of the man N. S. Rubashov is a synthesis of the lives of a number of men who were victims of the so-called Moscu Trials".That is part of the dedicatory that Koestler wrote for his book, "Darkness at noon".

Arthur Koestler (1905-1983) was a person that believed in the progress that Communism was supposed to bring, but that became disillusioned in the way in which that dream was being carried out in the URSS. He wrote many books that give expression to his feelings of disenchantment, but "Darkness at noon" is probably the most popular one.

Not overly long, and very easy to read, this book is the story of Rubashov, an old communist who took part in the revolution and who is very loyal to the "Cause". Strangely enough, he is accused of treason, and taken to jail, where he must face harsh interrogatories. While he is in jail, Rubashov experiences flashbacks that allow us to know more about him, and the things he did due to his devotion to the Party. He betrayed people he loved, and those he appreciated, for no other reason than obedience to the Party and fear of going to jail.

We can have an idea of Rubashov's feelings and ideas all throughout his ordeal thanks to the fact that "Darkness at noon" is written in the first person. After a while, we are Rubashov, and like him we are surprised, outraged, desperate and ultimately resigned to our luck.

In the beginning, Rubashov says that he isn't a traitor and that he hasn't done the things he is accused of. But slowly our main character starts to come to terms with the idea that the truth of the accusation isn't really important, what matters is to serve the country. And if the leader (Number one) says he is to be blamed, he must have done something....

The prisioner writes a diary, where he dwells upon the nature of men, and politics. He thinks that after the revolution he defended so passionately, an individual is defined merely as "a multitude of one million divided by one million". The individual doesn't matter because only the "Cause" matters. Regarding politics, he concludes that at the end only one thing is clear: "the end justifies the means". Is it any surprise, then, that the tone that pervades this book is so gloomy?.

On the whole, I highly recommend "Darkness at noon" to all of you, for two reasons. To start with, it is a literary masterpiece, beautifully written and accessible to the average reader. Secondly, and more important, it also shows us once again that every attempt to forget that the end doesn't justifies the means ends in a nightmare.

Belen Alcat


Rating:
Summary: It Was A Delight!
Review: Do you hear that tapping???? It's hard to understand how a novel that involves such brutality and cruelty could be such an excellent read. Masterpiece. This book will have you looking over your shoulder and between your legs and rubbing your sore shoudlers and tapping messages through the wall to your fellow prisoner/ neighbor.