Rating: 
Summary: A worthy book for any Wonder Woman fan's library.
Review: A quick summary of "A League of One" goes like this: Diana discovers from the Oracle of Delphi that members of the Justice League will die if they face a recently re-awakened primordial dragon. The very breath of the dragon corrupts the soul, and Wonder Woman decides to sacrifice herself for the sake of her friends by resorting to lies and trickery to get them out of harm's way. This is much more difficult than it sounds - Diana's essence is the spirit of truth - her decision to betray her friends in order to save them cuts into her very soul. Nevertheless, she goes ahead with her plans... I like this book a great deal because of the gorgeous artwork, which successfully fuses fantasy art with superhero action. Diana's character in this book remains true to both her mythological roots and to George Perez's revamp of Wonder Woman in 1986. Her pain at having to betray her friends, in particular Superman, is clearly portrayed, as is her deep friendship with Superman. Superman, the Boy Scout, and Wonder Woman, the Spirit of Truth, would have been so right for each other if it wasn't for Lois Lane. Although the theme of betrayal by a member of the Justice League is also explored in "The Tower of Babel" collection, I much prefered "A League of One". That is not to say this book is perfect - it is hard to imagine Diana not sharing her dilemma with her friends and trusting them to come up with a solution. The Justice League is family, and families take care of their own together.
Rating:
Summary: A worthy book for any Wonder Woman fan's library.
Review: A quick summary of "A League of One" goes like this: Diana discovers from the Oracle of Delphi that members of the Justice League will die if they face a recently re-awakened primordial dragon. The very breath of the dragon corrupts the soul, and Wonder Woman decides to sacrifice herself for the sake of her friends by resorting to lies and trickery to get them out of harm's way. This is much more difficult than it sounds - Diana's essence is the spirit of truth - her decision to betray her friends in order to save them cuts into her very soul. Nevertheless, she goes ahead with her plans... I like this book a great deal because of the gorgeous artwork, which successfully fuses fantasy art with superhero action. Diana's character in this book remains true to both her mythological roots and to George Perez's revamp of Wonder Woman in 1986. Her pain at having to betray her friends, in particular Superman, is clearly portrayed, as is her deep friendship with Superman. Superman, the Boy Scout, and Wonder Woman, the Spirit of Truth, would have been so right for each other if it wasn't for Lois Lane. Although the theme of betrayal by a member of the Justice League is also explored in "JLA: The Tower of Babel" collection, I much prefered "A League of One". That is not to say this book is perfect - it is hard to imagine Diana not sharing her dilemma with her friends and trusting them to come up with a solution. The Justice League is family, and families take care of their own together.
Rating: 
Summary: Moeller Takes On DC's Biggest
Review: All in all, it's a nice book. Christopher Moeller is a celebrated artist (check out his artwork on some of the Magic: the Gathering cards) and does respectable renditions of Wonder Woman, Superman, and Batman. In comparison to Alex Ross's versions, they are all more "proper." The story is certainly worth reading, although it's not as complete in terms of internal conflict as it could have been. Here is the breakdown of my rating: Graphics, story, dragon: 5 stars, Batman is defeated by Wonder Woman: 3 stars
Rating: 
Summary: For fans of WW and/or fantasy artwork, but not of plot
Review: As other reviews have made clear, this book should appeal to Wonder Woman fans. However, as a JLA fan -- and not because of Wonder Woman -- I found it somewhat lacking. Attempting to marry the already troublesome concepts of Wonder Woman's Greek-ish mythology and a dragon (with servant gnomes) left over from medieval times, Moeller goes way overboard with 60s-style Stan Lee "Hoary Halls of Hoggoth" pseudo-mystic dialogue, in addition to the common comic transgression of having a character explain his or her attributes for uninformed readers (I'm pretty sure that, after all these years, Wonder Woman doesn't need Martian Manhunter to tell her that fire is his race's greatest vulnerability). Also, having previously read "Tower of Babel" (though, I know, this book, in hardcover, came out well before that one), I find the whole single-member-betrays-the-team thing getting a little tired; I certainly don't need to see it retread in a one-off that seems to have no place in the continuity. But my main problem is this: did the book inspire the cover, or the other way around? Like the cover, the book has some excellent paintings of Wonder Woman and of a dragon. Also like the cover, it doesn't tell much of a story. It is, as previously noted, a deeper than usual treatment of WW; there seems to be a general comics consensus that she needs to escape her Linda Carter-era bimbo image and become the warrior princess we know her to be, but only in one-offs like this does anybody ever actually work at it. Respect for that, but what little plot surrounds it needn't, and really shouldn't, have been a JLA story. Mr. Moeller's writing gave me a solid two-star reading experience; begrudgingly, I give one more star in recognition of his stellar artwork. I hope to see more of the latter. But just the latter.
Rating:
Summary: For fans of WW and/or fantasy artwork, but not of plot
Review: As other reviews have made clear, this book should appeal to Wonder Woman fans. However, as a JLA fan -- and not because of Wonder Woman -- I found it somewhat lacking. Attempting to marry the already troublesome concepts of Wonder Woman's Greek-ish mythology and a dragon (with servant gnomes) left over from medieval times, Moeller goes way overboard with 60s-style Stan Lee "Hoary Halls of Hoggoth" pseudo-mystic dialogue, in addition to the common comic transgression of having a character explain his or her attributes for uninformed readers (I'm pretty sure that, after all these years, Wonder Woman doesn't need Martian Manhunter to tell her that fire is his race's greatest vulnerability). Also, having previously read "Tower of Babel" (though, I know, this book, in hardcover, came out well before that one), I find the whole single-member-betrays-the-team thing getting a little tired; I certainly don't need to see it retread in a one-off that seems to have no place in the continuity. But my main problem is this: did the book inspire the cover, or the other way around? Like the cover, the book has some excellent paintings of Wonder Woman and of a dragon. Also like the cover, it doesn't tell much of a story. It is, as previously noted, a deeper than usual treatment of WW; there seems to be a general comics consensus that she needs to escape her Linda Carter-era bimbo image and become the warrior princess we know her to be, but only in one-offs like this does anybody ever actually work at it. Respect for that, but what little plot surrounds it needn't, and really shouldn't, have been a JLA story. Mr. Moeller's writing gave me a solid two-star reading experience; begrudgingly, I give one more star in recognition of his stellar artwork. I hope to see more of the latter. But just the latter.
Rating:
Summary: Wonder Woman's show
Review: Great book. A different aproach to the justice league. Outstanding art (there's a pin-up of Wonder Woman that should be made a poster). It falls a bit short on the story...I kind of was expecting more, but it's a good read.
Rating:
Summary: really for Wonder Woman fans
Review: I'll start off by admitting that I'm not a huge fan of DC comics--other than Batman. And I'm not really a Wonder Woman person (and this is a WW story). But this really was alright. It is a story of betrayal and has an interesting philosophical/morality bent to it. It has dragons. Good writing. And an interesting artwork--almost painterly.
Rating:
Summary: And in A League of One Does this book stand
Review: The Amazon princess known as Wonder Woman is one of the world's mightiest warriors with a group of modern icons called the Justice League of America. But there would come a day when this group of modern day iconic heroes such as Superman, Flash, Green Lantern and Aquaman would come across a danger from ancient times long since forgotten with the pwoer to slay them and the hope of the world in her infernous breath. Her name, well names are powerful pieces of information my friend. Let's just call her an ancient Dragon. Once forgotten in the realm of myth and fantasy, this race of Wyrms is shown to be all too real and cunning as their Queen rises from the depths of Mt. Altdorf Switzerland to terrorize the world. Diana, home on her tropical Paradise island discovers from the infallible Oracle of Delphi a prophecy saying that the League, despite the Strength of Superman the Speed of Flash and the Skill of Batman will fall before the Dragon Queen. The pure and just princess is conflicted but finally decides to begin a magical and fantastic quest, an impossible journey to try and thwart fate. This story shows new readers just who Wonder Woman is. In the guise of fantasy story certainly worthy of any Dungeons and Dragons Reader the phenomenal strengths of Diana. With touching human scenes and chillingly cruel crimes against humanity perpetrated by the Queen, we as readers ahte this vile Dragon and are able to see and hear the three dimensional conflict of Diana. Diana not wanting to witness the deaths of her friends attempts to betray them one by one. Cleverly and quickly dispatching of each League member in her own way Diana shows us again and again that Wonder Woman, her idea her myth has evolved far beyond the camp of Lynda Carter into a breathing living woman. A woman who although afraid to die and aware of her mortality wil risk it all to save her friends when it counts the most. I'd give this book a 5 star rating. The coloring is dark and murky but trust me, Diana's facial expressions and the dialogue are snappy. And for those of you who think Batman cantake down anyone... Diana said it best as she punches him out.. "A League of One,,, it will be enough..." With first rate writing and hand painted pictures this hard cover graphic novel is in a League of its Own.
Rating:
Summary: Pretty good
Review: The dragons were defeated long ago, but as the last of them is awoken, Wonder Woman receives a dispiriting prediction - that the Justice League will defeat the dragon, but die in their victory. And so, Diana knows that to save her friends, she must betray them, and get them out of the way. Only then will the Justice League, a league of one, face this ancient evil. This is a pretty good graphic novel, with a wonderful storyline. The illustrations are, admittedly, a little disappointing; they could have been much better. But, that said, this is an interesting JLA, one that I enjoyed reading.
Rating:
Summary: One of the better JLA stories
Review: The title is incorrect. It should be "Wonder Woman : A League of One", as the JLA team members barely make an appearance at all. This is a Wonder Woman story all the way through. The art is beautiful, painted on par with Alex Ross. The story seems to be influenced by The Lord of the Rings... Wonder Woman is the Dragonslayer! As far as JLA books go, this one is better than anything Grant Morrison wrote... but not quite up to Mark Waid standards. If you enjoy fantasy, buy the book. If you're wanting a superhero story, skip this one. I thought it mixed mythologies well, but I'm sure some purists will find fault with it.
|
