<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: Life in baseball from an anthropologist?s perspective
Review: George Gmelch's Inside Pitch uncovers the lives of professional baseball players behind the scene, from an anthropological perspective. What this means is that the emphasis is placed on observations. There is not much of extravagance, often arising from the glamorized life style of ballplayers. Rather, it is the unglamorized side of stories that interests us in this book. This is an academic writing (though very readable), and as such it might look like a little dry read, except on a few occasions like when Gmelch, with his old teammates, reminisces his own days as a ballplayer back in the 60's, and writing about such highly emotional events as the release of a minor leaguer. The stories are told mostly from interviews of various people involved in the game, such as players, managers, scouts, people in management, wives of players, and even groupies. Being a former ballplayer himself, Gmelch does not miss those questions that would naturally arise from any curious baseball fans. Also it enables him to have comparative views on how things have changed from the days when he actually played, e.g., the increased role of money and the improved, yet somewhat less camaraderie-oriented (for the lack of better words) conditions surrounding minor leaguers. Despite being an observer, Gmelch obviously can relate deeply to players, having gone through similar emotional up's and down's himself. After learning how much the players need to go through before only few among them eventually climb up to the topmost echelon of the baseball world, I came to find myself accepting of players being lavishly paid (still don't want another strike, though), especially considering that in many other outrageously paid occupations like cooperate CEO's and entertainers, breed, luck, and/or connection may play much greater roles than sheer skills, for which others are paying. That is the extent to which you would come to feel like rooting both for those who flourish in the glory of the major league and for those whose dream ends up being shattered after tremendous hard work and stiff competitions. The purpose of this work, of course, is not to sensationalize or sentimentalize, so it is understandable that the tone of the narrative throughout the book is reserved to an extent, despite that many stories can be emotionally involved. For me, that takes something away from this highly interesting work. This is probably an unfair criticism from a student, being tired of reading too much academic work in an ivory tower. No wonder that two of the chapters I like most deal with players with unfulfilled dreams, including that of young Gmelch. I highly recommend this book to those who wish to view ballplayers as human beings, just like us.
Rating:
Summary: Life in baseball from an anthropologist¿s perspective
Review: George Gmelch's Inside Pitch uncovers the lives of professional baseball players behind the scene, from an anthropological perspective. What this means is that the emphasis is placed on observations. There is not much of extravagance, often arising from the glamorized life style of ballplayers. Rather, it is the unglamorized side of stories that interests us in this book. This is an academic writing (though very readable), and as such it might look like a little dry read, except on a few occasions like when Gmelch, with his old teammates, reminisces his own days as a ballplayer back in the 60's, and writing about such highly emotional events as the release of a minor leaguer. The stories are told mostly from interviews of various people involved in the game, such as players, managers, scouts, people in management, wives of players, and even groupies. Being a former ballplayer himself, Gmelch does not miss those questions that would naturally arise from any curious baseball fans. Also it enables him to have comparative views on how things have changed from the days when he actually played, e.g., the increased role of money and the improved, yet somewhat less camaraderie-oriented (for the lack of better words) conditions surrounding minor leaguers. Despite being an observer, Gmelch obviously can relate deeply to players, having gone through similar emotional up's and down's himself. After learning how much the players need to go through before only few among them eventually climb up to the topmost echelon of the baseball world, I came to find myself accepting of players being lavishly paid (still don't want another strike, though), especially considering that in many other outrageously paid occupations like cooperate CEO's and entertainers, breed, luck, and/or connection may play much greater roles than sheer skills, for which others are paying. That is the extent to which you would come to feel like rooting both for those who flourish in the glory of the major league and for those whose dream ends up being shattered after tremendous hard work and stiff competitions. The purpose of this work, of course, is not to sensationalize or sentimentalize, so it is understandable that the tone of the narrative throughout the book is reserved to an extent, despite that many stories can be emotionally involved. For me, that takes something away from this highly interesting work. This is probably an unfair criticism from a student, being tired of reading too much academic work in an ivory tower. No wonder that two of the chapters I like most deal with players with unfulfilled dreams, including that of young Gmelch. I highly recommend this book to those who wish to view ballplayers as human beings, just like us.
Rating:
Summary: Raves for Gmelch's Inside Pitch
Review: After reading Inside Pitch, I looked at the beloved game of baseball in a whole new fashion. It opened my eyes to many hidden aspects of the game, that fans rarely catch a glimpse of. The personal stories of Gmelch were heartwarming and informative at the same time. I recommend this book to any baseball fan!
Rating:
Summary: Raves for Gmelch's Inside Pitch
Review: After reading Inside Pitch, I looked at the beloved game of baseball in a whole new fashion. It opened my eyes to many hidden aspects of the game, that fans rarely catch a glimpse of. The personal stories of Gmelch were heartwarming and informative at the same time. I recommend this book to any baseball fan!
Rating:
Summary: A whole new look
Review: After reading this book I have found myself watching baseball in a way I never did before. I am much more interested in the players and their stories. If you find yourself in need of more excitment, read this book.
Rating:
Summary: A whole new look
Review: After reading this book I have found myself watching baseball in a way I never did before. I am much more interested in the players and their stories. If you find yourself in need of more excitment, read this book.
Rating: 
Summary: Definately NOT one of the best Baseball books...
Review: As a long time Baseball fan, I have read many books on the game. I found Gmelch's book to be rather disappointing. While it could've been more involving and presented the sport in the gawdy light it deserves, I found that Gmelch trivialized Baseball. He was repetitive in his ideas and analysis; furthermore, his analysis was not at all insightful by any stretch of the imagination. It simply seemed that he stated the obvious, skimming over the wondrous moments he must have experienced during his journeys. In the end, Gmelch does not really say anything worthy of publication. Any Baseball fan already knows much of what is in this book, and did not have to travel the country interviewing dozens of amateur and professional ballplayers of varying ranks to discover this information. If you want to read a book that will REALLY incite you to see Baseball in an entirely different light, and make you appreciate just how magical this game can be, read A. Bartlett Giamatti's "A Great and Glorious Game." It will give you shivers....
Rating:
Summary: Inside pitch
Review: The Inside Pitch by George Gmelch is one of the best baseball books I have ever read. This book gives the reader an inside look into the lives of baseball players. The Inside Pitch shows the reader what it is like to be a professional baseball player through the eyes of professional baseball players. You really learn a lot about baseball as a culture; what it is like to play minor league baseball, making it to the majors, being a rookie away from home, getting released, the pressures of performing well, bonus babies, groupies......Easily the best baseball book I have ever read.
<< 1 >>
| 
