Rating: 
Summary: Review Lewis, not Beane
Review: Before I read this book, I came to Amazon to learn whether people thought Michael Lewis had done a compelling job telling Billy Beane's story. I didn't come to find out what baseball fans think of Beane as a GM (which is the substance of many reviews here). Now that I have read it, I can report to the rest of you that it is very worthwhile, if you want to know how the business of baseball is conducted these days. Whether you agree with Beane's strategy or not, this book will take you inside the life of a GM like nothing else I've read. Lewis's past experience writing about tense business situations clearly helps him set the scene for the MLB amateur draft and all the preparation that comes before it. So leave your fan hat behind, and use your reading glasses instead.
Rating: 
Summary: Not just for baseball enthusiats
Review: This type of book, written the wrong way, can wind up only on the shelves of enthusiasts. Instead, Michael Lewis did an amazing job creating a book which will not only be interesting to baseball enthusiasts and statisticians, but also to anyone who even has a remote interest in sports or business. I agree with my local library's classification of this book as a non-fiction work that reads like fiction.
Rating:
Summary: Great read
Review: If I find a book that interests me, I read it in about 3 weeks. This one took 5 days. I couldn't put it down. If you are a baseball fan, even mildly so, you need to get this book. It almost made me an Oakland A's fan!
Rating:
Summary: In the age of short attention spans....
Review: This book is almost impossible to put down. Billy Beane's belief of how to build a team is a glimmer of hope for anyone who is a fan of small-market ball. This book provides a very interesting look behind the scenes of a big league club, and why the A's can't afford to maintain the status quo. Even if you aren't a baseball fan this book will grab your attention, because in the end it isn't so much about baseball as it about bucking trends and taking a risk on what you believe in.
Rating:
Summary: Sabremetrics finally rules!
Review: As an avid fan of Bill James in the 1970s and 1980s, I have been constantly dismayed by the lack of respect given to his skilled analysis and observation of the game of baseball in his various writings over the years, including the now highly acclaimed Baseball Abstract. An interesting parallel can be drawn to another book, written on another subject almost 40 years ago, a book called Beat The Dealer by Dr. Edward Thorpe. Dr. Thorpe, after many years of study and computer analysis, wrote his book in 1966 which factually explained how proper play and the use of card counting could defeat the casinos in the game of blackjack. It demythologized the long-held beliefs that only luck and money systems like the truly stupid Martingale could win at blackjack. The book, which is completely and totally based in pure mathematical fact, was ignored by the "old men" of the casino business who "knew" that the house always had the edge. It took many years (and many card counters winning lots of money) for the casinos to wise up and start to fight back, often by having their own people finally read Thorpe's (and his later followers) books. Once again, it is surprising it has taken so long for anyone in baseball to sit up and take notice of what those of us who followed sabremetrics and Bill James' analyses for many years always understood. I agree with many of the reviews that Billy Beane is not portrayed as a particularly endearing person. However, he seems to clearly understand what the facts are here, and acts on them. This is the sign of a good manager and I expect his approach will win out in the long run. And yes, he is right, just like in blackjack, the math will win in the long run (the full season), but it is hell in the short run. Some reviewers have said that in the short run, you need to ignore what got you there and play a different game. However, my experiences in blackjack suggest the opposite, that you have to accept that the short run involves a lot of luck and hope that over the long run (even in the long run of a series of short run playoffs), that the luck will eventually even out and that playing the solid game you always do will finally bear fruit. But as someone who always played blackjack with a small bankroll, I know the variance sure plays havoc with your mind and can tempt you to go the wrong way. One more point. Someone said they hoped that every manager in baseball is made to read this book. For the Oakland A's sake, I hope not, but even if they are, I doubt it will make much difference. Thorpe's book was widely available to read by anyone for many years, and even the casino bosses I talked to who read it would simply tell you that it was wrong. I expect that if every "old man" in baseball read this book, most would say it was something to be laughed at. It will take a generation to change this and in the meantime, I hope Oakland (and others) can ride the results to the bank (and the World Series).
Rating:
Summary: Very interesting and a bit misunderstood
Review: Some people seem to think Moneyball is mostly about Billy Beane being a genius, and as such there has been some backlash from those who don't see him that way. I don't think that's what the book is really about - it's about how a smart guy (Beane) figured out how to stay competitive with less money to spend than the competition. Essentially, Beane figured out what types of players are undervalued and spent his money there. It's hard to argue with the results in the regular season, although the team hasn't won in the playoffs. Moneyball also talks about Bill James, my favorite baseball writer. James labored for years developing theories that were mostly ignored by the baseball establishment. Now many of James' ideas (and those of other sabermetricians) are being accepted by sportwriters, broadcasters and general managers. Moneyball isn't just about baseball. It's about business, about using new knowledge rather than discounting it, and about evaluating risk. Some of the ideas in Moneyball could be applied to other endeavors.
Rating:
Summary: Would have been 5 stars, but a few parts bored me.
Review: This book was billed as some major expose on the inner workings and mind of Billy Beane - General Manager of the Oakland A's, and how he continues to make things work with no money against teams (mostly the Yankees) with significantly larger budgets. And for the most part, that's what it did. Did I enjoy this? Absolutely yes - I totally enjoyed parts of it (the draft day stuff, Beane's behaviour in the park). But other parts bored me. For some reason we got an entire chapter on how A's pitcher Chad Bradford grew up as a kid. That's fine and all, but I don't see how that was germaine to the book. I also was a bit bored about Beane's time in the minors and what his life was like as a player. Yeah, I understand it's background to why he does what he does now, but quite frankly, it bored me. But once the book got out of that, it was wonderful! Lots of insight into how a major league general manager's mind works - or at least Beane's. I agree there's something to sabremetrics (sp?) and it certainly seems to work for him. What I took away from this is that he seemed a bit naieve to think his way is the only way to do things, though. Running has it's uses. I get the impression that if he could, Beane would have every run scored on a bases loaded walk. :) However, that's a lot of nitpicking on my part - the book is an enjoyable read. Provided you enjoy the "business" of baseball. If you don't enjoy the biz side of the sport, you probably wouldn't enjoy this book.
Rating:
Summary: Great analysis of Baseball economics
Review: I thought this book did a great job of comparing the two divergent schools of baseball thought - the dominant "old school" approach, exemplified by the old time baseball "lifers" who know what they know because they know it, and the up-and- coming objective, statistical based analysis of the game, embodied in this book by Billy Beane. The book, slanted towards the new wave of baseball men, does a superb job of punching holes into baseball truisms and dopey practices (I particularly loved the section regarding amateur draft day - why do teams continue to throw away high draft picks and millions of dollars on untested high schoolers - high schoolers!!! - when there are so many quality college players to choose from?). But, most of all, what this book does is prove that you don't necessarily need a lot of money to win - just good management, which is something that is apparently in short supply in baseball. Every baseball owner and general manager should be required to read this book.
Rating:
Summary: Raves from a Non-Baseball Fan
Review: I am not a baseball fan nor am I much of a sports fan at all, but I loved this book. I review mainly business books and the business principles of this book are well stated, easy to understand and truly innovative. If you are in a field that tracks statistics (especially the non-profit world) this book will make you think! But be careful, it will also make you question! Moneyball gets you outside the box (scores) of baseball and if you are a decent interpreter it will help you get out the box in your profession. Highly recommended!
Rating:
Summary: ADDICTING AND GREAT!
Review: man im a student and i just moved 2 texas from oakland. This book is so addicting! i came home 7:00 PM and read until 11:00. it's so kewl and talks about all the complexities of baseball. Author add's tons of humor and cuzz words. i went 2 the 20th STRAIGHT GAME for a dollar and the book depicts tht game like no other! EXCELLENT BOOK! Now i need 2 go finish mai hw tht i havent started...
| 
