<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: highly informative, well written, encyclopedic in knowledge
Review: Retallic and Barker know of what they speak. The writers live near, and fish, the water of which they write. It is refreshing to see a "hook and bullet" book that does not try to browbeat you with the authors casting expertise or remembrances of the West of long ago.This is a very good, easy touse guide on idaho water. If you are going ther, buy it.
Rating:
Summary: highly informative, well written, encyclopedic in knowledge
Review: Retallic and Barker know of what they speak. The writers live near, and fish, the water of which they write. It is refreshing to see a "hook and bullet" book that does not try to browbeat you with the authors casting expertise or remembrances of the West of long ago. This is a very good, easy touse guide on idaho water. If you are going ther, buy it.
Rating:
Summary: highly informative, well written, encyclopedic in knowledge
Review: Retallic and Barker know of what they speak. The writers live near, and fish, the water of which they write. It is refreshing to see a "hook and bullet" book that does not try to browbeat you with the authors casting expertise or remembrances of the West of long ago. This is a very good, easy touse guide on idaho water. If you are going ther, buy it.
Rating:
Summary: A really helpful guide to fishing Idaho
Review: This book is the best Idaho guide I have seen. It has clear directions (especially for people who are not familiar with Idaho), plenty of maps, and good complimentary information such as fly shops, motels, and restaurants. It is well written without being condescending, yet it is of just as much use to the experienced flyfisher as it is to the novice. I have not tried out all the streams and lakes listed (obviously), but Retallic and Barker's descriptions and evaluations match those of the fly shops on the internet as much as could reasonably be expected. If I could fault anything, it would be that the book is 5 years old and many things can change in that time. I would really like to see an update. Other than that, I would rate it 4 ½ to 5 stars.
Rating:
Summary: A really helpful guide to fishing Idaho
Review: This book is the best Idaho guide I have seen. It has clear directions (especially for people who are not familiar with Idaho), plenty of maps, and good complimentary information such as fly shops, motels, and restaurants. It is well written without being condescending, yet it is of just as much use to the experienced flyfisher as it is to the novice. I have not tried out all the streams and lakes listed (obviously), but Retallic and Barker's descriptions and evaluations match those of the fly shops on the internet as much as could reasonably be expected. If I could fault anything, it would be that the book is 5 years old and many things can change in that time. I would really like to see an update. Other than that, I would rate it 4 ½ to 5 stars.
Rating: 
Summary: Very good and through book
Review: What an excellent guide! Very through. Great maps. The book covers every drainage in Idaho from ice out to ice over.
<< 1 >>
| 
