Aphrodite : Book One

Rating:
Summary: Beautiful, but expensive
Review: This book is beautiful in many ways, but is disappointing at times. The combination of Louys' text and Manara's art is a sure winner. Originally published in France with the original French text, this English version chooses an anonymous, but wonderful, translation from the 1920's. Following a long tradition of publishing this work with sensuous illustrations, the publisher has come up with a new approach. They will publish an original one volume novel in four volumes and illustrate each with the work of a different artist. This first volume contains 15 full-page watercolors by Milo Manara, an artist better known for his adult comics. Those expecting Manara to have converted Louys' sensual story into a graphic novel may be surprised that this is not the case. Where Manara shines as a comic artist, his watercolors are uneven. While some are outstanding, the painting of the statue of Aphrodite is a disappointment. The illustrated binding and layout is sumptuous... This promises to be a beautiful set with Georges Bess and Wendling slated to illustrate volumes 2 and 3. It is wonderful to see Louys' work getting this lavish treatment. The text is still vibrant enough to take on the sensual artwork of these modern artists....

Rating:
Summary: Beautifully rendered take on Shaw's Pygmalion
Review: When I first opened the book, I was caught into the lyricism and straight-forwardness. It's a fascinating story of a well-known and highly in demand courtesan who aims to seduce a sculptor. The sculptor falls for her and aims to please her, but once she is his, she falls into the shadow of his beloved statue. The story of sumptious, and I finished it in two days. It isn't for everyone, but for anyone interested, it is an excellent read.

Rating:
Summary: Beautifully rendered take on Shaw's Pygmalion
Review: When I first opened the book, I was caught into the lyricism and straight-forwardness. It's a fascinating story of a well-known and highly in demand courtesan who aims to seduce a sculptor. The sculptor falls for her and aims to please her, but once she is his, she falls into the shadow of his beloved statue. The story of sumptious, and I finished it in two days. It isn't for everyone, but for anyone interested, it is an excellent read.