Dark Legacy (Magic the Gathering, No. 10)

Rating:
Summary: Not Exactly the greatest book ever written...
Review: ... though i HAVE read worse. The author makes the same mistake many post-rerelease Star Wars authors do; he goes out of his way to put the source material into the book. Many of the references to M:TG cards are nothing more then that, references to cards. They don't integrate into the story too well. This really hurt the books impact on me, because every once in awhile there'd be some stupid pointless reference that had no reason to be there except to be a reference. I myself LOVE the game, but this book just doesn't cut it for me. The first "trilogy" (Whispering Woods, Shattered Chains and Final Sacrifice) was much better.

Rating:
Summary: Dark and compelling are what best describes this book!
Review: Even though the characters are a little flat, their unique personality more than makes up for it. Yunnie is more of a mystery than anyone else since he claims that he is minotaur (even though he is human) and that his past is shrouded in mystery. Well written and imaginative.

Rating:
Summary: Solid and serious fantasy novel - 3.5 stars out of 5
Review: This book was much more complex than I expected from a Magic:The Gathering tie-in. I bought it because of the author, and I was not disappointed. It has many good elements, although one or two of them did not sit as well with me as the others. The book has a very strong start, intriguingly presenting numerous characters in diverse settings, then slowly tying them all together. Most of these characters I found fascinating. A bit of the middle of the book got a little slow on one of the plot threads, but the ending was pretty strong. Well worth checking out. I greatly enjoyed a scientist/scholar character - unusual for a fantasy novel! The quest for a lost city scenario was really cool!

Rating:
Summary: Solid and serious fantasy novel - 3.5 stars out of 5
Review: This book was much more complex than I expected from a Magic:The Gathering tie-in. I bought it because of the author, and I was not disappointed. It has many good elements, although one or two of them did not sit as well with me as the others. The book has a very strong start, intriguingly presenting numerous characters in diverse settings, then slowly tying them all together. Most of these characters I found fascinating. A bit of the middle of the book got a little slow on one of the plot threads, but the ending was pretty strong. Well worth checking out. I greatly enjoyed a scientist/scholar character - unusual for a fantasy novel! The quest for a lost city scenario was really cool!