The Comfort of Strangers

Rating:
Summary: Campy little romance holds some fun
Review: Long ago in an Intergalactic Corridor far, far . . . well you get the idea. This futuristic, science fiction story is a different kind of novel for Peggy Herring, typically a romance writer. Comfort of Strangers involves a coalition of cultures, including a few female-only ones, that are struggling against the neighboring "evil empire" of Corlon, under the leadership of a heinous and destructive man named Exidor.

The novel focuses on Lela, a young healer turned scientific researcher and her mother's partner, Kricorian who is a sort of administrative leader for the "K Sector," an agricultural planet that also trains healers. The borders between the coalition and Corlon are decaying. Corlon star fighters are launching raids on these peaceful inhabitants. Their primary defense is provided by the warrior-focused, all female culture of Amtec. Their warrior women have an impressive reputation as skilled and lethal fighters as well as phenomenal lovers.

Members of the coalition have decided to hold a summit to sort out differences and decide what to do about the increasing raids. A delegate to the summit, Lela has the royal attention of the beautiful young Tavia, the Amtec princess. Yet Lela is drawn to the enigmatic commander of the Amtec warriors, Alaric. Tall, blonde and beautiful, Alaric has risen through the military ranks by her impressive intellect, strength and self-discipline. This highly respected leader carefully hides her feelings and seems to be sending mixed messages to Lela. Is she just following orders?

Although Lela is the lead character and the focus of amorous speculation and attention; Lela's other mother, Kricorian is more sympathetically drawn. Widowed for 15 years, Kricorian finds herself drawn to another Amtec warrior, Jaret. Will Kricorian be able to let go of the survivor's guilt and the grief she feels for the death of Lela's mother? Can she risk her heart again? Can she relinquish control?

Herring does not suffer from any restrictions to political correctness. When Lela prepares to open a cylinder that she believes contains a live human being, she gives Kricorian a laser gun and tells her, "if it's ugly, zap it. Don't be afraid to use that thing. It's the capsule I want to study." (p 63) This attitude is a far cry from most scientific investigative standards today, never mind the ethical obligations of a healer! This is not the only example of a poor moral code among individual characters or cultures other than the dreaded Exidor and his star fighters. Tavia's treatment of Alaric is case in point.

At its best, scifi/fantasy not only entertains but provokes the imagination and prompts readers to question current cultural practices and trends in scientific research or other technological developments. Comfort of Strangers did not strike any such cords in this reader. It's a bit like watching an old "B" grade sci fi movie. The plot and characters are thin. The dialog has a campy sort of quality that makes for some amusing reading. However, it doesn't seem certain that was the writer's goal. In conclusion, Comfort of Strangers is not a bad story. However, it does not stand up to many far more interesting, complex, action packed scifi/fantasy stories that have been released in recent years from lesbian writers.

Rating:
Summary: Great romance, so-so sci-fi
Review: Peggy Herring has consistently put out great works of fiction with characters that are likeable and unique. Fans of her work don't read for extensive plot, it's for the great character development. For me stories are character-driven and plot is secondary.

In "The Comfort of Strangers" the character development is as intriguing as in the rest of her books. There is humor, passion, confusion, and all ranges of emotions. As a lesbian romance it is top notch.

As science fiction... well, it leaves a lot to be desired. Anyone who enjoys watching science fiction movies will be a bit disappointed in this book. While some of the concepts are great (use of "Lidium" to power forcefields), what this book lacks is some punchy sci-fi vocabulary. Star Trek fans know what I mean... instead of unique phrases like "The Borg", "holodecks" and "photon torpedo banks" you have things in the book like "Star Fighters" (generic bad guys), "lasers" (generic space ship weapons) and "stun guns" (generic hand-held weapons). The unimaginative non-technical-sounding language detracts from the science of the fiction.

However once you get past that, you'll see that Ms. Herring's gift lies in character creation. Despite the weakness in the sci-fi department, I thought the character names were rather unique, imaginative and appropriate for the book. The character interactions are realistic and enjoyable. All in all this book is a lousy piece of science fiction, but an absolutely wonderful romance!

Rating:
Summary: Great romance, so-so sci-fi
Review: Peggy Herring has consistently put out great works of fiction with characters that are likeable and unique. Fans of her work don't read for extensive plot, it's for the great character development. For me stories are character-driven and plot is secondary.

In "The Comfort of Strangers" the character development is as intriguing as in the rest of her books. There is humor, passion, confusion, and all ranges of emotions. As a lesbian romance it is top notch.

As science fiction... well, it leaves a lot to be desired. Anyone who enjoys watching science fiction movies will be a bit disappointed in this book. While some of the concepts are great (use of "Lidium" to power forcefields), what this book lacks is some punchy sci-fi vocabulary. Star Trek fans know what I mean... instead of unique phrases like "The Borg", "holodecks" and "photon torpedo banks" you have things in the book like "Star Fighters" (generic bad guys), "lasers" (generic space ship weapons) and "stun guns" (generic hand-held weapons). The unimaginative non-technical-sounding language detracts from the science of the fiction.

However once you get past that, you'll see that Ms. Herring's gift lies in character creation. Despite the weakness in the sci-fi department, I thought the character names were rather unique, imaginative and appropriate for the book. The character interactions are realistic and enjoyable. All in all this book is a lousy piece of science fiction, but an absolutely wonderful romance!

Rating:
Summary: A new direction for Herring
Review: The Comfort of Strangers is a new direction for Peggy Herring. She's taken her style of writing love stories and gone into science fiction. The book centers around Lela, a scientist, who has been raised in a society of lesbians. Her settlement is united with several others in a trade/protective group that includes a settlement of lesbian warriors and the other societies are mixed. Someone is threatening the safety of these societies, but no one is sure who the threat is. The story develops at a quick pace, maybe a little too quick in some places, but it keeps you engaged as women establish relationships and try to save their people from disaster. There's a character named Alaric who turns out to be especially interesting. The book could use a little more development in some areas, but is an enjoyable read. The nice thing about Herring is that, if you read her books in order, you see that her style is constantly improving. She also knows how to write an enticing love scene without going too far over the edge.