Rating: 
Summary: Great Revival.
Review: I happen to think this is a great jump on point for any reader, it explains all of the characters, and their relationship with Oliver. I had only heard of Green Arrow before reading this Trade by Kevin Smith, whos' dialogue was not overtly crude, with moments of somewhat "dirty" things. I love how the story deve3loped, and the plot twists it had, i really wish smith would write more comics.
Rating:
Summary: Green Arrow: Master Bowman and Hero
Review: Green Arrow is a classic hero, who has endured the test of time. Until he blew up. Then no one really gave a...well...didn't really give anything at all about good ol' Oliver Queen. Until a guy named Kevin Smith came into the picture.
Quiver is one of the best graphic novels I've ever read, and really got me reinterested in comics. The wonderful combinations of action, sci-fi and supernatural are perfect for a ressurection. There's mystery, intrigue and all that, and even some guest appearences by Supes, Bats, GL (Kyle Rayner), WW, MM, blah, blah blah. And did I mention Hal Jordan and Etrigan?
Basically, this is an excellent book which you will probably read about 3 times in a single year. A real page turner, this story really gets you thinking, trying to solve the various mysteries and ultimatley recreates extreme interest in the Green Arrow character. I REALLY highly reccomend this well-put-together book.
Rating: 
Summary: Messy and meandering.
Review: Believe me when I say that I was looking forward to reading this series the way a kid growing up in the early 80's would be on Christmas morning knowing that an Atari 2600 was waiting under the tree. I mean, talk about your tasty yin-yang combo with hardcore fanboy Kevin Smith resurrecting the cult favorite Green Arrow. But alas, was I ever left winded after slogging through this 10 issue mess of a series. How did this Model T break down? Couple of key stumbles in my opinion:1) Poor plotting and pacing - This is a comic book for pete's sake! Don't wait till issue 8 before we cut to the crux of the action and are formally introduced to the arch villain of the series.
2) Painful dialogue - While I love Kevin Smith's penchant for dialogue in the movies for some reason the dialogue sounds completely awkward. Especially bad are the lines given to teenage characters. At best they sound like shoddy attempts to mimic Joss Whedon-speak, ala 'Buffy.' Then again, for those of you completely enamored with the D.C. Universe this series is definitely a 'not-to-be-missed,' but for those of you unfamiliar with G. Arrow this is not exactly the best introduction to the character and his storyline.
Rating:
Summary: Smith Scores a Bullseye
Review: First up let say I've been a Marvel Universe guy most of my disturbingly long comic book life. I've dropped into the DCU enough to keep tabs on the major characters and the big events (Zero Hour, Death (ha) of Superman) but I've never been a strict follower of DC contiuity. Certainly I knew only the basics about the Green Arrow - he was Robin Hood, he hung out with Hal Jordan's Green Lantern. Oh, and apparaently he died. But on the strength of Kevin Smith's name I gave this a go. And man was it worth it. In the intro Smith mentions he copped some flak about using too much DC continuity, making it too hard for the casual reader. Well, I am that casual reader and I had no problem with the story at all. Sure things were referred to, and I probably didn't get every single reference but it certainly didn't detract from the enjoyment. This is a great story, well told. Oliver Queen is a great character, no-nonsense, cynical and fun, and the cameos from the other DC big hitters who thought he was dead are great. Yes, it's wordy but the words are great. The humour is strong and the drama is emotional. It's more adult than a lot of super hero comics and darker in it's themes. Probably not for younger readers. Not every issue has action but I hardly cared, so strong was the story. I wasn't entirely sure about the artwork by Ande Parks and Phil Hester at first (I like a more realistic style of penciling generally) but I ended up loving it. Minor cavil: How about publishing the covers as full pages instead of four to a page in a cover gallery? Especially covers this good. The best compliment I can give this collection is that I'm not only going right out to chase more of this new Green Arrow, but I'm also hunting down the classic Arrow of the past as well. If are an Arrow-head past or present, or just like terrifically entertaining super hero tales well told then don't miss this.
Rating:
Summary: Rebirth or Coming of Age
Review: Having been a fan of the DC Universe for four decades now, I was surprised at how quickly The Quiver was able to draw me in. Generally, I've been disappointed by the attempts of many to "resurrect" classic heroes for a new generation. Too often these stories have been unable to blend a respect for the past with a new, engaging tale. Kevin Smith's Green Arrow was different. Having finished reading it, twice now, I am increasingly satisfied the further I explore. Oliver Queen is not only resurrected, both figuratively and literally, he also reaches a new level of maturity in this new world. He gains a new persepctive in his social conscience. Perhaps I find this enticing because it makes him so much like those of us who grew up with him. The Green Arrow was, to an entire generation, an Everyman. Kevin Smith has succeeded in bringing our hero back to us, an Everyman still, fighting for honor in the world around him. Now, however, his is changed by the world rather than existing apart from and above it. I find myself once again anxious to read the next installment in the now unfolded history of Oliver Queen.
Rating: 
Summary: good smith...unsure about ollie
Review: here are my opinions...
this is fairly good (and rather typical) kevin smith fare. if you are about to pick this up, and are a fan of the old green arrow...i have no advice for you, as i only picked this up, because it was done by smith. now, as it was done by smith, it is bound to have some of his style in there...
his style consists of a good deal of words. this guy loves words.
if you buy comics, and do not like to read, then do not buy this. smith uses words to enhance his stories, which are full of charecters. he brings in random guest appearances for seemingly no reason other than...he can.
deal with that. there are just mildly random dc heros and villians that show up, if only for smith to get a chance to write them. the story behind quiver is well thought out, and delves a little deeper than most comic fare (i say most, ruling out things like sandman, etc...) for me, it was an entertaining read, and an interesting concept for how to bring back a deceased hero. a little gimicky at times, but hey, this is a wordy comic book, not actual tolstoy
Rating:
Summary: Kevin Smith's Green Arrow MASTERPEICE
Review: I am a young comic fan who diddn't know a thing about The Green Arrow. My Pop was a major comic fan who stopped years ago. When I started and he found our that Oliver Queen (a.k.a. The Green Arrow, for those who don't know)had been resurected, He quickly started reading the Green Arrow once again. That trade paper back was lying around the house on a day I had nothin else to do and I decided to read it. Little did I know that was what I was doing the rest of the day. I couldn't keep myself from reading it. I quickly became a Green Arrow fan and read his monthly title every time it comes out. Kevin Smith has never ceased to Amaze me with his comic book writing talent. This is probably one of the best Stories I have ever read. I have now read the book 4 times going on 5. This is a must have, even if you HATE comic books. And for those Novel readers that read those big fat books like stuff from Stephen King or those best sellers, You would love this. The best comic ever.
Rating:
Summary: Green Arrow is back
Review: I had never read a Green Arrow story but I was somewhat familiar with his background history because of his appearances in Batman (who I am a big fan of) and JLA. I always thoguth he was a somewhat predictable supehero suffering from a Robin Hood Complex. I decided to read Quiver just because of Batman's role in the story....and after reading it, I am a Green Arrow fan. The story moves at a right pace with art that perfecly complements it. It begins with Oilver Queen's resurrection and his subsequent "examination" at the hands of batman (which was very entertaining by the way). It is a great story and shows why Green Arrow is an integral part of the DC universe and not just another Robin Hood wannabe superhero.
Rating:
Summary: The best comic out now
Review: I hadn't read comics for over 2 years, but my adoration of Kevin Smith led me to get this book. His characterization of Green Arrow is the best I've ever read. This book is great for new readers and those who are deeply familiar with DC Comic's staggering continuity. With appearances by Batman, Hal Jordan(Spectre), Arsenal, Black Canary, Barry Allen, Aquaman and the JLA, it is one great read. After reading this book, I am now proudly back reading comic books.
Rating:
Summary: Best Resurrection Story Ever
Review: I haven't picked up a comic book in 2 and a half years, but I bought this pretty hardcover, and I am once again a fanboy. Oliver Queen isn't just a superhero archer. Kevin Smith has given this character life (in more ways than one). These stories will wow those who pay attention to continuity(past storylines, character's relationships, life-altering events of other heroes), and it would also be a great read for someone who has never picked up a comic. Phil Hester and Ande Park's art team is the best in comics in my humble opinion. So buy this book and also keep reading.
|
