Rating: Summary: The Author Should be Ashamed!!! Review: Please, If your looking for a good Star Wars book, please don't choose The Crystal Star. I would give it 0 stars if I had the chance! It's boring from start to finish and it's so bad, I donated it to the public library! Now that's pathetic!
Rating: Summary: Fascinating Review: Firstly, I think people are being WAY to harsh Mcintyre. This book is AWESOME, albeit wordy. Lighten up people, a woman CAN write Star Wars just as good as anyone else.
Rating: Summary: This book RULES! Review: First of all, whoever said women can't write Star Wars books is WRONG! This book was awesome! Hethrir seemed really evil! I couldn't put this book down. Read it!!!!
Rating: Summary: PRETTY GOOD, BUT A LITTLE BORING Review: I hadn't known that Leia and Han had kids until I read this. And I think that it was a very good book; the second star wars book I'd ever read. I really enjoyed it, and liked "getting to know" the Solo children. It was boring, in some parts, cause I mean, we know that Leia is in her ship, and that she's flying off right? Who cares what numbers or how many she puts into a computer, who cares about the presis way that she flew away? I didn't and that was the boring part. Other than that, it was pretty good.
Rating: Summary: Is this for 3rd Graders? Review: This is like one of those 20 page SW books enhanced to 400. Everything is just laid out nothing is left for you to discover. Aside from the reading level allthe action if that's what you want to call is at the end. Another thing Luke is a wimp just like in Barbera Hambly's book. Last time I checked Chewbacca had above normal healing abilities.This got two stars, because if your're really young this book will be good. Other than that Mcintyre just messed up the SW characters and universe.
Rating: Summary: weird, and cool Review: I loved this book. It was really weird, but that was what I liked about it. It's my favorite of all the Star Wars books I have read (by the way, I've read 36 of them). Some of the other reviews say that it is only good for a kid to read. Maybe that's true, because I'm only twelve, but my mom read it, and she liked it to, so I would ask the reviewers to please be a little bit more polite. Thank you.
Rating: Summary: DISGUST. Review: Those who liked this must either be lunatics or 8 year olds who never saw SW movies. The typical result of an idiotic trekkie woman trying to meddle with the star wars universe
Rating: Summary: Doesn't deserve to be part of the Star Wars universe. Review: This was without a doubt the worst Star Wars book I have read. Vonda McIntyre showed that she had no knowledge whatsoever of the main characters, particularly Luke and Han. She portrayed them badly, giving aspects to their character that a good Star Wars fan would be repulsed by. Buying this book was a waste of my money and the only reason it got one star from me is because that is the lowest I could go.
Rating: Summary: What happens when you let a woman write science fiction Review: Well, damn i read the reviews here and i didn't listen to them, i bought the book, read it and tossed it to my cat's litter box. It's depressing to have to destroy a book. Esp. when it was from Star Wars. Listen close folks don't read this stinker. If you have taste or discernment about your Star Wars, then don't taint yourself with this Bantha fodder. Sorry, but women can't write a man's character for sh#*&%.
Rating: Summary: Good book Review: I think this was a good book. I have read many Star Wars books and this one is worthy to be a Star Wars book. Although it was hard to understand at some points, it was still good.
|