Rating: Summary: Very poorly written Review: I am very disappointent. It is outright boring stuff. Heroes are just sketches, names with not a bit of real life or emotions behind them. Incomprehensive sorsery, stupid empire, stupid plot, stupid dialogs, I got bored out of my mind at the first half of the first bool already. Just had to read it through before donating to the local library. These books are a good example how not to write fantasy.
Try Robin Hobb or Guy Kay for a taste of first class writing
Rating: Summary: A grim outing for Devlin Review: Devlin is betrayed by King Olafur and handed over to his chief enemy, the mind-sorcerer who almost destroyed him in book 2 of this series. Olafur thinks this will seal the alliance with Selvart that he has sought to secure his borders and that Devlin's life and loyalty is a small price to pay. However, Devlin himself has other ideas on the matter.In some ways this book is an anti-climax. Much of the story is not told from Devlin's point of view and as the land of Jorsk descends in to all out war we are told a grim tale with almost no lighter moments to break it up. In the end Devlin makes the best compromise possible out of a bad situation, but at the same time many of Devlin's key emotional growth points never really seem to be explained in a way that makes you feel more for him as a character. For the last book in a series in many ways this book seems to be a pause rather than a stopping point for Devlin's story, and it would have been nice to at least have seen him gain some happiness from all his sacrifice, instead we are almost left hanging as much could still happen to him given the state the Kingdom is in at the end of this book. The series almost deserves a 4th book if it can lighten up a little.
Rating: Summary: Saving the best for last Review: I had mixed feelings picking up this book. I've enjoyed the first two in this series and was sad to know that it would be ending. But at the same time I was eager to find out how Devlin's story would turn out. Devlin's Justice exceeded my expectations. It's darker that the first two books, as Devlin finally comes face to face with the unseen enemy who has been stalking him. He manages to defeat the prince, but that's only the first of the many challenges that he'll face. Ultimately Devlin will have to decide where his loyalties lie, and each of his friends will also have to choose between their sworn oaths and their friendship with the Chosen One. Bray does a nice job of pulling all the threads from the first two books together as she builds to the ultimate climax, and Devlin's final showdown with those who betrayed him. All in all, it's a great read and a fitting successor to the first two books in this series. Highly recommended.
Rating: Summary: Saving the best for last Review: I had mixed feelings picking up this book. I've enjoyed the first two in this series and was sad to know that it would be ending. But at the same time I was eager to find out how Devlin's story would turn out. Devlin's Justice exceeded my expectations. It's darker that the first two books, as Devlin finally comes face to face with the unseen enemy who has been stalking him. He manages to defeat the prince, but that's only the first of the many challenges that he'll face. Ultimately Devlin will have to decide where his loyalties lie, and each of his friends will also have to choose between their sworn oaths and their friendship with the Chosen One. Bray does a nice job of pulling all the threads from the first two books together as she builds to the ultimate climax, and Devlin's final showdown with those who betrayed him. All in all, it's a great read and a fitting successor to the first two books in this series. Highly recommended.
Rating: Summary: Devlins Justice - Did the Author really do herself justice Review: I really enjoyed the first two books they had a lot of depth to them with well developed characters and a great stories that I really enjoyed. The third book while good does not hold a candle to the first two books. I got the impression that the author rushed this book; there were many gaps, and incomplete scenes in this book compared to the first two book of the series. Do not get me wrong I liked the book but as one reads its like the story was rushed so that it would be published instead of the well crafted tales I enjoyed from the first two books of the series; In the end of the book I felt a little let down compared to the other two books. The story does tie some ends up but it also left many areas that in the story that could have been developed more than they were. The Author got us into the first two books by givng us insight to a tormented character that changed every few chapters so that you come to realize that devlin is a very rich character, many of the characters are well developed and we are given insight to a man and how he can effect the destiny of a kingdom. The third books starts off slow compared to the first two, and the events seem cut short and not as well developed as previous story's were laid out for us. All in all I liked the book but was not brought into the story as I was with the previous two books, she does leave the book's ending with the possiblility that she may do another book to this series or maybe even do a whole series based on the 5 yrs that devlin's regency will take place; I only hope that she develops some of the events more than she did in this book I felt that the event of devlin freeing his country would have entailed more to it than him just saying to the council hey I will do this for you if you free my country.
Rating: Summary: A disappointing end Review: In this, the third and final book of the series, Devlin is forced, time and again, to decide where the path of honor lies. It has all the classic ingredients for a good fantasy read - the capture and torture of the protagonist, the final dénouement with the evil sorcerer, the invasion of Jorsk by enemies, and the death of friends and comrades along the protagonist's path. Unfortunately, there is no characterization in this book and thus I had zero empathy for Devlin, his friends and comrades, or even his enemies. I was particularly disappointed that Devlin's Duncaer heritage does not play in part in this story - he might be entirely of Jorsk for all it seems to matter. Like other reviewers before me, I believe that Bray needs a fourth book in this series to really tie up the emotional loose ends she leaves hanging. If that book comes out, go ahead and get this one as a bridge to understand what has occurred. Otherwise, read the last chapter at your bookstore if you really want to know what happens and spend your money at Amazon on a better book.
Rating: Summary: A disappointing end Review: In this, the third and final book of the series, Devlin is forced, time and again, to decide where the path of honor lies. It has all the classic ingredients for a good fantasy read - the capture and torture of the protagonist, the final dénouement with the evil sorcerer, the invasion of Jorsk by enemies, and the death of friends and comrades along the protagonist's path. Unfortunately, there is no characterization in this book and thus I had zero empathy for Devlin, his friends and comrades, or even his enemies. I was particularly disappointed that Devlin's Duncaer heritage does not play in part in this story - he might be entirely of Jorsk for all it seems to matter. Like other reviewers before me, I believe that Bray needs a fourth book in this series to really tie up the emotional loose ends she leaves hanging. If that book comes out, go ahead and get this one as a bridge to understand what has occurred. Otherwise, read the last chapter at your bookstore if you really want to know what happens and spend your money at Amazon on a better book.
Rating: Summary: Sstirring fantasy Review: King Olafur of Jorsk knows his grip on the kingdom is not solid so he asks the Empress of Selvaret to honor an old treaty with his country by sending soldiers to battle Jorsk's enemies. When the Ambassador of Selvaret arrives at court with his retinue, he tells the king that the Empress has sent men to Korinth in the eastern part of the Kingdom, to guard against enemy invasion. In return the king is to turn over Devlin of Duncaer to them. Olafur agrees knowing whatever they have in mind for the people's hero isn't good. The King hands over Devlin to the Selvaret ambassador who in turn gives the people's hero to the Prince Consort Arnaud. Devlin is angered that his king betrayed him and knows that no matter how much he is tortured, the magical geas laid upon him won't let him betray Jorsk. When he is finally able to get free, he organizes a resistance to fight the Selvaret Protectorate who is deed if not in name already annexed one third of the kingdom. The third installment in The Sword of Change series DEVLIN'S JUSTICE is an enthralling sword and sorcery series. The hero has grown throughout the three books from someone who was suicidal to a leader of men. There is a lot of action in this novel but Patricia Bray fully develops her prime characters, even many secondary players, so readers get a well rounded and satisfying novel. Devlin is such a fascinating and complex character that it would be a shame if his adventures came to an end even with this stirring fantasy. Harriet Klausner
Rating: Summary: Sstirring fantasy Review: King Olafur of Jorsk knows his grip on the kingdom is not solid so he asks the Empress of Selvaret to honor an old treaty with his country by sending soldiers to battle Jorsk's enemies. When the Ambassador of Selvaret arrives at court with his retinue, he tells the king that the Empress has sent men to Korinth in the eastern part of the Kingdom, to guard against enemy invasion. In return the king is to turn over Devlin of Duncaer to them. Olafur agrees knowing whatever they have in mind for the people's hero isn't good. The King hands over Devlin to the Selvaret ambassador who in turn gives the people's hero to the Prince Consort Arnaud. Devlin is angered that his king betrayed him and knows that no matter how much he is tortured, the magical geas laid upon him won't let him betray Jorsk. When he is finally able to get free, he organizes a resistance to fight the Selvaret Protectorate who is deed if not in name already annexed one third of the kingdom. The third installment in The Sword of Change series DEVLIN'S JUSTICE is an enthralling sword and sorcery series. The hero has grown throughout the three books from someone who was suicidal to a leader of men. There is a lot of action in this novel but Patricia Bray fully develops her prime characters, even many secondary players, so readers get a well rounded and satisfying novel. Devlin is such a fascinating and complex character that it would be a shame if his adventures came to an end even with this stirring fantasy. Harriet Klausner
Rating: Summary: Disapointing Review: This book read like a report of activities, only less interesting. Great deamatic scenes were covered without any special attention : And then this happened, and then this happened, the end. Great fantasy plot, could've been treated better. If the whole series were as strictly spare and dry as this it would be ok, but the first books were different. Consistancy doth a great read make, and this book was inconsistant with the rest of the series. If it were a concious choice on the author's part to write a book in this style that's one thing, but the way the writing changed partway into the series it looked like she just got tired of it all and ground her outline out onto the paper. Like she just wanted to get it over with, was bored with the whole thing . And it had so much promise....
|