Rating: Summary: As usual, J.M. Dillard does a fine job. Review: This author is unquestionably the best at novelizing episodes or movies. The same author has done many Star Trek novelizations, and they've all been fine jobs. This one is no different; I admit that it's been a while since I saw the episode, but this certainly FEELS faithful to what I remember. The characters certainly come across well, and the storyline seems essentially unchanged.
Rating: Summary: good Review: this is a really well written boo
Rating: Summary: Good for a Star Trek novelization... Review: While this does not exactly qualify as great literature, for a Star Trek book it's pretty darned good.Based on the pilot Episode of DS9, it pretty much sticks to the plot of the episode, but it doesn't make the mistake so many do. The author doesn't try to stretch the episode to fit 275 pages, but instead fills in all the extra with background for the characters, both major and minor, so that we have a better idea of who we will be seeing through the series. It is relatively well written, although a few scenes do fall flat on their face when the author fails to adequately convey sarcasm or humor, and the prophets just didn't make the transition from TV to novel very well. All in all, if you are a DS9 fan, this is worth reading.
|