Rating: 
Summary: SPECTACLUAR!!!!!
Review: Micheal Stackpole has outdone himself with this book. If you read it and you read bacta war theres alot of familiar charecters in it.
Rating:
Summary: good story
Review: pretty good story. I don't think the price is that bad, considering all pages are in color
Rating: 
Summary: It is a good book but...
Review: The price isa my only problem, everywhere I went it was expensive, a lot of old chacters though, and I liked that, (Mainly from Bacta War) But in the X-Wing series (Written by Micheal A. Stackpole & Aaron Allston) were bigger and cost half of the price! For some reason that doesn't make since. But like I said, This book is an excellent book, and I also believe that if they cut their prices they might actually start selling more and getting more $$$$$$$$$$$ That's always important right? I'm probably going to read the whole series, but I'll do my best to wait and see if they go down in prices.
Rating: 
Summary: Disappointing
Review: Thi sisn't even for die hard fans unless they have money to throw away. The art was passable but the story was weak, devoted mainly to action with little support. Even the characters who weren't created just for the comic (Wedge Antilles, Bib Fortuna, et al.) all acted about the same. I recommend picking up Dark Empire if you want a good Star Wars graphic novel instead of this.
Rating:
Summary: Disappointing
Review: Thi sisn't even for die hard fans unless they have money to throw away. The art was passable but the story was weak, devoted mainly to action with little support. Even the characters who weren't created just for the comic (Wedge Antilles, Bib Fortuna, et al.) all acted about the same. I recommend picking up Dark Empire if you want a good Star Wars graphic novel instead of this.
Rating:
Summary: this book rulez
Review: thie art work is great, some minor detials where wrong, but it was the 1st issue so that is to be expected. a must get
Rating: 
Summary: Book includes an unadvertised bonus
Review: This edition includes a 13-page story that appeared only as an insert in Apple Jacks cereal. It was great working with Mike Stackpole, by the way! Thanks for the following (and other) very complimentary reviews!
Rating:
Summary: This is a Graphic Novel
Review: This is a graphic novel, i.e. "comic book", originally serialized in the Star Wars: X-Wing, Rogue Squadron comics series.
Rating: 
Summary: Tycho and Winter, love on sultry Tatooine?
Review: This is actually the second TPB of this series collecting issues 9 to 12. volume 1 was poorly done and never made a TPB. Volume 2, The Phantom Affair, TPA, had as its only real flaw a drab cover. Battleground Tatooine, BT, has a spectacular Cover and then the rest is a slight drop off in comparison with TPA. Nadeau's pencil work lacks some of the detail and there are many more lazy artist panels in TB vs TPA.
Story gets a 4, Cover a 5, Pencils 3.5, ink and coloring a 3.5 for a grade of 3 stars.Key players in this comic areCapt wedge Antilles, Lt. Tycho Celchu, Elscol Loro, Admiral Ackbar, Lt. Wes Janson, Dllr Nep, Plourr Ilo, Hobbie Klivan, Windmere Wellen, the blond after wedge, Winter, with grey hair who is interested in Tycho, Huff Darklighter, Ko'Shak, Cazne'olan, Sixtus Quin, and Kapp Dendo.
The story here sets but some events in the Bacta War book. The story here sets but some events in the Bacta War book.
Rating:
Summary: Tycho and Winter, love on sultry Tatooine?
Review: This is actually the second TPB of this series collecting issues 9 to 12. volume 1 was poorly done and never made a TPB. Volume 2, The Phantom Affair, TPA, had as its only real flaw a drab cover. Battleground Tatooine, BT, has a spectacular Cover and then the rest is a slight drop off in comparison with TPA. Nadeau's pencil work lacks some of the detail and there are many more lazy artist panels in TB vs TPA.
Story gets a 4, Cover a 5, Pencils 3.5, ink and coloring a 3.5 for a grade of 3 stars. Key players in this comic areCapt wedge Antilles, Lt. Tycho Celchu, Elscol Loro, Admiral Ackbar, Lt. Wes Janson, Dllr Nep, Plourr Ilo, Hobbie Klivan, Windmere Wellen, the blond after wedge, Winter, with grey hair who is interested in Tycho, Huff Darklighter, Ko'Shak, Cazne'olan, Sixtus Quin, and Kapp Dendo.
The story here sets but some events in the Bacta War book. The story here sets but some events in the Bacta War book.
|
