Rating: 
Summary: its...different
Review: This manga is definitely a must have for any gundam fan, which is why i still gave it 5 stars, but i would not rate it as one of the best gundam works. First of all, it moves way too fast, i mean, its almost at the mid point by the end of the book! Secondly, whats with the use of action words everywhere?? I mean, "Rage" and "Shake"?? i think those are kind of obvious actions if you look at the pictures. Then of course i have the problem with heero....he changed dramatically from the series...its really hard to believe he was ever the kind-hearted boy from the flashback in endless waltz. Theres not much detail as i hoped there would be, but its got the gundam name and the gundam boys we all know and love so well so what more could you ask for? ....ahem, well i guess there is still a lot, but thats besides the point! ATTENTION: DO NOT, I REPEAT, DO NOT LET WUFEI TOUCH YOUR VIDEO GAMES...HE WILL DELETE THEM.
Rating: 
Summary: For people who don't feel like watching the 49 episodes
Review: I'll keep this review simple. the writer of this summerizes what happens in the saga with three books. I find nothing wrong with the book except that sometimes he sometimes excludes parts that I considered important. But this is a minor detail. Also a plus with this book and the other two is a bonus part that are short stories that include the G Gundam cast as well as Wing which is quite enjoyable.
Rating:
Summary: Good
Review: This is a nice Manga. The sound affects are cool, the storyline is cool, and the artwork is really good. In my opinion Gundam, is better than Nen Genesis: Evangelion. I like manga better than Anime anyway. A lot of you complain that this is nothing like the show, but most mangas aren't a substitute for their anime counterparts. The character development does g kind of fast, though. Definetly worth buying. If you're a Gundam Wing, Manga,Comic, Anime or Gundam fan, you'll love this book. If you were able to, I would give this book a four and a half out of five. ~Dan~
Rating:
Summary: A Good Manga Novel, A Little Different from the Series
Review: Essentially, this is the Gundam Wing episodes condensed to fit into a graphic novel form while retaining as many of the main elements of the show as possible. This first book covers the series from the Gundams arrival on earth up to the point where the 5 scientists have built the Vayeate and Mercurius for OZ, and the pilots have returned to space. The story moves at a much faster pace than the show, as several have noted. The characters appeared fairly true to their show counterparts in this first novel, but their are some slight differences in personalities that fans of the show will quickly note. These differences may be due to the pace that doesn't allow for a lot of character development. The art is great and some of the mini-comics at the end are kind of funny. Overall it is a decent adaptation, however there is thing about it that really annoyed me. The Japanese manga reads right to left, opposite to us Americans and many others, so that their books are done in a manner that seems backwards to us. The publishers of the book simply flipped, or mirrored, the artwork so it could be read from left to right. This means that every suit holds its weapons opposite of how it should, some dialogue seems to come at an awkward time, etc. It is still worth checking out if you really like Gundam Wing and want a slightly different slant on the story.
Rating:
Summary: A very good mixed-bag
Review: Usually, reviews tend to be nothing more than formal opinions. I'll try to write a review that really reviews this book. First of all, I do not recommend this book to die-hard fans of the anime, as they will definately be offended by it. Also I don't recommend it to those unfamilar with the anime, for this book will undoubtedly confuse them. In both cases, how? Compared to the show, this manga is a lot more fast-paced and cuts out many plot pieces that liven, sometimes even define, the anime. The characters are sometimes a little "distorted" and have little chance for character development, and the dialogue at times can be weak. And depending on your tastes, the way the sound effects are sounded might seem really stupid ("Step Step", "Turn", "Rage"). But it does have its high points. The Gundams themselves are drawn rather nicely, the plot is easy to follow and understand if you know the series pretty well, and unlike American comic strips (that I know of, at least), frames sometimes "blend" into each other instead of remain static rows of art panels ("Inu-Yasha" is a perfect example of this). But we always have to return to the story's fast pace, which will either be loved or loathed. To me, however, I feel this story is targeted to a reader who wants to enter the Gundam universe without having to watch all 49 episodes and thus the complex plot. This book can leave many parts up to the reader's imagination, which I think is nice. Of course, a complete series manga would've have hurt, but that's a different story. All in all, the actual comic is good but not great. So why did I give it four stars? The "Domon" strips in the back of the volume! Whether they're funny or not depends on your own personal humor, but for me they were absolutely hilarious! If the comic eventually becomes boring, these will most likely entertain you long afterwards! Luckily for us Americans, this comic wasn't made especially for America; Japan got this manga as well (in Japanese, of course), so we weren't cheated out of a "real" Gundam manga. While this comic is decent, there are better, more fulfilling manga series out there ("Inu-Yasha", "Fushigi Yuugi", "X/1999", and "Magic Knight Rayearth" are good examples). In the end, I recommend this to Gundam fans who want to relive this classic series without worrying too much about its complex story. Whether or not you'll like this mange is all up to you, though.
Rating: 
Summary: Hmm....
Review: Well, this definitely wasn't the best manga I've read. I know most comics move a lot faster than a TV series, but this seemed to go *too* fast. If I hadn't seen the whole GW series before I read this, I seriously doubt that I would've understood much. You don't find out much about the characters' personalities. I haven't read book #2 yet, so I don't know if they go into that anymore either. The art wasn't anything to write home about either, and to me Heero just looked...mental? Now I know he's pretty insane and all, but this comic just made him out to be maniacal O.o And I don't know if it was just my comic that was like this or what(I bought it here), but the ink seemed like it wasn't supposed to be as dark as it was. Too much black and not many gray tones. The mini chibi Domon Wing strips that they had at the end were pretty cute & funny though ^_^ I absolutely *love* Gundam Wing, but this book really didn't do anything for me. You'd be better off buying doujinshi(fan made comics).
Rating:
Summary: Very Cool
Review: I got this book at Borders today-er, technically yesterday as it's almost 2 AM-and was trying to convince myself to finish what I was doing (writing a very in depth summary including like ALL dialogue for GW ep 4: Nightmare at Victoria) when I decided to start reading it on my way to the bathroom. I started reading (and unfortunately had to stop after my little break), and pretty soon got so hooked I had to stop in the middle of my summary to read. After that I didn't pause except to hit the record button on the VCR for Gundam Wing: Uncut (can you tell I'm obsessed?) until I was done. It was great. The story line was kinda different and moved a lot quicker but that always seems to happen in manga to anime (like Sailor Moon) or anime to manga (like GW). My favorite part was the Chibi Domon W at the end-the characters were so cute! And, naturally, it was hysterical. (Relena got a lot of attention, which pleased me cos she's my fav.) My only problem besides the slight change in plot and speed of events was that Heero seemed...different. He seemed to have less of that "antisocial, thinks he's Evil Kanievel (sp?), and hardly speaks" thing goin' on, and of course the fact that Duo never got a chance to say that made me a bit upset. Yet I'm finding myself reaching to read it again before I even read my other book which i stopped in the middle of (2099 number six: firestorm. read it) despite the fact that it's a real sit on the edge of your seat type book. But I'm not here to review that. Read the first GW graphic novel. It's great.
Rating:
Summary: Cool Manga
Review: This is definately worth buying. The character developments are really good. The storyline is similar to the original Gundam 0079 storyline. 5 young men each gundam pilots,try to oppress the goverment OZ. The art is beautiful. This graphic novel comes with the first 4 gundam manga comic books. It has a bonus comic at the end, a comedy collection of comic strips. A must buy manga.
Rating: 
Summary: A TRAVESTY!!!!
Review: Okay, I looooooove Gundam Wing. But I'm not a big fan of mecha in itself. Why? Gundam Wing had a complex, twisting plot, beautiful art, and complex characters.
I may love Gundam Wing, but I hate this manga. They cut out a lot of details, and made it move waaaaay too fast. They didn't have time for the characterization that made the TV series great. Plus, the publishing job is AWFUL. Mixx has destroyed it again! The size is tiny, but the font is huge. They shortened Mobile Suit to MS. The printing is cheap quality. The ink actually *smears* if it gets the tiniest but moist. The sound effects are lame at best.
If you want a Gundam Wing book, get Blind Target, Ground Zero, or Episode Zero. And watch the TV series. But whatever you do, do NOT get the books.
Rating:
Summary: An interesting series, but not the best out there.
Review: With the market starting to recognize how much people love manga, titles that would've most likely never have seen the light of day in America several years ago are now appearing in droves. Many of these series are quality titles that truly show how manga is done right, but some of these titles are ones that were released to capitalize on a sudden trend. The three-volume "Mobile Suit Gundam Wing" manga is one of the latter group, and while it's not bad, it isn't something a serious manga reader would want to have in his collection. The "Gundam Wing" manga tells the story that takes place during the 49-episode anime series. However, readers familiar with the series will notice two things: (1) the manga moves at a much faster pace than the anime; and (2) several plot elements have been changed, altered, or omitted. While the second factor isn't too much of a bad thing, the first factor is what really hurts the manga. Scenes that took up several episodes in the anime series suddenly take only a few pages, which removes quite a bit of characterization. In the first volume especially, the story doesn't feel smooth or connected, but more like a plot summary. The story does feel a lot smoother and better developed as the series continues, but the overall impact is hurt by the rushed plot. It also unfortunately makes the "Gundam Wing" manga fan-only publications, as only fans of the series will understand the plot. In regards to the second factor, the changes and omissions in the story are actually a matter of taste. Some people might not like the idea of having their favorite anime scene cut from the manga, but others might actually like the changes and refreshing look at the series. Of course, omissions and alterations do mean that character appearances and personality developments are altered somewhat, but an open-minded "Gundam Wing" fan might actually enjoy reading a different "version" of the anime series. Visually, "Gundam Wing" can't be called the most visually-appealing manga on the market today. Characters do look like thier anime counterparts, but not in a detailed kind of way. However, the actual Gundams and all other mobile suits are drawn rather nicely, so fans of the mecha shouldn't be disappointed. If the artwork of the manga had to be called something, I'd say it is slightly above average. In regards to the translation, "Gundam Wing" unfortunately shows the badside of TOKYOPOP. It's easy to see that the type-like text was written using a machine, and this resulted in some unfortunate spelling errors (ie "Leader" instead of "Lead her", "Berge" instead of "Barge", etc.). And the translation as a whole is sadly mediocre, as it feels stiff and emotionless, showing how little the translators cared about this manga. Why else was Trowa called Noin in the first volume? Because the translators didn't put in the effort to check their own work. Still, if you can stand a bad dub on an anime, then the translation shouldn't be too much of a hindrance. But the manga does have a really good feature going for it: the "Domon W" strips at the back of each volume. Essentially, these are four-panel strips that use chibi-like representations of the characters of "Gundam Wing" and "G Gundam". Some of these strips are downright hilarious, some of them are completely lame, but they definately bring up the value of the manga volumes. All in all, "Gundam Wing" cannot be called the best manga out there. It's painfully obvious that TOKYOPOP released the series quickly to capitalize on the booming interest in the then-recently released "Gundam Wing" anime; if they had just paid more attention to the translation, the manga would've been so much better. But as it stands, the three-volume manga series can only be recommended with reservations. If you're looking for good "Gundam Wing" manga, rather try "Episode Zero" or "Blind Target". If you want good manga in general, try "Inu-Yasha", "Nausicaa of the Valley of Wind", or "Battle Angel Alita".
|
