Vedic Physics

Rating:
Summary: Finally!
Review: Author should also read Swami Yukteswar's "Holy Science," published by Self-Realization Fellowship. It confirms many of the concepts in your book. Yukteswar was a yogi of high realization, notably featured in an Evan Wentz book and Yogananda's Autobiography of a Yogi.

Excellent book and thanks!

Rating:
Summary: good book
Review: For readers who do have knowledge of modern science will be able to understand this book. As it just details vedic science and relates it with modern science.

Rating:
Summary: Interesting speculative physics or metaphysics
Review: Having read the book carefully, I can say that it speaks of some interesting characteristics of the mind reflected in the Vedic hymns that mirror the world of physics. I believe this is what Subhash Kak also seems to say in his foreword to the book. In other words, this book is not about physics but rather it represents the connections between the physical world and the structure of the mind. One might call this subject speculative physics or metaphysics. It is not the clearest exposition of such metaphysics, and this made me struggle to decide whether to give the book two stars or three stars. I chose the latter number for its sheer originality.

Rating:
Summary: Explaining the Vedas with help of modern science
Review: I was skeptical about this book, but when to expect nothing, all the suprises are positive - this book certainly proved to be excellent. This book contains a very good explanation about the origins of Vedas and points way to true meaning and purpose of the Vedas, is pleasant to read and very interesting, you have to read it! :)

Rating:
Summary: Where is the science?
Review: I've always been interested in this subject matter ever since I saw Carl Sagan's "Cosmos" miniseries (where he mentions Hinduism's approach to cosmology). Unfortunately we ordinary people overlook and thus miss out on deeper meanings in our own books. The Rg Veda is the heritage not only of Hinduism, but of all humanity. Roy's interpretations were, to say the least, mind-blowing. I was fascinated and read the book in a day. I can't wait to read it again. There are a lot of Sanskrit words, but the "glossary" at the end was a very helpful reference. Whether you agree with him or not, this book is written by a brilliant scholar and his research is very thorough. I have recommended this book to other friends and relatives of mine, so I can have someone to discuss it with! I urge you also to read it, esp. if you are from India, it will make you proud.

Rating:
Summary: Interesting speculative physics or metaphysics
Review: In case you did not know, Soma is a hallucinogen widely used in the Vedas. I am just kidding about the rating. I gave this book a 5 star so that my review should come out on top. And this book is not even worth the money you are paying to be online and see this review. Read on for the truth.

This guy is crazy. After Vedic Mathematics dazzled me no end. I was keen on reading this one too. But it has been a huge disappointment.

Well, if his interpretation of the Vedas is so perfect, how is it that he has not come up with any new physical principles that have been described in the Vedas? Or have the Vedas chronicled the physics only upto the 21th century? No Unified Field Theory in the Vedas?

All I can say about this book from the Indian perspective is that it is an insult to all the Rgvedi Brahmins in India and abroad. A debauchery of their literary heritage. Something that they preserve.

Thanks, Mr. Author. Thanks for telling me that what I chant daily after my bath is a treatise on high velocity sub-atomic particles. Anything else? Is the Rgvediya Sandhya some sort of inter-planetary morse code or something? Did you drink Soma before you started off on this literary tourney?

Please, we are adults out here, some of us partially educated. Yes, even in India. The cenus puts the literacy rate at 65%.

Give up writing, become a politician in India. Your theories could do wonders for the fascist incumbent thugs there.

regards, Onkar Joshi

Rating:
Summary: Vedic Physics: Recovering Science's Hidden History
Review: Recovering Science's Hidden History

"Vedic Physics: Scientific Origins of Hinduism" - Raja Ram Mohan Roy, Ph.D.; Golden Egg Publishing (Toronto, Canada) 1999

Reviewed by William Courson

Raja R. Roy was born in India and studied at Indian Institute of Technology and Ohio State University, earning his doctorate in materials science and engineering and is a working research scientist. Professor Roy has penned a fascinating and very readable little volume (248 pages) on the scientific origins of Hinduism as reflected in the Rig Veda, in his view an allegorical work describing the origin, structure and function of the physical universe. Dr. Roy ably defends an idea that has always been known; namely, that the Rig Veda has two meanings: the apparent and the actual.

On its face, the Rig Veda seems to be a book about cows and horses, clouds and weather and crops - a collection of the songs of a pastoral people - without a hint of organization. Why would such a writing be considered by so many to be the source of all knowledge from time immemorial? The only rational explanation is that the songs and poetry of the Rig Veda encapsulate a hidden message, which it itself clearly states:

"The Vedic mantras are in the never-decaying remotest sky, wherein the gods reside. One who does not know that, what will he do with the Vedic mantras? one who knows that, the gods stay with him." (1.164.39)

One simple fact has obscured this obvious conclusion for a very long time; Vedic scholars have enjoyed little knowledge of contemporary science, and scientists have little knowledge of the Vedas. The Vedas are considered eternal, and logic demands that an eternal book cannot contain only stories about the mundane doings of human beings and their agricultural pursuits. There needs to be something more.

From a detailed and protracted study of Vedic literature, many have concluded that the sacred words are but a representation of the creation and unfolding of the universe, the process of cosmology. According to the author, the knowledge of cosmology, of physical processes and particles, of the creative-destructive interplay of matter and energy contained in the Vedas is very abstruse, and thus was and is still well beyond the comprehension of ordinary humans. Therefore, the Vedic sages coded their knowledge in a simple form in which the underlying principles and processes could be taught and understood.

The Rig Veda was composed about five thousand years ago and is likely to have existed as an unwritten source of knowledge ages before that. We know very little about the scientific achievements and less about the scientific ideas of our ancestors. The question necessarily arises: is it possible that there were highly advanced civilizations in past, whose technological achievements and their theoretical framework have been forgotten? In Professor Roy's view, the answer to that question is "yes," and there can now be objective verification of this because the Rig Veda has been so remarkably well preserved in that most scientifically exact of languages, Sanskrit. The scholars of ancient India went to heroic lengths to preserve every word of the Vedas, and they are in the same form today that they have been in for millenia. The question is why? Why did generations of Indians go to so much trouble to preserve the Vedas, while their apparent meaning seems to be so mundane, so inconsequential?

The reason the author affirms is that Vedas are coded, and once that code is understood, it has such a powerful message that it cannot help but transform one's perception of reality. This book describes the scientific meaning of the Vedas (focusing on the Rig Veda) and other Hindu scriptures and compares them with currently accepted scientific teaching. The nature of atomic and subatomic particles, gravity, electromagnetism, the cohesive forces of the universe, the wave function and entropy have all been anticipated and described in the words of the Rig Veda. The twentieth and twenty-first centuries have witnessed merely their rediscovery.

This is a delightfully written book, and one that is easily understood by the reader without a technical scientific background (although the latter is helpful). Professor Roy is superlatively skilled at conveying subtle points simply and effectively, and this volume is a worthy addition to the library of any student of science, history or religion.


Rating:
Summary: A bold reinterpretation of the Vedas
Review: Roy makes an excellent combination of Vedic textual evidence, together with modern physics, to present his thesis that the Vedic rishis had ``intuited'' several aspects of contemporary science. Seems a fantastic view, but Roy marshals considerable evidence in support of it.

The 19th century colonialist approaches to the Vedic texts were a dead-end. Now we have the elements of a surprising and plausible new view that complements the traditional mystical interpretations of the Vedas. I recommend this book strongly.

Rating:
Summary: Good Intentions - Could have been better.
Review: The Book seemed to be a reflection of the "Cosmic Science" I had discussed with my parents & siblings since Childhood.. The Author is well versed in Physical science but sometimes mis-interprets the Vedic phrases leaving "mush to be desired"... For example, in the Purusha Surta, there is a verse saying the "Legless purusha Attained legs"; well the word for leg in sanskrit is "paada" meaning part. So the sentense would be, the undivided had divided itself... That would be close to a rational mind.

Also, the use of the term "God" is a no-no when explaining the RGveda. Purusha denotes the ABSOLUTE.

On the whole, I would call it a Very welcome step in explaining the Vedas. The forthcoming versions might see a lot of corrections :)

Rating:
Summary: Good Intentions - Could have been better.
Review: The Book seemed to be a reflection of the "Cosmic Science" I had discussed with my parents & siblings since Childhood.. The Author is well versed in Physical science but sometimes mis-interprets the Vedic phrases leaving "mush to be desired"... For example, in the Purusha Surta, there is a verse saying the "Legless purusha Attained legs"; well the word for leg in sanskrit is "paada" meaning part. So the sentense would be, the undivided had divided itself... That would be close to a rational mind.

Also, the use of the term "God" is a no-no when explaining the RGveda. Purusha denotes the ABSOLUTE.

On the whole, I would call it a Very welcome step in explaining the Vedas. The forthcoming versions might see a lot of corrections :)