No Place for a Lady

Rating:
Summary: Doesn't ring true
Review: I really wanted to like this book, which I hoped was a worthy successor to Greyle's last two books, which were truly outstanding. In spite of a rather doubtful plot description, I decided to risk it because of my confidence that if anyone could could write a great book with this setting, Greyle was the one.

Well, she didn't quite manage it.

It's not just Fanny's background as the illegitimite daughter of a politician and an actress that makes her an unlikely match for an aristocratic lord. She changes personae at the drop of a hat, from a bawdy tavern wench to a street-wise underworld character playing a dangerous game with two rival mob bosses to a spy trying to prevent an assassination.

The basic idea of elevating someone from the lower classes is not new. It has been done quite successfully by many authors. But Fanny just seems too far down. It's no wonder Lord Chadwick persists in seeing her as a whore throughout most of the book. Not only was she raised around a promiscuous mother who died of the pox (!!!), but after her mother's death, she lived among thieves and prostitutes and learned from them how to survive in a cruel world. (It is truly unbelievable that she could still have her virginity after living this type of life.)

Throughout the book, Fanny insists that she is more comfortable in the streets than in the drawing rooms of the ton. However, both of the crime bosses have seen through her disguises and intend to kill her. There is no place to hide. She has no money. It is all very admirable that she wants to help the children, but it makes no sense to keep going back there when her life is in danger.

Marcus, Lord Chadwick, persists in trying to get Fanny to be his mistress. He doesn't even think twice about marrying her. . . what would his mother think if he brought home a ... as a bride? He persuades his sister to launch her in society, inventing a respectable background for her, but he can't stand seeing her with any other man. Even after a very honorable man courts her with a view to marriage, Marcus can't see her as anything but his mistress. As a hero, Marcus doesn't measure up.

I appreciate Greyle's attempt to promote social activism and equality through the character of Fanny Delarive, but it just seems too contrived to ring true. But by far the worst flaw is the lack of romance. I mean, let's face it, how romantic is it when the hero keeps thinking of the heroine as a ... and how he can't marry her because of his family obligations? In the end, I am not convinced that he knows the difference between love and lust. Nor am I convinced that a marriage between two such unequal partners would be accepted by the rigidly intolerant ton, even if the mother-in-law problem could be resolved.

Rating:
Summary: engaging Regency romance
Review: In 1807, at his London house, Lord Penworthy informs his visitor Lord Marcus Kane in front of whore Fantine Delarive that someone tried to kill House of Commons MP Wilberforce. Stunned that a vulgar woman would be at their meeting, Marcus is further shocked when his host asks the two guests to work together. Though both agree to perform their patriotic duty Fanny will be paid for her efforts. Marcus, though experienced in espionage in France, needs a guide to work his way through the serpentine slums of the rookeries where the first clues will take the sleuths.

As they work as a team, Marcus realizes that first impressions mean nothing. He sees his partner act very comfortable as a lady attending an aristocratic soiree. Marcus also receives an education into the life of the poor chidlren living and in some cases thieving in London's slums. As the duo's efforts lead to danger, they fall in love. Marcus desperately tries to persuade Fantine that they belong together, but she worries that her beloved blue blood could never accept her work on behalf of the impoverished children.

This engaging Regency romance provides readers with an insightful look at a way of life just a short distance from the typical Ton that star in the sub-genre novels. That absorbing glimpse provides a host of characters some nameless that enables the audience to better understand the cheeky heroine. Perhaps Fantine adapts to easily to everything like a chameleon (who is the real Fanny?), but fans will appreciate this feisty woman and the metamorphosis of Marcus who recognizes what a treasure she is.

Harriet Klausner

Rating:
Summary: engaging Regency romance
Review: In 1807, at his London house, Lord Penworthy informs his visitor Lord Marcus Kane in front of whore Fantine Delarive that someone tried to kill House of Commons MP Wilberforce. Stunned that a vulgar woman would be at their meeting, Marcus is further shocked when his host asks the two guests to work together. Though both agree to perform their patriotic duty Fanny will be paid for her efforts. Marcus, though experienced in espionage in France, needs a guide to work his way through the serpentine slums of the rookeries where the first clues will take the sleuths.

As they work as a team, Marcus realizes that first impressions mean nothing. He sees his partner act very comfortable as a lady attending an aristocratic soiree. Marcus also receives an education into the life of the poor chidlren living and in some cases thieving in London's slums. As the duo's efforts lead to danger, they fall in love. Marcus desperately tries to persuade Fantine that they belong together, but she worries that her beloved blue blood could never accept her work on behalf of the impoverished children.

This engaging Regency romance provides readers with an insightful look at a way of life just a short distance from the typical Ton that star in the sub-genre novels. That absorbing glimpse provides a host of characters some nameless that enables the audience to better understand the cheeky heroine. Perhaps Fantine adapts to easily to everything like a chameleon (who is the real Fanny?), but fans will appreciate this feisty woman and the metamorphosis of Marcus who recognizes what a treasure she is.

Harriet Klausner