Rating: 
Summary: the very best kind of folly . . .
Review: It's very true that a less-than-terrific book by Dorothy Gilman is still much more fun to read than an excellent one by a lesser light. This book is so well set-up that I fell head-long under its myriad charms, but kept falling out again for the strangest reasons. That's why the 4 rather than 5 stars. Andrew Thale is sent by his businessman father to western Massachusetts from their home in Manhattan, to inspect a supposedly neglected property that had belonged to Aunt Harriet Thale, who died five years before the opening of this story. An unhappy young man, Andrew has suffered a nervous breakdown after a plane crash, causing him to have a monumental case of writer's block. Even though he's had two well-regarded mystery novels published, he seems unable to write anything at all anymore. Not even interesting tid-bits for the company newsletter, a position handed him by his father. Off Andrew goes in the company Mercedes. Although not all that far away in hours or miles, once he finds the place, it proves to be centuries removed from today's world. For Aunt Harriet was a collector--of people who were down on their luck a bit, or had no other place to go, or were generally looked down on by Society. She assembled a truly great household of delightful eccentrics, and promised them that they could stay there forever. And so they have. Miss L'Hommedieu could have arrived on a "Streetcar Named Desire" embodying as she does the ancient southern belle, wrapped in layers of chiffon, and sporting beautiful old-fashioned hats. She entertains her fellow householders by writing a paragraph of a new story and reading it to them every evening. Problem is, it's a different story every time, and she never continues any of them. She only does beginnings. To digress a moment--what wonderful beginnings they are, too! They almost make one wonder if perhaps Ms. Gilman had resurrected them from her younger days. If so, I do wish she'd finish some of them. They're wonderful! Back to the book . . . Then, there's Gussie, who practices Wicca quite openly, to the general admiration of the nearby townsfolk, as well as her own housemates. Leo is a well-educated and well-read Marxist, who delights in quoting passages from the great philosphers through the ages. This came in handy when Tarragon Sage Valerian--so named by Miss Thale, who claimed that privilege after finding the baby on her doorstep--made her appearance. Tarragon is much loved by all, regardless of her birth, and has been very well-educated in her home school, organized by Leo. But the house--Thale's Folly--well, the money left by Miss Thale dwindled, and the electricity was turned off. Followed, of course, shortly thereafter by the water. Fortunately, there is a creek and a pond on the twenty-five acres around the house, and some of those acres are put to good use as vegetable and herb gardens. The little band survives, in spite of themselves. This is the situation when Andrew arrives; he's totally confounded by everything. Doing all the wrong things first, however, he is their inadvertent saviour. When his room is ransacked, he stumbles over the missing will while searching for something to read. He then discovers his long-lost Mother living most happily in a cabin on the other side of the pond. All too soon, the gypsies have arrived, and Andrew has miraculously found his next book in a trunk in Miss L'Hommedieu's room. All the loose ends are neatly tied up in the last ten pages. Therein lies my major complaint. It's TOO rushed! There are just too many loose ends still dangling when one turns the final page. More! I want more! Please! Actually, this book had such a gentle, naïve feel to it, one could almost think it was an early book by Ms.Gilman, perhaps even pre-dating the illustrious Mrs. Pollifax, or the Clairvoyant Countess. It had such a very 50s feel to it, the sudden mention of a cell phone or computer was quite jarring. Plus all those wonderful beginnings by Miss L'Hommedieu were crying for middles and endings. Even with these niggles, though, it was still a most enjoyable book. With an added bonus--an alert to the newest Mrs. Pollifax adventure. Hooray!
Rating:
Summary: A wonderful read.
Review: Novelist Andrew Thale has some problems in his life. His dad is overpowering enough as a father, but what makes life even tougher is that he is also Andrew's boss. Andrew's father has sent him to a make an assessment of the property an eccentric aunt left them five years ago. Once there, Andrew meets a group of people as eccentric as his late aunt and finds himself mixed up in the mysteries of their lives. The surprise for Andrew and his family is that the lives and mysteries of these people help to solve some serious problems in their lives. Dorothy Gilman is an exceptional writer with a lot of success behind her name, and if you ever read the Mrs. Pollifax series or any of her stand-alone mysteries you will understand why. In reading Thale's Folly, I noticed it read more like general fiction than a mystery. Although hints toward the mystery are dropped here and there, it doesn't take off until half way through the book and even then the author focus more on the characters and their lives than the mystery. Don't misunderstand me, I still liked the book, it was a personal eye opener for me. I loved the characters, they are convincing and unusual, and the transition from city to country was so clear that I felt myself relaxing along with Andrew Thale. It's an enchanting, compassionate story that, to me, took on the form of a parable with it's ending.
Rating:
Summary: A wonderful read.
Review: Novelist Andrew Thale has some problems in his life. His dad is overpowering enough as a father, but what makes life even tougher is that he is also Andrew's boss. Andrew's father has sent him to a make an assessment of the property an eccentric aunt left them five years ago. Once there, Andrew meets a group of people as eccentric as his late aunt and finds himself mixed up in the mysteries of their lives. The surprise for Andrew and his family is that the lives and mysteries of these people help to solve some serious problems in their lives. Dorothy Gilman is an exceptional writer with a lot of success behind her name, and if you ever read the Mrs. Pollifax series or any of her stand-alone mysteries you will understand why. In reading Thale's Folly, I noticed it read more like general fiction than a mystery. Although hints toward the mystery are dropped here and there, it doesn't take off until half way through the book and even then the author focus more on the characters and their lives than the mystery. Don't misunderstand me, I still liked the book, it was a personal eye opener for me. I loved the characters, they are convincing and unusual, and the transition from city to country was so clear that I felt myself relaxing along with Andrew Thale. It's an enchanting, compassionate story that, to me, took on the form of a parable with it's ending.
Rating: 
Summary: Couldn't put it down!
Review: So nice to read a mystery without gore and violence. I felt good after reading this book and actually wished there was more. Loved the characters. Wish I could find my Thale's Folly!
Rating:
Summary: Absolutely delightful!
Review: Spend a little while with a group of loveable, slightly eccentric characters, who beat the odds and manage to come out on top. You will probably end up wishing you could join them at Aunt Thale's. If you are looking for a feel-good book, this one certainly qualifies.
Rating:
Summary: A great read!
Review: The only thing disappointing about this book was when it ended. Dorothy Gilman does not disappoint.
Rating:
Summary: Just a nice book
Review: The previous readers have done a good job of reviewing, so I won't repeat. I just want to say that my wife and I thought this is one of the best books written. This along with Nun in the Closet, of course.
Rating:
Summary: Just a nice book
Review: The previous readers have done a good job of reviewing, so I won't repeat. I just want to say that my wife and I thought this is one of the best books written. This along with Nun in the Closet, of course.
Rating:
Summary: From start to finish, 4 hours, tops!
Review: There comes a time in the avid reader's life when one day you just cannot get a satisfied start on a book. I happened to see this book on a lonely shelf and I did not fail to take a chance. I began reading and was trapped after the first few pages...from beginning to end I kept reading. Each and every character has a spellbinding uniqueness. Andrew found what he needed by going to view a piece of property and a house that his father thought was left to him by his late sister Harriet. The house, unbeknownst to his, was inhabited by a distinguished group of people. Andrew fell hopelessly for each one of them. Having arrived a stagnent writer, he ends up with so much more. This is one book that should not be passed up.
Rating:
Summary: From start to finish, 4 hours, tops!
Review: There comes a time in the avid reader's life when one day you just cannot get a satisfied start on a book. I happened to see this book on a lonely shelf and I did not fail to take a chance. I began reading and was trapped after the first few pages...from beginning to end I kept reading. Each and every character has a spellbinding uniqueness. Andrew found what he needed by going to view a piece of property and a house that his father thought was left to him by his late sister Harriet. The house, unbeknownst to his, was inhabited by a distinguished group of people. Andrew fell hopelessly for each one of them. Having arrived a stagnent writer, he ends up with so much more. This is one book that should not be passed up.
| 
