Rating: Summary: A Wonderful Story Review: I picked up this book after reading a review about it in a magazine - the title and cover hinted at a story that would be odd yet appealing. I wasn't disappointed.The story is a character study as much as anything else, centered around Mona Gray, a 20-year old woman who is going through the motions - without much direction or ambition in her life. She stumbles into a job as an elementary school math teacher and has an near-romance with a young science teacher. However, her insecurities about herself and her life hold her back from going (and growing) forward. She quits at anything and everything before she even starts. Mona is also obsessive compulsive which manifests itself by often knocking several times on wood (for good luck/security) and eating soap (as behavior modification). Added to the mix is an eclectic assortment of supporting characters: her loving mother, physician father (who is suffering from some unnamed and mysterious disease), and a next-door neighbor who wears a number on a chain around his neck to indicate his daily mood (the higher the number, the better the day). Due to an unfortunate accident at school, Mona must take the scary first step and become her own person. Mona's journey is especially sweet and poignant. A little gem of a book!
Rating: Summary: Good, but it's missing something Review: I had heard a great deal about An Invisible Sign of My Own and was eager to read it. I have to say that I left it with mixed feelings. For one thing, this book was too short. It was extremely engaging and entertaining, in words it is a fable. But to tell the truth, the end seemed unbelievable and farfetched and overall disappointing. Things just didn't add up. The main plot of the story evolves around the trials and tribualtions of Mona Gray an obsessive compulsive math addict who believes that every time she gets good at something, she has to quit. A strange illness has plagued her father for most of her life. But numbers mean more to Mona Gray than they should. She knocks wood, multiplies people against each other, and loves to eat soap. But on ehr 19th birthday, she is ejected from her house by her mother. Getting a job teaching second grade math, she is shocked to find out how enthuastic young children can be. But at the arrival of a new science teacher, Mona realizes that her firm bubble of life may be popped by love- the supreme destroyer. The premise of this book is wonderful, but the ending is only second best. It didn't make me like the book any less, its just reducing from my 5 star rating.
Rating: Summary: Not Your Average Novel Review: The world of Mona Gray, the protagonist of An Invisible Sign of My Own, is full of eccentricities. Living in a small town of modern-day America, Mona interacts with many peculiar residents. There's Mr. Jones, the hardware store owner who wears a different number each day and even her own father, a dermatologist, whose suffering from some unnamed and perhaps nonexistent disease causes him to search out inventive cures. However, Mona herself probably possesses more idiosyncrasies than anyone. From the first sentence of the first chapter, one will quickly discover that there is just something different about Mona. "On my twentieth birthday, I bought myself an ax," she declares. For me, characteristics like her crazy ideas, active imagination, and obsession with numbers make Mona all the more likable. The author, Aimee Bender, has accomplished much by telling the story of Mona in prose that captivates and draws the reader away from normalcy. It is interesting to be able to visit the mind of Mona as she deals with the struggles of daily life, such as teaching her second-grade math class. How could she have known that bringing an ax (in the shape of a 7, as she pointed out) into the classroom would result in injury? When not attempting teaching her adoring students, Mona fights the hardships of love. A self-proclaimed "quitter" since the age of 10, Mona has a difficult time keeping her new love, the science teacher. These subplots weave together to create the beautiful story of Mona Gray, seemingly a story of self-discovery. Much insight to life can be gained through Mona's view of the world. I recommend this book to anyone who would like to read a refreshingly charming and funny story. Thankfully, An Invisible Sign of My Own is definitely not your average novel.
Rating: Summary: Lacks Verisimilitude, Even For a Story That's Bizarre Review: I had very mixed feelings about AN INVISIBLE SIGN OF MY OWN. There's no doubt that it's marvelously original or that Aimee Bender writes dark, but very fluid, pitch-perfect prose. On the other hand, a novel has to have verisimilitude even if it is as bizarre and almost surreal as AN INVISIBLE SIGN OF MY OWN. I found that verisimilitude lacking in this book. For one thing, the protagonist/narrator, Mona Gray, is just twenty years old, yet she manages to rent an apartment with no funds and no job. Then, she's hired to teach math at the local school despite the fact that she has absolutely no credentials at all other than a love of numbers. And there's the offbeat way she teaches math: telling the children that numbers are everywhere, in hatchets, in dead leaves, etc. Since the age of ten, Mona's life has been overshadowed by her father's hypochondria and fear of death. He doesn't have any identifiable illness; he's just sort of "fading away." (Again, not quite believable.) In an effort to save her father, to pull him back from whatever forces are pulling him away from her, Mona begins bargaining with the universe by giving up almost all of the things she loves: running, dancing, the piano, films, egg salad, even sex. The only thing Mona can't seem to give up is math. Her love for numbers and the order they bring to her disordered world overrides her desire to bargain with the universe for the sake of her father's health. AN INVISIBLE SIGN OF MY OWN is peopled with characters who are every bit as quirky and offbeat as are Mona and her father. There's Mr. Jones, Mona's former math teacher who lets the world know the state of his emotional health by wearing a number on a string around his neck; there's science fiction teacher, Benjamin Smith, who teaches his students health by having them act out the symptoms of various diseases. And, this isn't Smith's only quirk. His arms are covered with burn marks, causing us to wonder just what it is that he's been acting out himself. The quirky characters aren't all adults. Mona's math class is made up of little tyrants, mini-monsters, children who are simply too observant for their own good. Bender's theme, that love can overcome death, has been done many times before, and, truthfully, it's been done better than Bender does it here, but to her credit, she does give it a fresh and original spin. There's certainly nothing wrong with Bender's prose; it's witty, graceful and it's gently nuanced. And, even though it's dark, it's never ponderous or heavy. Bender has written this book with a light touch despite its sad, and sometimes, complex, subject matter. A lack of verisimilitude is the main reason I gave this book two stars instead of three (should be two and one half, really). Whether we create an entirely new universe or stay firmly rooted in this one, we have to let our readers know the boundaries and criteria of that universe and Bender simply didn't do that. The story and the characters just weren't as "fleshed out" as they should have been and the ending was too contrived and not at all believable. There is a lot to like in AN INVISIBLE SIGN OF MY OWN, but, unfortunately, there are some things not to like as well. I think Bender is a fresh and funny writer who is highly original, but I think she has to work on the art and craft of novel writing a bit more. Right now, I think she does quite a bit better with the short story.
Rating: Summary: Definitely over-hyped Review: I actually got this book for free from someone at my work, and I thought "Great, looks like a book just up my alley." However, I now understand why the person who owned the book gave it away. The protagonist, Mona, has a mental disorder which should make her an interesting and sympathetic character, but she is written about in such a way that I never feel she is real, and not only that, I don't really like her much. I feel like this was an interesting concept of a book--that is, if I told you about the characters and events in the book over dinner it would sound like a good book. Unfortunately, when I actually read the book it seemed to drag, and plot features seemed too pat, things weren't fleshed out enough to make them seem real, and the characters were flat (I think the author feels that giving her creations quirky tics is enough to make them characters--but an interesting tic does not always make a fleshed out-let alone interesting character). Overall, I'd recommend skipping this book, there's definitely better books to read.
Rating: Summary: Very cute, sweet story, but needs a reality check Review: I'm presently in the middle of this book and can't help but stumble over little details. For instance, Mona is 19 years old, and moves out, but doesn't yet have a job. What place will rent to her w/o her having a work history, or money? And she immediately gets a job as a math teacher, without any kind of degree or credential. In most places in the US, one must have a credential to teach, except in some private schools. In addition, except in some private or alternative schools, grammar school generally consists of one teacher, one room, one grade, until one reaches middle school. And while multiple classes with multiple teachers *does* happen [I went to such a school], this is the exception, not the rule. So why isn't it mentioned Mona teaches in a private school? I know I'm picking nits, but little reality issues like this irk me and keep me from otherwise enjoying an otherwise enjoyable story...
Rating: Summary: knock on wood Review: Bender's quirky novel is absolutely captivating. If you're a fan of the band Soul Coughing read this book-- the whole time I was reading it reminded me of their music-- rhythmic and beautiful.
Rating: Summary: silly yet sad, entertaining and wacky. my kinda book. Review: the main characters life is one of compulsions, strange family members, and people in her life that all somehow connect and make life a little bit stranger. (i felt "at home" in such a book!) it has very funny little moments that made me snicker, and i grew compassion for the characters of the book. i read it in two days so that means it was a good one!
Rating: Summary: Odd, enchanting Review: Aimee Bender's poetic style is perfectly suited to this strange but transfixing novel about an obsessive compulsive teacher's and her journey toward emerging from her self-imposed emotional cocoon. I wouldn't call it an enjoyable read per se, but I certainly enjoyed this novel and its bizarre protagonist. I was never sure whether to laugh, cry, or be disgusted, especially during the unforgettable axe scene. I have rarely found books so imaginative and relishsome as this one.
Rating: Summary: Poetry. Review: An Invisible Sign of My Own is filled with a rare poetry. Aimee Bender has a talent for seeing moments through the most interesting lenses, and capturing them in plain, beautiful language. The story is odd and minimal, but very real (real even though perhaps implausible -- does that make any sense?), very touching.
|