<< 1 >>
Rating: Summary: She had a second chance to win his heart Review: Lily London had loved Max Sheridan ever since she was a seventh-grader and Max Sheridan was the senior star of the football team. Max had married someone else, though, and had left Amarillo, Texas. Now, several years later, Max has returned to help run his mother's diner while she recuperates from a broken leg, and Lily finds herself still in love with Max, and loving Max's little boy Nate, too. Max, however, had given up on his faith in God, and Lily longs to show Max that God is always there for him, through good times and bad. As obstacles come into their path, though, can Max and Lily find love with one another, or will they be torn apart once again?This book was almost bipolar in nature. There was Lily, who was considered to be superhumanly kind and compassionate, almost to the point where she was a doormat, allowing everyone to walk on her. Even though people would say things to rile her, she'd just let it go and take it, instead of saying anything about it. The few times she actually stood up to someone bullying her, she felt guilty about it later. She was very weak-willed for most of the book. Then, suddenly, there was this transformation in her towards the end of the book, and she became a vengeful shrew-like person. It was like watching her dramatically change into someone completely new, and it was kind of weird. Most of the book was spent trying to convince and cajole Max into becoming a Christian again, which got really repetitive and annoying after a while. I felt really sorry for him, trying to be guilted into becoming a Christian again. The author also had the tendency to introduce something into the plot, and then forget about it. For example, Max's son Nate had a prominent role in the first half of the book, but was barely even mentioned in the second half of the book. It was almost like Nate didn't exist. Another example is the guilt Max supposedly felt for his wife's suicide, and yet it was barely mentioned at all. There was a glaring error in the book when Lily donated blood to Nate. Nate's blood was AB-, and Lily's blood was o+. Granted, I'm not a nurse yet, but I know that people who have negative blood cannot receive donations from someone with positive blood. Maybe most people wouldn't give that error a second glance, but honestly, if someone was given the wrong type of blood, the results could be disastrous. Also, Max also admitted in the book that he was in love with Lily when he used to live in Amarillo. The idea of an 18-year-old man being in love with a 12-year-old child made me VERY uncomfortable. All of these pale in comparison to a lovely sentence found on page 212. The author said, in so many words, that if someone didn't trust Jesus, he or she can't be trusted as a person. I don't know what kind of fantasy world this book was supposed to be set in, but I know that this statement is patently false. The person I trust most in this world is an atheist, and I would trust him with my life and the life of my daughter. Just because someone is not of a particular religion does not make them untrustworthy, and to assume so is just plain wrong. This elitist and false comment got under my skin, big time. I could give no more than two stars for this book, and that was a stretch, to say the least.
Rating: Summary: She had a second chance to win his heart Review: Lily London had loved Max Sheridan ever since she was a seventh-grader and Max Sheridan was the senior star of the football team. Max had married someone else, though, and had left Amarillo, Texas. Now, several years later, Max has returned to help run his mother's diner while she recuperates from a broken leg, and Lily finds herself still in love with Max, and loving Max's little boy Nate, too. Max, however, had given up on his faith in God, and Lily longs to show Max that God is always there for him, through good times and bad. As obstacles come into their path, though, can Max and Lily find love with one another, or will they be torn apart once again? This book was almost bipolar in nature. There was Lily, who was considered to be superhumanly kind and compassionate, almost to the point where she was a doormat, allowing everyone to walk on her. Even though people would say things to rile her, she'd just let it go and take it, instead of saying anything about it. The few times she actually stood up to someone bullying her, she felt guilty about it later. She was very weak-willed for most of the book. Then, suddenly, there was this transformation in her towards the end of the book, and she became a vengeful shrew-like person. It was like watching her dramatically change into someone completely new, and it was kind of weird. Most of the book was spent trying to convince and cajole Max into becoming a Christian again, which got really repetitive and annoying after a while. I felt really sorry for him, trying to be guilted into becoming a Christian again. The author also had the tendency to introduce something into the plot, and then forget about it. For example, Max's son Nate had a prominent role in the first half of the book, but was barely even mentioned in the second half of the book. It was almost like Nate didn't exist. Another example is the guilt Max supposedly felt for his wife's suicide, and yet it was barely mentioned at all. There was a glaring error in the book when Lily donated blood to Nate. Nate's blood was AB-, and Lily's blood was o+. Granted, I'm not a nurse yet, but I know that people who have negative blood cannot receive donations from someone with positive blood. Maybe most people wouldn't give that error a second glance, but honestly, if someone was given the wrong type of blood, the results could be disastrous. Also, Max also admitted in the book that he was in love with Lily when he used to live in Amarillo. The idea of an 18-year-old man being in love with a 12-year-old child made me VERY uncomfortable. All of these pale in comparison to a lovely sentence found on page 212. The author said, in so many words, that if someone didn't trust Jesus, he or she can't be trusted as a person. I don't know what kind of fantasy world this book was supposed to be set in, but I know that this statement is patently false. The person I trust most in this world is an atheist, and I would trust him with my life and the life of my daughter. Just because someone is not of a particular religion does not make them untrustworthy, and to assume so is just plain wrong. This elitist and false comment got under my skin, big time. I could give no more than two stars for this book, and that was a stretch, to say the least.
<< 1 >>
|