Al-Qaeda : The True Story of Radical Islam

Rating:
Summary: very informative work
Review: Everyone in the West should read this book, and especially here in the states where all the information we get is filtered, spun, and oversimplified. This book causes the reader to question several basic precepts of the so-called war on terror. The first is that by killing all the bad guys we will solve the problem. Bush, as Burke points out, is bin Laden's most effective recruiter. Every time the US military does something in the Middle East, bin Laden's notion of a cosmic struggle between the West and Islam is reinforced. Another is that democracy is the answer--actually, as Burke demonstrates, pro-Western regimes in countries like Egypt and Pakistan have had to use authoritarian tactics to suppress popular Islamism. Finally, Burke shows how the war in Afghanistan was basically successful in destroying terrorists' bases of operations, but that the US invasion of Iraq, by giving those terrorists an new place to operate, was a major setback. Bush's advisors should give this a read if they aren't all illiterate.

Rating:
Summary: Thorough, thoughtful and well argued
Review: London Observer Chief Reporter Jason Burke was featured in the recent BBC2 documentary "The Power of Nightmares" which compared the rise of Islamic militancy with the corresponding (and equally unnerving) rise of the religious right in US politics. The rather silly cover of his book on the subject belies what is in fact a thorough, erudite, dispassionate and compelling account of the rise of Radical Islam, of which "Al Qaeda" - in its strict sense - is really only a small part.

Burke has spent a number of years in various Islamic hot spots (Saudi, Afghanistan, Kurdish Iraq) and has apparently the spent the most of the last four years doing his homework. The account he sets out (which really ought not to be a surprise to anyone but the Neo-Conservatives) is that Islamic militancy is not centrally controlled; there is no "head of the snake" except the one Western foreign policy has created in [...]. For nothing has assisted fundamentalism as a rallying point for (the in reality mostly social and political) discontent in the Islamic word than his vilification by Messrs Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz and their friends. Indeed, Burke's case is that before the Western Hawks began targeting it, Islamic militancy was, amongst its own constituents, all but dead in the water.

Burke is convincing in his arguments that Al-Qaeda *the actual organisation* was never more than a hard-core of twenty or thirty militants, was not more than indirectly associated with many of the terrorist acts attributed to them, and was dispersed, incapacitated and in large part eliminated after the war in Afghanistan. But Al Qaeda *the idea* - which is the creation of western conservative political classes - has spread virus-like amongst the Islamic world, and is a much more threatening spectacle. Ideas are a whole lot harder to kill off than individuals.

In laying the groundwork for his thesis Burke is obliged to engage with a lot of minutiae of the history of Islamic dissent (every bit-player in the last twenty years gets a mention), and this part of the book is somewhat heavy going, though it certainly leads gravitas: without it, Burke would be open to criticism for a lack of thoroughness. But otherwise, this is a stimulating and important book.

Olly Buxton