Astrology : A History

Rating:
Summary: An extraordinarily attractive historical intro to Astrology
Review: This solid, amazingly attractive history of Astrology is quite possibly the best overall book on the subject currently available in English. Although it does not replace the superior A HISTORY OF WESTERN ASTROLOGY by Jim Tester, the latter does not deal with every epoch in the history of the subject since Tester did not live to complete his work. Whereas Tester begins with the Greeks and largely ends in the Renaissance, Whitfield continues into the early modern period with the demise of Western Astrology due to the parallel collapse of the Aristotelian scientific worldview upon which astrology depended. Whitfield also focuses on the semi-revival of astrology in the 19th and 20th centuries, which has only a very superficial connection with classical Western Astrology, superficial because the scientific worldview that made astrological influences scientifically tenable to educated individuals is no longer in place.

Whitfield is not an original researcher, in the sense that he has blazed new trails in the study of astrological history, but he seems to be familiar with all of the basic materials and historians in the field of study. He does an admirable job of explaining both the scientific assumptions of the originators of the astrological synthesis that took place in Hellenistic Egypt in the two or three centuries from 200 B.C. onwards that established most of the key elements of Western Astrology. He provides clear and coherent discussions of all the major figures from Ptolemy to William Lilly. He correctly understands that astrology was not directly refuted by its various critics over the centuries, but fell only after the scientific worldview upon which it depended collapsed. Astrology fell out of favor after the 17th century because the work of such scientists as Gallileo and Robert Boyle made Aristotelianism untenable.

The book is outstanding not only for its precise and coherent narrative, but for the host of attractive illustrations. Though the text makes it one of the finest surveys of the history of astrology in English, the illustrations make the volume as attractive as many coffee table books. These illustrations are not mere window dressing. They show how intimately astrological concerns were bound up with the way both intellectuals and everyday folk conceptualized the universe from 200 B.C. to the 17th century.

I will add that Whitfield is clearly an agnostic regarding the claims of astrology. If one is an ardent believer in astrology, one might find this aspect of the book offputting. Nonetheless, even for true believers in astrology, this fine volume will remain essential as a superb summary of scholarly and academic study of the birth, development, continuation, and eventual collapse of Western Astrology.

Rating:
Summary: A good introductory work.
Review: This work attempts to trace the key role of astrology in Western intellectual life, but Peter Whitfield does not incorporate all ancient, classical, medieval, and modern sources as well as Dr. Lester Ness' recent study. Like, "Written in the Stars", it does however show that Western astrology evolved in different cultures and adapted to differing belief systems.