Rating: 
Summary: A book thats no longer significant or relevant today
Review: This work by Bucaille has already been refuted and debunked fully by Dr.William Campbell's response "The Quran and the Bible in the Light of History and Science"! -also available from Amazon. What proper 'Science' can we possibly learn from the Quran, which states that Alexander the Great looked for the setting Sun and found the Sun setting in a 'pool of muddy water'-Surah 18 v.83 onwards ! The sun must MOVE towards or around the Earth, for this to happen. And the sun also SHRINKS smaller then the Earth in order to be absorbed into a muddy pool, yes? This is in stark contradiction to Science which says the Earth rotates around the sun, and its the Sun which is stationary -not the other way around! Then in the same Surah, we learn that Alexander the Great made a dam of molten brass and iron between two mountains..! Something thats both historically and archaeologically UNTRUE and totally false and UN-proven! Then also in surah al-Muluk 67 onwards the Quran teaches that we can use the Stars for stoning the Devil (Satan)..! How scientific indeed!Dr.Campbell's Book puts it back into perspective for us by correcting a lot of the major flaws in Bucaille's. Bucaille's statements on the Bible, Gospels and Christianity itself are especially very speculative, selective and misleading to say the least. It is high time for Bucaille and his sponsors to return to the drawing board and give this 'obsolete' book a major revamp, using Dr.Campbell's scholarly comments and response as a guide. Or else, as another reviewer has said, this book will surely drift away into the wilderness of non-significance! It actually deserves "minus-Four stars"!
Rating: 
Summary: LOADS OF RESEARCH IN TERMS OF SCIENCE AND RELIGION!
Review: WHat is honestly not fair, is people lowering their feedbacks more then neccesarly, on a book, simply because it is aginast their opinions, or they don't like that the book speaks praisingly about something they dislike. I own the original of this book, and i am honestly going to say: NO ONE CAN DENY this scientist, surgeon, and mathmtecian etc... did do RESERACH. You can't deny it, even if you wnat to give him negative stars. It's a clear cut easy read book, with many scientific facts compared to what the bible, the quran as well as some of the torah, has to say. there's an introduction to each religion's belif, not opinionated. THIS man is a non-muslim! why would he lie about something and then take the time to write a book, had his observations been false? Being non-muslim, i half expected this book to be written in an answering-to tone of all the bible's "misconceptions".Unlike most books who merely state opinions and well... have no root of research, this man took time. Science is a big thing. you can't state your opinion without a theory, research, an experiment, and a conclusion. THat is exaclty what this author did.
| 
