Rating: Summary: A notable book in history; more philosophical history now. Review: Unquestionably, Russell has made a mark on the world through this book. It is an honest and personal appraisal of Christianity made by a well-known and respected thinker who valued peace, intellectual honesty and knowledge. It represents a time in the intellectual history of man when the Christian religion no longer had its tight grip on those willing to question it.As a series of essays collected in one volume, the style of this book is deceptively informal, and Russell seems to rely on the reader occasionally to have some background in the subject. Consequently, the power of his arguments may elude the reader on first viewing. But when viewed with care, this book yields several of the classic objections to Christianity that have never really been overcome by its apologists. By no means does he cover the entire debate (Michael Martin's "The Case Against Christianity," for example, is more comprehensive.) However, strictly speaking, if even a few of his objections cannot be refuted by the Church, then the point has been well made. Mixed with some of the more powerful passages are some less powerful suggestions which may seem odd even to us today. Although provocative, they can at times seem less than convincing. One must not weigh all of Russell's writing equally in this book and should take from it what works and leave what doesn't. But on definitely should *not* "throw out the baby with the bath water" or be convinced to do so by others. A necessary book to read for anyone trying seriously to come to grips with the real issues surrounding Christianity, and for anyone wanting to be literate in this debate. Add it to your library.
Rating: Summary: Ok, so he had a few good points Review: First off, let me say that I think it is rather asinine of people to expect any one individual (whether critics claim this or not) to reveal the faults of a religion and/or bestow all the answers to the religious questions that people have been wondering. Bertrand Russell had a few really killer arguments as to the existence (or rather, non-existence) of God. I found that portion of his book to be extremely interesting, though I had previously thought (but had never been able to coherently express) most of his major points. However, after that, his book falls short. I found his ideas about Sex Education (and consequently, why such a topic is a social taboo) completely erroneous. Though the book was originally written in the 1920s (or was it the 30s? I forget), so one can't really blame Russell for thinking people prudish. Other aspects of his book had problems as well, and certain sections were rather obvious and pointless, in my opinion. However, If you are looking for a book with good theological arguments, I suggest you read at least the first half of this book..
Rating: Summary: A must for everyone (including Christians) Review: There have been many contradictory opinions about Bertrand Russell's ideas on religions (esp. Christianity) and our way of life. This book expresses his general thought, and is therefore a good introductory book to Bertrand Russell's brilliant work. Before reading this book, I recommend everyone (who is interested) to first OPEN HIS/HER MIND AND BE AN INTELLIGENT AND REASONABLE READER. You do not have to agree with him to see his points. Personally, I do not totally agree with him, but I do give him a lot of credits. There are many things you can learn from his philosophy. Sit tight and start reading, and if you do not get 'fed up' when you finish reading this book, you have been an intelligent reader (either agreeing or not agreeing with him). Enjoy!!!
Rating: Summary: Internet is better Review: Personally, I think the Christian religion is stupid. Russell's book does not contain as much information on Christianity's weakness as could be found on the internet.
Rating: Summary: A Breezy read which carries off the smoke of superstition Review: You may or may not be happier upon finishing this book, depending on where your beliefs lay beforehand. But know this: once you reject the biggest Lie any society can throw at you, you're halfway home.
Rating: Summary: A truly free mind that we are missing these days! Review: What a deliberation! In a sober, non-polemical way Russell points out why he believes ALL religions (including communism!) to be both, not true and harmful to humans. Not only does he manage to show why it is highly unlikely that there is any kind of "God", but also he describes that religion is inhuman because of the pschycic terror it always has performed on humans. Instead, so he believes, man should develop a humanistic society without religion or superstition. How many free and courageous spirits like Bertrand Russell are there in these days of revival of dumb religious fanatism and fundamentalism?
Rating: Summary: This Is the Emotive Argument Against Christianity? Review: I've run across many skeptics who say this book shoots an arrow throught the heart of Christianity. I was very interested to find out how this man could supposedly singlehandedly destroy Christianity. I was extremely disappointed. from incorrect assumptions on Christian teachings to inferior logic, I wondered how anyone could possibly think this is a well thought out group of essays. It is clear Mr. Russell only wishes for the destruction of families and marriage, as well as the perversions of children. Two-thirds of the essays touch on why there isn't more freedom on sex for all. A severe waste of time and money.
Rating: Summary: Brainwashed no more! Review: I used to be a Christian, but thanks to this book I now see the light! Christianity relies on the sheepish nature of humans to follow its teachings. Ironically, without Christianity my life seems so much more full of zest and meaning. I now live as a human being and not a sheep.
Rating: Summary: A response to others who have reviewed this work Review: Though simple, the arguments russell uses are indeed powerful. he systematically dismantles christianity and exposes the many flaws that it has. If christians could be open to new ideas (obviously forbiden by the church because any religion needs followers) they would quickly see what fools they are. The bible is no longer relevent and you are only fooling yourselves believing in god. Science has taken over and it doesn't correlate with the bible. Evolution-what's in second place behind that theory.
Rating: Summary: Russell Effectively Combats Christian Theology Review: This is one of Bertrand Russell's best works. In his essays Why I am Not a Christian his several arguments provide enough fodder to effectively portray Christianity as unreasonable and a bunch of poppycock. Other essays such as "A Free Man's Worship" provides a good look into what is wrong with worshipping the unpresent God. He also provides much evidence to how religion holds back man and how much it has destroyed. A must read for every atheist or theist.
|