Prelude: 1799, 1805, 1850 (Norton Critical Edition)

Rating:
Summary: A beautiful epic, with an English Romantic spin
Review: It is interesting that Wordsworth should never have published his most impressive poem. Norton calls it the "most original long poem since Milton's Paradise Lost," and it certainly deserves to be ranked alongside the master of the English epic. This poem was not published until after Wordsworth's death in 1850, and there are several versions of it (which are included in this book). The 1798-1799 version is very short, but the 1805 is expanded and includes many epic devices which Wordsworth borrowed from Milton and others. The 1850 version is basically a revised 1805 edition. It is not necessary that you read all three versions of the poem to understand its power, but it is useful to have them all at hand like this.

The Prelude is an autobiography about Wordsworth's early life. It is full of sublime images of the world through the eyes of a Romantic, and includes some of the most beautiful imagery ever set to verse in English (I believe). Wordsworth's reflections about the evils of ambition and self-absortion, among other things, are also very powerful.

This poem has been widely quoted by such Christian authors as CS Lewis, and has been admired by many great English poets. It is truly a masterpiece, an epic poem done in the tradition of English Romanticism. You can get this poem in many compilations, but usually in abridged form. This edition features the poem in its entirety, and in three version. This poem is essential to any study of English Romanticism.

Rating:
Summary: five stars
Review: This book articulates a vision of the world and of the emotions it inspires in a cerebral, yet densely imaged poem. Wordsworth did not want the poem published for fears that it was too self-absorbed; adressing earlier reviews that have made this complaint, it is true that the poem is self absorbed in that it presents the vision of the world from an individual perspective...as all poems do. I find Eliot's use of quotations and footnotes drawing on his banks of memory and reading to be far more self-absorbed than this: a poem intended to communicated clearly. It is true that it is personal in that it was written to a friend with devotion and love, but this does not detract from the power of the language, the power of the vision, and the impact of the poem upon the age(s). As for comparing Wordsworth to a modernist, that comparison is difficult to make as the modernists rejected the romantic's formal language and optimism (both present in the prelude, despite moments of recognition of a bleak 'wasted' world).

Rating:
Summary: Beautiful
Review: This is arguably one of the most profound epics to come out of the British Romantic period. If you are interested in the works of the Romantics at all -- much less Wordsworth in particular -- this should be a cornerstone of your library! This biographical epic poem takes the reader on a journey through the adventures, angst, and artistic development of Wordsworth himself. A truly beautiful work of art from a most revolutionary literary period in the history of England.

This Norton version includes all three published editions of the poem: the original 1799, and the lengthier 1801 and 1850. In this particular volume, Norton has set the 1801 and 1850 side by side, allowing for examination of differences between the two editions and thus making it an invaluable critical resource as well as a remarkable literary accomplishment.