The 11 Myths of Media Violence

Rating:
Summary: Lots of great stuff, but still not definitive
Review: The first half of the book is excellent. I was prepared to give it a full 5 stars as a comprehensive overview of the various effects of media violence (both negative and positive). But unfortunately, some careless writing sneaks into most of the second half of the book, with subtle exaggerations and various arguments that won't hold up to rigorous scrutiny. Those exaggerations and arguments are meant to strengthen his criticism of media violence, but unfortunately weaken his strength as an overall authority. The author has assembled a lot of great information into this book, which may be an ideal starting point for readers new to this topic, but many of his excellent points, arguments, and insights get carried slightly farther than are truly defensible at this time (scientifically, logically, sociologically). I am still waiting for the definitive book on this topic that I can recommend without reservations to people I know. This one I would recommend to average readers but not unreservedly to the rigorous thinkers and scholars I am fortunate to count among my friends. With some editing and a touch more temperance, it could have been. Ah well, read it and learn what you can. It's good, but far from the last word on the subject.

Rating:
Summary: Understanding Media Violence
Review: The11 Myths of Media Violence is a must read for everyone who has ever sat in front of a television. Potter indicts our culture thirsty for a quick fix and simple black and white answers. He reminds us we live in a wonderful world of mystery, complexity and untold shades of gray. I need more copies of this book for the many friends and cohorts with whom I attempt to discuss the harms of media violence. At last our conversations won't be stuck on a superficial level. Kudos to Potter for his vital role in opening this can of worms we can no longer choose to ignore.
Ann Simonton, Director of Media Watch