Rating: 
Summary: Great review of bulingualism, but it is a bit too abstract
Review: I enjoyed reading this book. As a beginner in this field, I learnt about many hidden issues that I might encounter raising my child in a bilingual environment. The index section turned out to be especially useful as it briefly defines the problem and provides the reader with potential resolution.The Bilingual Family: A Handbook for Parents contains both theory and examples. However, if you expect to see a lesson plan, you are up for a disappointment.
Rating: 
Summary: very optimistic
Review: I found this book a great asset. I am now in the 7th month of my pregnancy and will be dealing with multilingual upbringing of my child soon. I am Slovak, my boyfriend is Dutch, we speak English together and are living now in Argentina. This book gave me a lot of encouragement for the future. It is written in a very optimistic tone and gives you a lot of tips how to deal with different linguistic situations along the way. I highly recommend it to everybody who want to bring up their children in a bi- or multilingual home. Great useful reading.
Rating:
Summary: If you only want to read one book, this will cover the bases
Review: I'm a native English speaker, married to a Russian, and we want to bring our daughter up bilingually. I found this book very useful - it is easy to read, easy to understand, and a good survey of the main issues, while raising some of the deeper issues of language acquisition. I would recommend it to anyone in my position. Like all the best books on child raising, it acknowledges that each child is unique, and so restricts itself to general guidelines on how to approach each situation. One minor quibble is that it does not deal with the problems of teaching two alphabets, but this is not a common problem, and we will just deal with this when it arises. The thing that I really like about this book is that both authors are bringing up their children bilingually, and use their children as case studies. They have many other case studies, which makes it clear how many different situations can arise, and what has worked in each case. They are also smart enough to include the case of parents with different native languages who choose to bring up their child with a single language. They emphasise the importance of establishing consistency in the approach to language - whatever you decide is the best way, you should stick to it, and let the child work with this situation. This could be the standard one parent/one language approach, modified as appropriate when there are non bilinguals present, or it could be one language for the home, the other language outside. The book has other approaches that have worked in other situations, including trilingual situations. The other thing that I learned from this book is that it is crucial to expose your child to situations where they use the language. If they need to speak a language, then they will. There were many stories of children who refused to speak one language, until they were confronted with a grandparent/cousin/friend who could only speak that language, and then the fluency came fast. Another interesting point was that you should not be worried if your child mixes the languages - they will sort things out in time. It may not be a misunderstanding about meaning, it may just be that different words have different associations, and these get distinguished eventually. The authors also caution against correcting your child's language too much, which seems like good advice to me. Language is more a tool, than a skill; you are using it to communicate, rather than score points for correct usage.
I read this book in a day - it's readable, with lots of real-life examples. It also has some side-tracks into the deeper issues of linguistic theory, which raises some interesting issues, and there is a list of books suggested for further reading.
Rating: 
Summary: Reads like a Masters Thesis
Review: In this world of increased Globalism, where millions of people cross ethnic and linguistic frontiers on a daily basis, one would think that bilingualism would be a well studied subject. I was dissapointed by Bilingual Family in that it unsucessfully tries to be both scholarly and a "how to" manual. For a serious student or scholar of bilingualism this book is a dissapointment in that it is a superficial and somewhate dated survey of the current literature on bilingualism. Those looking for a "how to" manual will also be dissapointed by the stilted and dry writing style of the authors. The best thing about the book is the numerous short case studies of family bilingualism in numerous parts of the world. In the end, I felt as though I was reading somebody's Masters Thesis.
Rating:
Summary: Reads like a Masters Thesis
Review: In this world of increased Globalism, where millions of people cross ethnic and linguistic frontiers on a daily basis, one would think that bilingualism would be a well studied subject. I was dissapointed by Bilingual Family in that it unsucessfully tries to be both scholarly and a "how to" manual. For a serious student or scholar of bilingualism this book is a dissapointment in that it is a superficial and somewhate dated survey of the current literature on bilingualism. Those looking for a "how to" manual will also be dissapointed by the stilted and dry writing style of the authors. The best thing about the book is the numerous short case studies of family bilingualism in numerous parts of the world. In the end, I felt as though I was reading somebody's Masters Thesis.
Rating:
Summary: Excellent resource!
Review: This book is definitely useful for multi-cultural families seeking to raise their children to be bilingual. It reviews various studies, but maintains an anecdotal format which is encouraging and accessible. Clearly it is based upon sound research but avoids being stuffy or non-conclusive. Excellent resource - I have recommended it to numerous friends and colleagues in expatriate communities and multi-cultural families.
Rating:
Summary: Very useful introduction.
Review: This book offers excellent introductory information and strategies, directed toward people who are not in the linguistics field. It is easy to read, with good examples. Also contains a practical discussion on whether or not you will probably succeed based on your time commitment and resources. Definitely has European focus.
Rating:
Summary: Raising kids bilingually? Esto es para ti!
Review: This is a fantastic book for parents who want to or need to raise their children in a multilingual environment. The approach is scientific, though the prose is not at all technical (it uses clinical studies, but you do not need a PhD in linguistics to understand the very real comforting and practical advice. We are a bilingual couple (English/Spanish) living in Japan. It was wonderful to read about the experiences of others in similar situations. The only (very mild) criticism I have is too much space spent debunking old ideas about bilingualism which seem out-of-date today. However, I understand that these ideas were entrenched in certain segments of society and need addressing for many people (meaning we, as parents, need the information to be able to handle skeptics as we encounter them). Case studies cover just about every contingency, and although the book is obviously based on European languages, the results can easily be seen to apply regardless of which languages are in question. It may take a little longer for certain language skills to develop between Japanese and English than between English and French, but the main point made is precisely that language aquisition is all relative. And kids will eventually sort it out. If you're worried or wondering about raising your kids with more than one language, buy this book. I'm glad I did.
Rating:
Summary: Good book, but can at times be a bit long-winded
Review: This is a good book and the authors have a lot of relevant and helpful advice to offer. Unfortunately, their expression and writing style can often leave something to be desired, as a result of which the book (particularly in the earlier sections) at times tends to read a bit like a university lecture. I think many new parents or parents-to-be might prefer a book that makes its point without letting the treatment bloat to much with the extra baggage of diversions and discussions about the discussions. Not to detract from the merit of the book, it still is a good read, particularly the chapter on case studies, which describes 16 different multilingual families under various circumstances and how they raised their children multilingually and to what extent, and in which respects, they were successful in doing so. If the one indulges the somewhat tedious writing style, every so often one comes on a piece of text that indeed makes one stop and nod, thinking "now that's an interesting point of view". Furthermore, the fact that there are only a handful of books written on this topic (aimed at the parents in question at least), makes it even more worthwhile.
Rating:
Summary: A useful book for middle-clas bi- and multilingual families.
Review: This is a useful book for middle-class families that are trying to raise their children bilingual. It's subjects are mostly (but not all) educated middle class families that are bi- and mulitilingual "by choice" (i.e. living in a foreign country because of the parents' job, parents with different native languages, etc.) and speak European languages. It provides basic conceptual framework for bilinguality and goes through all possible cases of bilingual families. These examples are very helpful - not only one of them is likely to fit your particular situation, but you get a feel for how different language arrangements can work out. The book is very optimistic and encouraging in tone. It is very useful introductory reading on the subject. It is probably not going to be very useful for families in forced emigration, families with foreign adopted children, or monolingual families that wish their child to learn a foreing language. It does not have any detailed instructions, as its main purpose is to show that bilinguality is doable and comes in many different flavors. I was very reassured by this book in my desire to raise my children bilingual and bicultural.
|
