Rating: Summary: Interesting and scary but also flat and preachy Review: Unlike some of my fellow reviewers, I was not so impressed with Tierno's The Secret Life of Germs. While a lot of what he has to say is fascinating, and I learned a lot from his writing, I found his style to be off-putting. The author certainly seems to have the credentials to talk about his subject (and the media exposure as an expert to boot, as he repeatedly tells of his television appearances). And he does a very thorough job of showing the history of and the reach of germs in our world. And for the paranoid, he certainly gives enough credence that the clean world around us is just teeming with dangers. But I found much of the book seemed to be written by not a germ adversary but a germ-aphobe. Tierno seems to go out of his way to show the simple things are deadly, citing X thousand of death from this microbe or that one. And how we must maintain vigilance in our daily life by washing constantly. If you believe his courses of action you would be constantly scrubbing your hands during the course of preparing dinner. While yes, there is unmistakable dangers our there to be careful of, Tierno seems to lack tradeoff in balancing the dangers with everyday life. He is also very fond of citing statistics - how many death are caused, and such, yet for someone with the background he has, the lack of a single source for his statements undercuts his arguments. No footnotes. No endnotes, No bibliography. Just his "Protective Response Strategy." As an overview of germs in our world it is a good read. But as the wakeup call to arms that the author seems to want it to be, if falls flat.
|