Home :: Books :: Professional & Technical  

Arts & Photography
Audio CDs
Audiocassettes
Biographies & Memoirs
Business & Investing
Children's Books
Christianity
Comics & Graphic Novels
Computers & Internet
Cooking, Food & Wine
Entertainment
Gay & Lesbian
Health, Mind & Body
History
Home & Garden
Horror
Literature & Fiction
Mystery & Thrillers
Nonfiction
Outdoors & Nature
Parenting & Families
Professional & Technical

Reference
Religion & Spirituality
Romance
Science
Science Fiction & Fantasy
Sports
Teens
Travel
Women's Fiction
Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your History Textbook Got Wrong

Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your History Textbook Got Wrong

List Price: $24.95
Your Price: $15.72
Product Info Reviews

<< 1 .. 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 .. 27 >>

Rating: 4 stars
Summary: The greatest history no one ever knew
Review: This is a fascnating book. Although it can be a bit dry in some spots, it is overall a book that will hold your attention all the way through. Do not be intimidated by this book just because you will find it on good history teachers book list. It describes people you have studied in a completely different way. He encourages you to question what you are learning right now, he even encourages you to question what he is telling you. It opens up the personality to history that has been hidden behind political correctness, personal agendas, and social inequality. Remember that history was written by the winners, but this book asks you to look at everyone involved in the event. This is a great book, I would suggest it to anyone.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: Examining the myths
Review: This is, of course, not a book primarily about history. It's a book about cultural bias in history textbooks.

If you consider that subject matter to be "liberal", so be it. But I would challenge you good conservatives to show me where the major points that he makes in this volume are wrong.

Rating: 4 stars
Summary: Yes!, it's a polemic, not history, but a good one
Review: This book is not a history textbook and I do not think that was the author's intention. The book, or pamphlet if you like, is an argument meant to clue everyone in of the clear bias in U.S. history textbooks that teach high school students tripe (in the words of Lisa Simpson). The examples are few but well argued and it is slanted to the left and deals a lot with race and class relations. It is meant for the layman and does a good job arguing part of what is wrong with U.S. History textbooks. You will find theories on why the textbooks all seem to say the same, un-thought-provoking things, included in many of the examples.

Rating: 2 stars
Summary: Interesting, thought-provoking but very tedious to finish
Review: Although points were made in this book that were eye-opening it was a hard book to finish. James Loewen is clearly not a history professor, he is a professor of sociology. So the book is basically about race & class relations and how they are misrepresented in American History books. This is interesting & made me change my vocabulary to some degree. However he drones on about 2-3 points in the whole book, so it begins to get tiring. Also, I was expecting a more broad discussion of 'Lies my Teachers Told Me' rather than just one on Race relations. I did find the book interesting, I'm glad I read it. I would recommend it to someone who wants to know more about race & class (sociology) rather than history.

Rating: 1 stars
Summary: a tedious read
Review: The author's premise is that American History textbooks try to present our past as heroic and mythic; omitting the bad and mischaracterizing the evil done in our past. To show this, the author states that he has surveyed 12 textbooks and interprets their contents.

I would not recommend this book for various reasons.

The author's style makes for a rather tedious read. His constant repetition and rephrasing of material accounts for much of the book's contents. The book is actually a pamphlet that has been bloated through the use of needlessly restating already presented material.

Another problem is that the author holds that the omission of any material at all from the textbooks is a deliberate act of biased editorialising. So, for instance, if President Woodrow Wilson is not painted as racist as he should be in Textbook "A", it is not as a result of space or time limitations of High School curriculum, but rather "agenda."

Something else that bothered be was that fact that Loewen couldn't let his quotations speak for themselves. For instance, when quoting a passage from one of the Puritans speaking of God, "...we thank Him [sic]..." Loewen inserts the [sic] to demonstrate that he is not capitalizing the Divine Pronoun, but thus it was found in the unenlightened original. Also, when one of the European invaders of the Americas refers to the natives as "...Savages [sic]..." Loewen has to insert the [sic] to show that the ignorant Europeans didn't realize the correct posit, as Loewen does, that
one should speak of the Native Americans as civilized and the European invaders as savages.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: good to better understand history
Review: Lies my teacher told me is good because it helps to show how history can be manipulated by people and how certain groups of people can be left out. Lies also deals with how ineffecitely how history is being taught to our children. It seems more and more of our students are graduating high school withoug knowing anything about major historial events of american history. However, Loewan does go into his personal views of society which undermines the book because the book starts off well by showing our history and then turnds into loewan's crusade, but the book is still something good to read.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: Prompting the Intellect
Review: So you thought you know your history?

Loewen offers a provocative perspective of American history by questioning European
heroification oriented history through the retelling American history from the perspective(s) the
Native and African Americans. Challenging the European dominated American myth, Loewen
questions the basis for much of America's storied history providing ample support for his
position.
One historical reckoning does not provide complete accuracy. Yet, societies' educational
systems attempt to instill their own societal ideas and methods to preserve the societies' identity
and integrity. As Loewen accurately states, American social studies textbooks omit or downplay
our nation's shortcomings. Our society promotes a positive self-image to motivate patriotic and
loyalty. It's not surprising that historical figures are made mythological for this purpose. Ancient
Egypt created gods from tale tails of early kings; the Old Testament draws from Babylonian myths
to explain creation; America glorifies the stories of Columbus and the Pilgrims to explain our
presence in the country.
In an informational age the American story needs to suit its cultural kaleidoscope
however. Loewen whets the appetite for historic cultural reconciliation. America is not solely the
Eurocentric melding pot. It never was. Such an image presents a shallow attempt to understand a
multi-dimensional past.
To properly understand a concept, one must understand both its positive and negative
elements. Loewen teaches us the America story is not an exception. Be teaching negative
perspectives of American history, Loewen challenges us to critically consider what we teach. By
understanding our society as viewed by all its parts, we can fully comprehend our stories and
consciously strive for ongoing betterment.
The book does have some weak elements. While Loewen appears at times overzealous in
his efforts, oversupporting his viewpoints with a plethora of support documentation. His support
and conclusions about some historical figures create some concern. Yet, the nature of Loewen's
subject matter requires this degree of support to overcome the storied past. More examples are
needed to overcome deep-rooted perceptions than are required to create initial impressions. His
discussion of John Brown raises some concern about advocacy of vigilante murder methods.
For all his criticism, Loewen appears vague and short on solutions. This shortcoming
results from the nature of the subject matter. In discovering historical half-truths have systemic
causes, Loewen appears to lack a definate method to address the need for systemic change. He
reasons this method must occur through the classroom, however. The chapter on governmentally
tainted information questions the accuracy of accounts of nonconforming social movements.
Thus a direct challenge to the system does not appear feasible. Just as a steamship can't pivot
suddenly, so much systemic change evolve.
Loewen stimulates an interest in knowing our historic truths. He provides a springboard for more
investigation into our past. The classroom is an excellent place to start this process
systematically.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: A Matter of Perception
Review: So you thought you knew your history?

In this book, James Loewen performs a masterful job of challenging how we perceive historical events and how they are taught to us. In the process, he draws our awareness to the cultural and therefore political wrongs of our past and prompts us to consider our future in a new light. Columbus, the Pilgrims, Wilson, and other historical key figures will not be considered the same after reading this book.

It's a shame more authors don't pursue similar establishment challenging book content

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: my second favorite history book...
Review: upon reading this book i learned :

columbus killed and enslaved scores of arwaks and indians, and did not die poor and obscure, but quite well off

the pilgrims did not intend to go to plymouth rock initially and the first thanxgiving day dinner was a hoax

that millions of indians were killed and conned out of thousands of acres of land because they wouldn't adapt to the white way of life...

that lincoln was a better friend to blacks and slaves than i thought

that negros played organized baseball in the late 19th century
jackie robinson was not the first

that black jockeys won 15 of 28 kentucky dirty and were forbidden to compete

woodrow wilson was a savage racist who segregated the federal government

helen keller was a socialist

john f. kennedy did not initially support support civil rights

and why the media lied about the vietnam war

i can see why history books lie about history and make people heroes when they clearly don't deserve to be...after all, it's HIS story...

thank you mr. lowen for writing a history book that will awaken many people's interest in the subject. it has renewed my faith in the power of honest scholarship....you will never take history lightly after reading this book..

Rating: 4 stars
Summary: Content worth consideration and reflection.
Review: I first read this book when I was attending Honolulu Community College, in Hawaii. While attending HCC I took a class in Asian Civilization. Because of Hawaii's Pacific Rim location, it straddles an interesting position both geographically and culturally. Things never addressed on the mainland are available to the inquisitive mind. How many people know of the Native Hawaiian Sovereignty movement? How many people know that American troops surrounded and confined Queen Lilioukalani to her house until she abdicated her throne?

Lowewen addresses the omissions and restructuring of history to satisfy the tastes of a few individuals, those with something to gain personally and often financially. He may not offer the widest expose on the issues involved, he may well choose sources with a decidedly liberal bent, however he makes a compelling point -- what is your head being filled with and should you believe it? This isn't just a question one should find out by reading a book, it's a question one ought to ask one's self every day.

Loewen's book is of considerable value in encouraging people to stop and think about things. It is not the only book one ought to read on the subject. For anyone to assume that this is the treatise to end all treatises, I ask you to think again. It is merely one way in which to ask yourself what goes on outside your normally accepted sphere of existence. It offers food for thought and does so in a manner that is easy to read. The information is easy to absorb and well researched within the sphere Loewen chose to research it in.


<< 1 .. 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 .. 27 >>

© 2004, ReviewFocus or its affiliates