The Lives of a Cell: Notes of a Biology Watcher

Rating:
Summary: Not what many expect, but outstanding.
Review: A group of students and I just finished reading THE LIVES OF A CELL as part of a readings in biology seminar this spring. Once you read the first 3-4 chapters it becomes obvious that there is not a central theme (or is there) for the book.

Contents of this book are a compilation of reflective articles originally published in a medical journal. Chapter topics range all over the place, but they present many topics drawn from biological thought prominent through the mid-1970s -- everything from molecular biology to Gaia to sociobiology.

There is a wealth of material here appropriate for discussion among undergraduate students, professionals, and perhaps even science-directed high school students. Each of the 29 chapters are about 3-5 pages long, can be easily digested, and beg to be reflected upon and discussed.

As for the writing, other Amazon reviewers have referred to the writing in this book as being poetic. While I didn't see so much of that, I was struck by Thomas' ability to turn a phrase, make a point, and discuss complex biological ideas in a manner that is easily understood. The writing in the book is a definite plus.

There are also times in the book where I can imagine Thomas grinning as he wrote, or, perhaps giving the occasional wink! He must have had a wonderful sense of humor.

OK, back to the theme...if there is one...it seems to me that one common theme of several of the chapters has to do with communication -- oral, chemical, behavioral, and genetic. Other possible themes include the fact that humans are "not all that." That we are part of the global system, not running it. Another possibility includes the idea that everything can be an analogy of the way that a cell works -- organelles, membranes, cellular processes, products, and so forth.

This is excellent reading for anyone interested in ideas about life and living. Well written, occasionally humorous, and intruiging.

5 stars!

Rating:
Summary: Short tales of biological fascination
Review: At less than 150 pages, this book is packed with more biological insights than stupendous stacks of others. Dr. Thomas's description of how eukaryotic cells arose is a true marvel of how life adapts. He makes strong arguments that the biological norm is not competition but cooperation. The cells of our bodies were constructed when separate species of bacteria somehow decided that their long-term survival would be enhanced if they were to combine their specialized functions into a single cell. Such an event is truly extraordinary and may be the real miracle of life. It could turn out that simple single-celled life arises quite easily, but the combining of the separate species into a new, more complex cell is the rare event. Since it is apparently necessary for it to occur for intelligence to arise, that may be the reason why there is such an interstellar silence of signals from other intelligent species.
Despite his status as a physician, the author is also realistic about medicine. He describes his informal poll that physicians families receive less medical intervention than others and yet there is no alteration in their patterns of illness. His theses about how we generally get better more because it is in the nature of things for us to recover from illness than anything medical is advice that more people should take. He also argues that disease causing organisms are most often biological accidents, where the error is sometimes found on the human side. In these cases, the disease is a consequence of our bodies overreacting to the situation rather than anything the "infectious" agent does.
I was pointed towards this book by a college professor who told me that it would teach me more about biology than my current texts ever could. She was right and I learned much concerning how to marvel about what biology is all about from this book. Armed with that knowledge, it became, and still is, the most exciting subject I have ever studied.

Rating:
Summary: Appeals to both the artist and the scientist
Review: I like this book... a lot, especially the last few chapters. This book covers a lot of topics. A lot. Each chapter is only a few pages long, which is nice for people who don't chunks of time to read. Everything he says builds up to the last chapter. It's eloquently written and a fun/easy/intellectual read.

Rating:
Summary: Appeals to both the artist and the scientist
Review: I strongly disagreed with the review titled "Fake Science," so I was amused to see that the review's author used the word "applauded" where I believe s/he meant to use "appalled."

This book clearly isn't, and doesn't pretend to be, "scientific," in the sense of data acquired by rigid adherence to the scientific method and presented in dry academic format. It is more a lovely ride along the currents of Lewis'philosophical meanderings upon life, at various levels of complexity, in various contexts. This book instilled in me a sense of wonder at the wonderfulness of it all. P.S. I am a scientist.

Rating:
Summary: your chance to meet Lewis Thomas
Review: Lewis Thomas is who I want to be when I grow up - his writing is intelligent, witty, highly personable, full of fresh insights and passion for his subject matter: man and his home in the universe. Lives of a Cell is the book that jumpstarted my interest in biology over twenty years ago.

"Viewed from the distance of the moon, the astonishing thing about the earth, catching the breath, is that it is alive." - so begins the essay "The World's Biggest Membrane", in which he likens the earth with its atmosphere to a cell with its membrane. "The photographs show the dry, pounded surface of the moon in the foreground, dead as an old bone. Aloft, floating free beneath the moist, gleaming membrane of bright blue sky, is the rising earth, the only exuberant thing in this part of the cosmos. [...] It has the organized, self-contained look of a live creature, full of information, marvelously skilled in handling the sun."

What other science writer manages to surprise and delight you at every turn of a phrase? What other poet brings the incredible precise detail and the easy authority of a practising scientist? What other essayist ranges from the smallest part of a cell to the solar system with equal curiosity and interest and yet always manages to keep man in focus?

Lewis Thomas opened up a whole niche of science writing by showing its immense appeal, which is yet not mass appeal. Writers and thinkers as highly talented and diverse as Natalie Angier and Diane Ackerman have settled in this niche, and have prospered there.

Rating:
Summary: The Ultimate Biology Watcher
Review: Lewis Thomas' book is a beautifully written collection of essays. He writes much in the style of the 13th century author Frederick Montaigne, whom he later writes an essay about in another book. The essays, combine to bring a truly penultimate view of biological life. His observations, more than conclusions, bring one very close to a belief that in some way, all life is connected.

In a particularly interesting essay on "organelles" Thomas points out that mitochondria, the engines of the cell in every animal, do not exchange DNA like every other part of the body in sexual procreation, but in fact, are passed directly from the ovum to the zygote in the cytoplasm, and never change or recombine their DNA. This apparently being a protective mechanism developed over 100's of thousands of years because the preservation of the exact mitochondrial DNA sequence is so important, that it could not be left to chance, as are most every other characteristic of the animal.

Throughout the book, Thomas reveals truly extraordinary facts about biology and microbiology that tend to leave the reader in actual awe. For an incredibly interesting and fast education about cellular biology this National Book Award Winning collection is truly a fascinating read.

Rating:
Summary: Biology On A Cellular Level: Impressive
Review: Lewis Thomas' book is a beautifully written collection of essays. He writes much in the style of the 13th century author Frederick Montaigne, whom he later writes an essay about in another book. The essays, combine to bring a truly penultimate view of biological life. His observations, more than conclusions, bring one very close to a belief that in some way, all life is connected.

In a particularly interesting essay on "organelles" Thomas points out that mitochondria, the engines of the cell in every animal, do not exchange DNA like every other part of the body in sexual procreation, but in fact, are passed directly from the ovum to the zygote in the cytoplasm, and never change or recombine their DNA.

This apparently being a protective mechanism developed over 100's of thousands of years because the preservation of the exact mitochondrial DNA sequence is so important, that it could not be left to chance, as are most every other characteristic of the animal.

Throughout the book, Thomas reveals truly extraordinary facts about biology and microbiology that tend to leave the reader in actual awe. For an incredibly interesting and fast education about cellular biology this National Book Award Winning collection is truly a fascinating read.

Rating:
Summary: An interesting book by any measure
Review: Look, it's not as smooth a read as Microcosmos--BUT, it is very interesting, and would make an excellent follow up to Margullis and Sagan's book Microcosmos. This book gets a bit farther into the development of human sexual traits than Microscosmos (of course, one can and should buy a copy of "What is Sex" by Margullis and Sagan if they are that curious) However, it reflects well on both books should they be read back to back as I have. It is difficult for a person like me--with a limited understanding of cell biology---to find easily understood books on the subject. This is one. I highly recomend Thomas' book to anyone who wants to understand the biology of humanity.

Rating:
Summary: An intellectual stroll through biology and medical science
Review: This book is a collection of essays written by Thomas covering various subjects. There is no formal structure or scientific process to them. It is more like an intellectual stroll through the park, something you might have a professor mention in passing, elaborated. Being a medical student myself, I found the book extremely interresting, but make no mistake, the vocabulary assumes some sort of degree in biology or biochemistry or medicine.

For those of us used to reading journal articles, this is nothing like one. He doesn't have firm conclusions or hypotheses. He just sort of proposes an idea and lets it float around in our collective consciousness.

The only criticism I have of this book is that Thomas can be repetitive at times. He will reiterate ideas and points and if you are reading the book cover to cover, that fact can be annoying. However, if you read an essay every now and then, stopping to digest the material, I believe you'll find that Thomas has some interesting insights into the world of science.

Rating:
Summary: Fake Science
Review: This book is best read after you have gone through your own search for knowledge. A short refreshing break from all the textbooks and other enlightening books that you have waded through, always coming out a better and more educated person. The Lives of a Cell is that much needed reflection on what you have gained from other books not nearly as beautifully crafted as this book. Lewis Thomas has the talent to make short essays that with one breath calls upon all previous knowledge you may have received. Seemingly seperate essays all intertwine to form a message that is a beautiful as the individual essays. Truly worth buying, even if you don't immeaditely read it, you will come back to it again and again as your journey through science and knowledge provides greater insight on the toughest problems posed by philosophy.