Rating: 
Summary: Excellent review of history/costs of damming the Columbia
Review: A fair and even handed book that looks at the human, social, and environmental costs of damming the Columbia river. Harden gives us insight into the thinking an motivation of all parties involved in the management of the Columbia, including the government, farmers, bargers, Indians, environmental activists, windsurfers, and "eviros" living West of the Cascades
Rating:
Summary: So much good information
Review: A full and complete modern history of the Columbia River. At times sad, always intriging. Harden has done an excellent job of combining interviews with research that makes an excellent read.Highly recommmended.
Rating:
Summary: Readable and thought-provoking
Review: Although the author probably is personally opposed to the dams on the Columbia, his vivid and respectful profiles of the different users of the river (the slackwater barge operator, the Indian tribe that lost its source of food when the river was dammed, the irrigation farmer, the windsurfing yuppie, the father and son who work on the Hanford cleanup) make us understand that no matter how this tricky issue is resolved, there will be a human cost. His recollection of growing up in Moses Lake, a town which owes its prosperity to the dams, adds even more credibility to his account. Harden's device of telling the story in stages, as a trip down the river, is unobtrusive and keeps things interesting. This book will make you think and it will also treat you to some gorgeous descriptions of the Columbia.
Rating: 
Summary: An eye opener.
Review: I grew up in the Tri-Cities and spent the first 19 years of my life living just blocks away from the Columbia River and there was a lot of information told in this book that I never knew. Harden does a wonderful job of relating the history of the Columbia River and the effects that the many dams built on the river had on the land, the people, the nation, and the economy. I thoroughly enjoyed his story and felt he handled well the many issues important to preservationists, politicians, and farmers. I recommend this to anyone who lives in the state of Washington and is interested in man's permanent effects on this land.
Rating:
Summary: An eye opener.
Review: I grew up in the Tri-Cities and spent the first 19 years of my life living just blocks away from the Columbia River and there was a lot of information told in this book that I never knew. Harden does a wonderful job of relating the history of the Columbia River and the effects that the many dams built on the river had on the land, the people, the nation, and the economy. I thoroughly enjoyed his story and felt he handled well the many issues important to preservationists, politicians, and farmers. I recommend this to anyone who lives in the state of Washington and is interested in man's permanent effects on this land.
Rating:
Summary: Great book, great insight
Review: Living just 80 miles south of the Columbia, Harden's book gave me an easy, detailed account of the history of the Columbia and the effects of electricity v. the life of beautiful salmon. Although Harden often blames locals for the decline in salmon, and at other times, the government, I found it to be a fair look at both sides of the story. Harden's forte is taking a Paul Harvey approach, telling the rest of the story behind the Columbia River. A great review of the pros and cons of hydroelectrics and the effects it has on not just the West Coast, but the whole nation. I learned that there is a hell of a lot of politics being played on the water. By the way, don't eat salmon, it tastes disgusting.
Rating:
Summary: Wonderful writing. Interesting points of view.
Review: Once in a great while a book comes along that is so beautifully written, with stories so well told, that the subject matter seems secondary to the writer's ability to sustain interest. For me, with little interest in the northwest (I've been there twice), this was such a book. It is from Harden's exceptional skill as a writer and narrator of stories that the Columbia River suddenly became of great interest as I turned his pages. "A River Lost" tells the story and history of the Columbia River and the environmental, economic and aesthetic impact of daming that river in the first half of the last century. Especially interesting are the stories and points of view of those who work and live on its shores, the fate of the native indians who have lived in the region for hundreds of years and the differences in culture between the Starbucks yuppies east of the Cascades and the blue collar workers so dependant on the water and its billions in federally subsidized benefits to the west. Highly praised in reviews by The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Economist, the Village Voice, The Seattle Times and Publishers Weekly, it is a great read for the information, for the writing, for a piece of American history.
Rating: 
Summary: A good read, entertaining, but rather shallow in conclusions
Review: The author has done his homework, but allowed his personal PC-ness to strangle his conclusions. He is quick and mighty to blame the "Republican Congress" for what he perceives to be current failure, while he completely and naively fails to see, and never reports, that it was 50+ years of Democrats who "did it "!! It was, never the less, a good read with many clever and poignant word pictures.
Rating: 
Summary: A River Lost = Eyes Wide SHUT
Review: This anti-development propaganda is typical of those who live off the development but don't know what the people went through to get it there. His historical information is misinformed and his quotes of "locals" are misrepresented. A very sad, missed opportunity to tell the story of how people and the environment change over time.
Rating:
Summary: How to destroy a regional economy with taxpayer money
Review: When this book was written the current water, fish, and power crisis was in its infancy. This book foretold the inevitable conflict that now threatens the economy of the entire region. The documentation of the wasteful use of water by irrigators to grow crops that are unprofitable with a system paid for by taxpayers and electric ratepayers should be mandatory reading for all Northwesterners. If BPA fails and electric rates skyrocket the reasons are all spelled out here. Those who want to frame the debate as "fish versus Power" will find in the pages of this book that in actuality the real contest is between power generation and irrigation. My 16 years as a water resource planner for the Department of the Interior made me want to say "right on" with every page I read.
| 
