Anchoress of Shere

Rating:
Summary: "Shere" Drivel
Review: Alas! An intriguing topic and a book with much potential, which is undone by poor writing! Moorcraft is at his worst when he attempts to write dialogue, which is as bad as that in any supermarket variety bodice-ripper. Who could get into the head of a 14th century anchorite? Surely not Mr. Moorcraft.Three stars for selecting an alluring topic, though.

Rating:
Summary: unusual but nonetheless fascinating tale
Review: In 1392 in what is now the quaint town of Shere in Surrey, England Christine Carpenter willing locked herself away from the rest of the world in an attempt to reach a state of oneness with God while still living on the mortal plane. Almost six hundred years later, fanatical Catholic Priest Michael Duval became fascinated with what Christine and other Anchoresses like her tried to do and decided to flesh out her story in a novel.

However, Michael's muse has deserted him so he is going to do what he has tried to do five times before. He is going to kidnap a young woman and incarcerate her in a specially created cell in his basement. He is then going to teach her about religion so that she can become "his" modern day Christine and he will able to finish his book. He successfully kidnaps Marda Stewart who, unlike her predecessors, intends to live to tell the tale about the killer priest.

Paul Moorcraft captures the atmosphere of fourteenth century England to perfection while telling Christine's "story". He also shows the mindset of a serial killer through his actions and thoughts. Though six centuries separate the two stories, they are held together by an intriguing plot that will keep the reader turning the pages until they finish this very unusual but nonetheless fascinating tale.

Harriet Klausner

Rating:
Summary: Fascinating tale of faith and redemption
Review: Julian of Norwich is the best-known medieval English anchoress, but her life is too sane for Dr. Moorcroft. His sado-masochistic novel features a little-known lapsed anchoress, Christine Carpenter of Shere. Raped by the Lord of the Manor only in Dr. Moorcraft's lurid fiction, she walls herself up in conditions no medieval parish would accept. He matches this with Michael Duval, a demented 1960s Catholic priest who kidnaps and tortures young women so that they may "become" his fantasy girlfriend, Christine. Dr. Moorcroft misses no possible cliche, no imaginable foolish error, no modern superstition about the actual Middle Ages. He hasn't got a good grip on the 1960s either. The last of Duval's victims, Marda Stewart, is a remarkably stupid young woman, who survives mostly by accident and her genuine cooperation with her captor's fantasies. In this book no one thinks; "instinct" and "intuition" rule. I felt extremely sorry for the real Christine Carpenter, a confused but earnest young woman, who honestly tried a difficult vocation and failed.

Rating:
Summary: Maria Monk Rides Again
Review: Julian of Norwich is the best-known medieval English anchoress, but her life is too sane for Dr. Moorcroft. His sado-masochistic novel features a little-known lapsed anchoress, Christine Carpenter of Shere. Raped by the Lord of the Manor only in Dr. Moorcraft's lurid fiction, she walls herself up in conditions no medieval parish would accept. He matches this with Michael Duval, a demented 1960s Catholic priest who kidnaps and tortures young women so that they may "become" his fantasy girlfriend, Christine. Dr. Moorcroft misses no possible cliche, no imaginable foolish error, no modern superstition about the actual Middle Ages. He hasn't got a good grip on the 1960s either. The last of Duval's victims, Marda Stewart, is a remarkably stupid young woman, who survives mostly by accident and her genuine cooperation with her captor's fantasies. In this book no one thinks; "instinct" and "intuition" rule. I felt extremely sorry for the real Christine Carpenter, a confused but earnest young woman, who honestly tried a difficult vocation and failed.

Rating:
Summary: Graphic and sadistic
Review: Marda Stewart is drawn to the village of Shere after visiting St. James's church but she has no idea of what a profound impact this decision will have on her life. She soon meets Father Michael Duval. Duval has become obsessed with the story of Christine Carpenter, entombed within the walls of the church in 1329 when she become the anchoress. As Father Duval writes about Christine's life he feels the need to recreate her entombment and focuses on Marda to mold into his perfect recreation of Christine. This is a tightly woven suspense novel that focuses on a fascinating historical figure and reading it has caused me to want to know more about the Anchoress of Shere. I have already started searching the web and looking for books and although there are many theories, no one knows exactly what happened to her. This book is currently being published in the U.S. after it became a success in England and there is also talk of turning this into a movie.

Rating:
Summary: Fascinating tale of faith and redemption
Review: This book takes its time telling two stories intertwined on the page and in the mysteries of the past and the future. One story is that of Christine Carpenter, a young girl who voluntarily entombs herself as an anchoress in her 14th century church in the village of Shere... and that of Marda Stewart, who is violently entombed in 1967 in this same village of Shere by a pshychotic Priest who is obsessed with his fictional retelling of Christine's story. The narrative of the book is engrossing and very effective at pulling the reader into both stories simultaneously. Jettisoned between the harsh realities of the Middle Ages and the terrrifying events unfolding in the 1960's there are graphic descriptions of terror that are necessary in understanding the horror and exhultation that can be experienced by the body, mind and soul. Only through journeying through these graphic passages can the reader come to fully appreciate the final pages of the book which offer an eloquent and profound lesson in redemption.
The book is not meant to be a historical document on the dogma of the Church or the nature of anchoresses and instead the author uses these as the premise to paint a canvas of the evolution of faith and the power of the human spirit. But mostly, through the three main characters, the reader comes to see religion and especially faith (wether meek devotion or fanatical obsession) as an individual journey that has a mystery all its own.