Rating: 
Summary: A Compelling Creep Show
Review: “The Red Room” is a fine keep-you-up-all-night psychological thriller. The Frenches don’t let us down in this character-driven novel of suspense. A homeless teen-aged girl, only known as Lianne, is murdered near a canal in a seedy part of London. The police are certain they have their perpetrator, Michael Doll, who freely admits he was at the scene. Michael is a disturbed young man who has been convicted of minor sexual offenses. Have you ever met someone who you found disgusting and repulsive, but yet you found yourself pitying him or her? Meet Michael, a perfect example of the breed. The authors play the reader like a violin to elicit these contradictory emotions. This is one revolting guy, and yet---Enter Kit Quinn, a psychologist who has an unpleasant background with Michael. The police want her to “sign off” on his ability to stand trial. Dr. Quinn thinks there is much wrong with Michael, but doubts very much if he is a murderer. And so our story begins. Kit, an efficient appearing lady, who has a soaring imagination, captivated me. She is one of those people who have an aura of beauty and civility in everything they do. She gathers flowers, but does not garden. She is a fine appreciator of the smells, colors, and satisfactions of the freshest, simplest food—yet she claims she never has food in the house. I particularly liked that Kit is nobody’s fool; her awareness is very keen for both the faults and virtues of her friends and lovers. The novel overflows with wonderful characters. Julie who descends uninvited on Kit and stays for the entirety of the book, is a free spirit and borrows food, clothes, and space shamelessly. Yet we forgive her because of her innate generosity, her charm and her humor. The middle-aged Detective Chief Inspector is convinced that Julie and Kit are romantic partners, and fumbles manfully to be sophisticated about his misapprehension. The suspense builds and builds, the tension all the greater because we care about these people. We want the best for each of them and know it will not work out that way. The authors do not let us down and keep the intensity high through the last page. I liked this book and believe it ranks with my favorite French novel “Killing Me Softly.” Read it and enjoy.
Rating: 
Summary: Creepy, and suspenseful
Review: Dr. Kit Quinn is used to interviewing people in police custody, but nothing could prepare her for Michael Doll. Doll, picked up for questioning after being caught hanging around a school yard, is unlike anyone Kit has ever interviewed, he is handsome, smart, and in a split second he destroys her life. During a routine questioning, Kit takes her eyes off of Doll for a second, and in that second she hears a shattering sound, the next thing she knows blood is pouring down her face, because Doll has attacked her face with a broken mug, crippling her beauty, and shattering her confidence. Three months later, suffering from nightmares of the attack, Kit is asked to help the police once again. This time a teenage runaway has been murdered, and YES, Michael Doll is the key suspect. Putting aside her own fears, Kit agrees to interview Doll, only to find there is not enough evidence to pin the murder on him, and he is set free. Further investigating this crime will lead Kit to a link of another murder, this one a housewife abducted in broad daylight and killed, the main figure in this murder is, YES, Michael Doll. As the investigations heat up, Kit starts receiving phone calls, break-ins in her apartment, and the feeling of being followed. And, the person always lurking in the shadows is, you guessed it, Michael Doll. Still NOT convinced Doll is the killer, Kit delves deeper into the crimes, only to bring her fears to a shattering conclusion, as she suspects who the real killer is. 'The Red Room' is a real grabber, it starts full steam, and just keeps gaining momentum as it hurdles to it's shocking climax. Just as the reader thinks they have figured out the puzzle, Ms. French throws in a new twist to keep us guessing. Well written, briskly paced, and an expertly executed plot, keeps 'The Red Room' way ahead of many novels in the thriller genre. Nicci French has made the obsession territory her own, and she deserves it, for her novels are always entertaining. Taking everyday characters and throwing them into an all-too-plausible (nightmare) scenario, Ms. French gives her readers a terrifying journey through the dark side of the human psyche. After two previous bestsellers, Nicci French out does herself, by going one step further in revealing the nightmares that live inside us all. A MUST read! Nick Gonnella
Rating: 
Summary: Too Many Cooks Spoil the Stew
Review: Dr. Kit Quinn, a young English psychiatrist, is a resilient woman. She's back on the job consulting with the London Police Department just months after having her face sliced by a bizarre, fixated loner. Now she's helping the police with a murder investigation, the prime suspect in which is none other than her attacker. The "Red Room" starts out with promise, but quickly turns into a disappointment. "Nicci French" is actually the pseudonym of a married writing team, and the book reads like it. It is very difficult for writers to collaborate on a seamless novel, particularly when it comes to crafting a suspenseful plot. The story never generates any real thrills, and the story is only mildly interesting. It was refreshing to read a story set in London; it was a nice change from the typical American mysteries I usually read. The murder investigation, however -- the heart of the mystery -- left me cold. Reviewed by Mystery Ink
Rating: 
Summary: Am I Blue....
Review: I don't know about you, but when I read a book by one of my favorite authors, my expectations are higher than when I read a book by an author who is unknown to me. When the book doesn't live up to my expectations, I guess I feel so let down that I tend to be hyper-critical. This latest book by Nicci French lacked the edge and the connection to the protagonist that I experienced when reading a French book. When reading "Killing Me Softly" and "Beneath the Skin," I was constantly asking myself..."What would I have done?" I rarely found myself asking that while reading "The Red Room" On the contrary, I felt no connection to the protagonist, Kit Quinn. Although the character is explored in great depth, I just could not get drawn into her life. Most of the other characters in the book were not well defined and, quite often, I wondered why they were there at all. Story lines were introduced and never fully explored or haphazardly explained leaving me a bit bewildered at times. This was one of those books where you are waiting for that stunning moment to occur. There was only one scene in the book that was reminiscent of the French style. Unfortunately, a three to four page scene is not enough to carry a book. On the positive side, the book was a very fast read. Maybe that is because I was frantically turning pages hoping to reach the point when I would feel that sense of urgency I felt when reading the prior two books. When I finished this book, I had the feeling that this was the first book in a series featuring Kit Quinn, who goes from being a therapist to a forensic psychologist and super sleuth in short order. If allowed, I would give this book 2-1/2 stars. As homage to the husband and wife team of Nicci French who have given me so many hours of exciting and insightful reading pleasure, I will give the book a three-star rating. I am left waiting for the next French book with the optimism that it will be up to the level of excellence of the prior two books.
Rating:
Summary: Nicci French has done it again!
Review: I have read and loved all of French's books -- I particularly loved Killing Me Softly and Beneath the Skin -- and I couldn't wait to read The Red Room, although I have to admit that I am disappointed with the fact that this book doesn't delve into the subject of obsession, like her previous novels. Well, I guess the writer had to try something new. Dr. Kit Quinn is a crime psychologist who has been given the task of helping the police investigate the murder of a homeless girl. The assigned detectives believe that a creepy fisherman named Michael Doll is responsible for said murder, but Kit is convinced that it isn't a simple open and shut case and begins to fish out the truth by connecting crimes that the detectives see as irrelevent to the crime in question. There are various twists in the novel, and in most cases the development of the story may confuse the reader (or at least it confused me), but -- like the vast majority of novels in this genre -- everything falls into place at the end. The novel contains a memorable foreshadow. This books is everything a good mystery/thriller should be. I have to admit that this novel isn't as suspenseful or sensuous as French's previous efforts, but it is a great read nevertheless. In the bargain for a clever thriller? Read The Red Room. In fact, I recommend all books from this great English writer.
Rating:
Summary: Strong Then Weak
Review: I have read several Nicci French books as I live in Europe and more of her books have been available here than in the U.S. I have enjoyed each of them, but have noticed a tendency toward rambling in some of them. As well, I have thought a few times that their (Nicci French is the pseudonym for a husband-and-wife writing team) dialogue can be be weak sometimes. I think that this book improves on both of those issues. The story moves along at a rapid pace and I find the dialogues much more convincing that in previous books. However, I have a different complaint with this book and it seems, from reading other reviews, that I am not the only one to feel this way. The ending is weak and left me with a slight bad taste in my mouth. Sometimes it seems as if a writer reaches a certain wordcount in a book and says, "Ok, that's it. Let's wrap this thing up now." But, the ending is not so weak that it takes away from the enjoyment of reading the book; in fact, I almost wish that they would write another book involving the main character from this one, Dr. Kit Quinn. And, I hope the other Nicci French books become available for U.S. readers soon for their sake.
Rating:
Summary: Don't bother
Review: I love French's other books and this was a total disappointment.
Rating:
Summary: A Schivelbein
Review: I loved Nicci French's first 2 books and put this one on order as soon as I saw she was coming out with a new one. Wow was I disappointed. I had a hard time finishing it. The book was nothing like her others. There was no suspense and when you find out who the killer is It seems completely unbelievable. I would not recommend this. If you want to read a good book by her get "killing me softly" that was a good read. I sure hope her next one is better.
Rating:
Summary: engaged my interest from start to finish
Review: I rather liked "The Red Room" by Nicci French. This novel is not quite like French's previous novels -- it is a little more subdued and restrained. The heroine, Dr. Kit Quinn, a forensic psychiatrist, is also a little different from previous French heroines: while interviewing a mentally unbalanced derelict, whom the police suspect of being a sexual deviant, Kit is rather badly scarred in the face when the derelict, Michael Doll goes spare and tries to attack the policeman in the interview room. Add to this the unpleasantness of being ignominiously dumped by her longtime boy friend, and you realise that Kit has lost a lot of her self-assurance and confidence. This makes her a little diffident at times, and very anxious at others. This is the tone that more or less pervades over much of the book; it can be exasperating for some readers, but if you put aside your preconceptions about how an investigative heroine is supposed to be or act, than "The Red Room" becomes a very interesting and rewarding read. Another interesting point about this mystery novel and it's heroine, is that Kit seems to operate best when she acts on instinct. When she first confronts the murder of the homeless runaway, Lianne, instinct makes Kit look at other unexplained murders/deaths, as she's very sure that that Lianne's death was not a one off. She gets very little support from the police and her own colleagues, who spend much of the novel downplaying her instincts and insinuating that Kit has somehow lost her edge and her astuteness. Here again is another difference between Kit and other heroines in the mystery genre: Kit is frequently unable to explain herself properly in order to garner the support she needs from the police and her colleagues. This, again could be off-putting, but I found that it added a kind of texture to the novel, making it all the more unique and interesting. What Kit shares in common with other mystery novel heroines is her fine sense of justice. Eventhough she's not quite sure if Michael Doll is a murderer or not, she refuses to take part in a kangaroo investigation that seems to be heading in the direction of fitting him up for the killings, solely because he is a rather repulsive and off-putting individual. Kit fights the police investigators all the way so that they will not take the easy way out and concentrate on one suspect only, thus losing sight of the 'big picture' sotospeak. "The Red Room" is a really interesting read. Kit Quinn, with all her anxiousness, compassion for the victims involved and their families, and courage to follow her instincts in spite of all the opposition she faces, is a rather engaging heroine. Some may find that her lack of assurance and her restrained manner makes her a rather uninteresting and unlikely heroine. However I found these traits drew me in more, and made her a lot more accessible than she otherwise may have been. The mystery itself was an interesting, if somewhat common one; however it was a well written and executed one, and engaged my interests from start to finish. A really good read.
Rating:
Summary: engaged my interest from start to finish
Review: I rather liked "The Red Room" by Nicci French. This novel is not quite like French's previous novels -- it is a little more subdued and restrained. The heroine, Dr. Kit Quinn, a forensic psychiatrist, is also a little different from previous French heroines: while interviewing a mentally unbalanced derelict, whom the police suspect of being a sexual deviant, Kit is rather badly scarred in the face when the derelict, Michael Doll goes spare and tries to attack the policeman in the interview room. Add to this the unpleasantness of being ignominiously dumped by her longtime boy friend, and you realise that Kit has lost a lot of her self-assurance and confidence. This makes her a little diffident at times, and very anxious at others. This is the tone that more or less pervades over much of the book; it can be exasperating for some readers, but if you put aside your preconceptions about how an investigative heroine is supposed to be or act, than "The Red Room" becomes a very interesting and rewarding read. Another interesting point about this mystery novel and it's heroine, is that Kit seems to operate best when she acts on instinct. When she first confronts the murder of the homeless runaway, Lianne, instinct makes Kit look at other unexplained murders/deaths, as she's very sure that that Lianne's death was not a one off. She gets very little support from the police and her own colleagues, who spend much of the novel downplaying her instincts and insinuating that Kit has somehow lost her edge and her astuteness. Here again is another difference between Kit and other heroines in the mystery genre: Kit is frequently unable to explain herself properly in order to garner the support she needs from the police and her colleagues. This, again could be off-putting, but I found that it added a kind of texture to the novel, making it all the more unique and interesting. What Kit shares in common with other mystery novel heroines is her fine sense of justice. Eventhough she's not quite sure if Michael Doll is a murderer or not, she refuses to take part in a kangaroo investigation that seems to be heading in the direction of fitting him up for the killings, solely because he is a rather repulsive and off-putting individual. Kit fights the police investigators all the way so that they will not take the easy way out and concentrate on one suspect only, thus losing sight of the 'big picture' sotospeak. "The Red Room" is a really interesting read. Kit Quinn, with all her anxiousness, compassion for the victims involved and their families, and courage to follow her instincts in spite of all the opposition she faces, is a rather engaging heroine. Some may find that her lack of assurance and her restrained manner makes her a rather uninteresting and unlikely heroine. However I found these traits drew me in more, and made her a lot more accessible than she otherwise may have been. The mystery itself was an interesting, if somewhat common one; however it was a well written and executed one, and engaged my interests from start to finish. A really good read.
|
