Dead Water

Rating:
Summary: Better than ever
Review: I always enjoy Benjamin January novels and learn a lot of history. Ben January is one of my heroes. I think of him, and of Rose, his friend, then his wife, even when not reading the books. The fear of being caught and sold as a slave -- though January was freed as a child and is a 'Free Man of Color' is palpable and edifying throughout all Hambly's books. Everybody should know about this. (And everybody should know that children and women, some men, are vulnerable in many places in the world to slavery, and that dark people in Iraq, for instance, are vulnerable to U.S. troops mistaking them for the enemy and being captured and tortured, much as blacks in the south were legally vulnerable for hundreds of years. --See Salon.com, 12/09/04, 'Whitewashing Torture'.)
In Dead Water, I learned a lot about river boats in the 1830s, how they sometimes go aground and have to be rocked by all the men on board until they can get it again into deeper water. How after it rains the water may be more travelable as it is higher, how later the rivers were dredged so that large riverboats such as the 'barn on a platform' boat here would have far less trouble.
Sometimes Hambly has written as if the plot is padded in around the historical notes and details of the time. -- Still the stories have held up nonetheless. In this one the plot and story equalled the history and I felt it was the most easy to read. Whichever, I always come away with a deep sense of place after reading one of the January novels and hoping for the next one. If, as suggested at the end of this, Mssr. Janvier is going to get involved in the underground railroad I will be even more fascinated to see what transpires. I hope, as one reviewer implied, this is not the end of the series (!!!!). I thank Barbara Hambly for her research, her creative stories and her taking me to an extremely important time and place, and with a very, very likable, admirable, honorable character.

Rating:
Summary: The best Benjamin January mystery yet
Review: I got hooked on Benjamin January books when I visited New Orleans for the first time a couple years ago. New Orleans is such a fascinating, historical city, and Barbara Hambly captures that feeling of what it must have been like to live in New Orleans in the early 1800's. I've read all her Benjamin January books. "Dead Water," in my opinion, is the best yet of the series. Sometimes in her other books, I've gotten weighed down with too many characters to keep track of. The characters in "Dead Water" are excellent. The book also ends with a hint of future endeavors for Ben and Rose, and it sounds as if it will be very interesting. I am looking forward to the next book already.

Rating:
Summary: Dead Water
Review: I was a bit disappointed with this latest installment, but I have to immediately qualify that statement.

Overall, the books in this series are well-written, marvellously researched, and boast a level of detail that makes the setting absolutely come alive. The plots are fast-moving with plenty of action and tension, and the characters are vividly drawn and interesting.

In this particular book, I thought there was slightly less detail and drama than in some of the earlier ones. My suspension of disbelief was a bit strained by the introduction of Jefferson Davis as a character, and I thought Hannibal's rather pathetic naivete in the duel clashed with his personality as I interpreted it in earlier books. I also missed Shaw (I really want a novel just about him. Sigh.)

However, Dead Water is still a book well worth reading and I recommend it.

Rating:
Summary: marvelous historical mystery
Review: In 1836 Bank of Louisiana President Hubert Granville wearily and depressingly informs his friend free man of color Benjamin January that his four thousand dollars is gone and the bankrupt firm can only make good with three hundred dollars. Hubert believes that bank manager Oliver Weems stole the specie and note reserves.

Ben learns that the crooked Oliver is leaving town on the steamboat Silver Moon. He and Rose also go on the steamboat hoping to catch Oliver with the loot. Ben acts as a valet to a white friend while Rose goes below, as required, to stay with the other free female Negroes and slaves. However, finding the stash proves difficult when someone tosses Weems into the Mississippi while the Underground Railroad works a watery route. As Ben gets involved with freeing slaves, battling with a so-called abolitionist, and a few other major sidebars, he has little time to concentrate on learning who killed weasel Weems and what happened to the money.

Few writers can provide as picturesque and complete look at life in pre Civil War New Orleans than Barbara Hambly does. Her latest tale DEAD WATER furbishes her usual full plate of historical tidbits entwined into a fabulous mystery. Besides the voodoo and the Twain like Mississippi descriptions, just the water route of the Underground Railroad will surprise readers into a slight paradigm though a river route seems so obvious. The crime elements hook the audience and Ben remains a wonderful protagonist so that combined with the enhanced setting fans receive a marvelous historical mystery.

Harriet Klausner


Rating:
Summary: On a steamship we will go...
Review: In Dead Water, Barbara Hambly gives us what could be the last of the Benjamin January series of suspense novels (her web site says that a decision won't be made on further entries until next year). If that is the case, she chose a more regular novel than usual to go out on. It's not that it's a bad book, because I still loved it. However, it's a lot more straightforward and not as intricate as past January books. It's still worth checking out, though.

In Dead Water, Ben & Rose are startled and frustrated to hear that the manager of the bank where they have all of their money (obtained in a previous adventure) saved in order to make their final payment on their house has stolen it all and is heading up the Mississippi river on a steamboat. The new manager asks Ben to book passage on the same boat and attempt to figure out where the gold and bank notes are. Ben engages the help of his old friend, Hannibal, in their quest, as Hannibal is able to act the role of master to Ben's slave to avoid suspicion. Once they get on the boat, they stumble on to more intrigue than just a case of missing gold. Secret affairs, slave trading, a voodoo curse and a man who makes a living stealing slaves complicate matters. Ben has to sort it all out while still keeping his cover and not acting like an "uppity black man." It's a good thing there's a future president of the Confederacy on board, especially when the bank manager ends up dead.

This sounds like a complicated plot, so why did I say it's more straightforward than usual? Usually, the situation that Ben & Rose find themselves in is very complex. Twists and turns abound and it can get confusing for the reader at times. There were times where I wasn't quite sure what was going on. This wasn't the case in Dead Water. Instead, Hambly throws a lot of simpler plots at us, hitting us with quantity instead of complexity. It doesn't work quite as well, though Hambly saves it with excellent characterization of everybody in the book. The problem becomes that all of the plots are resolved almost simultaneously, and Hambly falls once again into the annoying habit of having a sudden gun battle resolve a few of them. This has happened a bit too often in this series, and is probably the only fault.

Once again, Hambly dazzles in terms of characterization. Ben & Rose leap off the page, and Hannibal is his usual witty, sardonic and slightly opium-addled self. The dialogue between the three of them is wonderful, and the other characters are quite good too. Hambly captures their emotions perfectly. When gets left off the boat, his panic at the thought of Rose being captured by a slave trader and sold away from him is palpable, and the tension is riveting. The interaction between all of the other characters crackles as well, with animosity between the two slave traders, the romances and affairs that are all over the ship, and possibility of a voodoo priestess stowed away in the hold. This is great stuff.

It wouldn't be a Hambly review if I didn't mention the atmosphere. Hambly sets the stage like nobody I've ever known. She'll spend a couple of paragraphs just describing the setting where Ben & Rose are walking, allowing the reader to picture it vividly.
The people that colour these descriptions have nothing to do with the plot, but I'll bet you get a picture of where Ben is. As a reader, you dive into the setting, and you feel like you're on a steamship in the middle of the Mississippi. Hambly's prose is quite evocative and it makes the book even more enjoyable.

One problem for long time fans, and it's a problem with Days of the Dead, is the lack of Abishag Shaw, the New Orleans police chief. He's the best character in the entire series, and he's been gone for a while. For this reason, I'll be even sadder if this is the last book in the series. On the other hand, it is nice that Hambly doesn't try to shoehorn characters into the story where they don't belong. Some mystery novelists do that and it gets on my nerves. Hambly avoids that trap.

Dead Water suffers only in comparison to the other Ben January books. There are a bit too many coincidences for it to be among the best. However, it's still better than a lot of other books out there. If this is Ben January's last hurrah, it's certainly not a bad one to go out on.

Rating:
Summary: An Emotionally Powerful Book!
Review: It's very difficult to pick the best Benjamin January novel, but I really did enjoy this one. The suspense kept building and building throughout the book until the final amazing chapter. In this book we really get to see what being a passenger on a steamboat in the 1830's was like. And January himself - who appears larger than life - has grown and developed into a really well-rounded and well-developed character, and he truly makes this series. It is also Ms. Hambly's skill with weaving plots, settings and characters that makes this series so exceptional. In this book January, his wife Rose and their friend Hannibal are passengers on a river boat as they are trying to track down a thief who has threatened one of the New Orleans banks. It is even more important for Ben because the bank that was robbed happened to be his own bank, and unless he and his wife and friend can find the missing money, Ben and Rose will lose everything they hold dear. What more can I say? This book is as close to a masterpiece as any you'll find in the historical thriller genre.

Rating:
Summary: Suspenseful, emotionally involving and memorable
Review: The Benjamin January series is one of the best historical series being written today, mystery OR mainstream. Hambly's breadth of research and talent for creating atmosphere is matched by the depth and realism of her characters, resulting in a Dickensian portrait of ante-bellum New Orleans that is suspenseful, emotionally involving and utterly memorable.

"Dead Water" is in my opinion the "breakout" novel of the series, raising the stakes to include the whole institution of slavery. Extraordinarily satisfying -- highly recommended.

My only complaint is the wait of (what looks like) two years to find out what happens next.