Fairness: A Novel

Rating:
Summary: Subtle, Understated, Moving....
Review: As a newcomer to Mount's writing, I admit his style tends to develop slowly for readers expecting more obvious dramatic flair.

For whatever reason, Gus reminds me of John Dowell, Ford Madox Ford's ambivalent, wavering, duped, narrator in "The Good Soldier." They both are jilted lovers who gradually realize their idealized conception of the world around them is a facade. This is one of the variations of first-person narration. The common theme is to give the narrator all knowing insight, VOG (voice of god), compared with the mere mortals surrounding them. In this novel, Mount takes the less traveled path. That being, the less than entirely reliable narrator who evokes pity. The possibilities here are usually more interesting. Insomuch as the reader identifies with the author's voice, the learning curve is dynamic and elastic...

Rating:
Summary: Does not travel well "across the Pond."
Review: Ferdinand Mount is an elegant, controlled, and immensely intelligent writer, and his Jem (and Sam) is brilliant. When I saw this new book at the local bookstore, I read the blurbs on the jacket and and bought it on impulse. But while it was pleasant enough reading and offered some interesting morsels to chew on, I found it ultimately disappointing. The third novel in Mount's Chronicle of Modern Twilight, Fairness features the same characters. Unless you have read the other novels, however, you may be as nonplussed as I was by the huge gaps between the characters as described in summaries and on the book jacket, and the same characters as you find them in this novel. This is not Mount's fault, but the potential reader should be cautious.

Gus Cotton, the narrator, is a young man who, at the outset of this book, becomes friends with golden-haired Helen, like him working as a nanny/tutor one summer in Normandy. Gus and Helen, their employers, the children and friends of the employers, and even the bookies and racetrack touts from the earlier novels in the series appear and reappear, sometimes in extraordinary coincidences, over the twenty year time span of this novel. Unfortunately, Gus himself is a cipher, too phlegmatic to inspire much sympathy, and not strong enough to hold the myriad characters and long plot line together. Helen is described as aspiring 'to a morally satisfying life,' yet throughout the book she constantly makes self-interested and surprising compromises, and falls into bed with just about everyone. There are few occasions in which we see Helen wrestling with moral decisions--she simply acts, impulsively. Though the blurb-writer calls her a 'modern female counterpart to Candide,' she is actually a mystifying and depressing character, without the obvious naivete one associates with Candide and which allows for lively satire.

A government-sanctioned stripping of mineral resources from a Central African country, a miners' strike, and a child abuse investigation feature in the plot and involve both Gus and Helen. While these may be the scandals 'that have defined'-and sometimes shattered--the latter decades of the 20th century' for British readers, they are not so familiar to American readers, and their significance pales.

Fairness may be an important part of Mount's large scale Chronicle of Modern Twilight. It may develop themes and social commentary significant to the overall success of the Chronicle. As a separate novel, however, it was not an exhilarating or comic experience, at least for this American reader. This rating is three stars for enjoyment, five stars for the writing.

Rating:
Summary: You won't get no satisfaction
Review: I really tried to get into this novel, being a big Waugh fan. And while I have respect for Mount's writing style, this novel basically stinks. The characters are pretty obtuse, and there are too many of them and they run together...sort of like Brideshead Revisited, except these characters aren't interesting or charming. The just have eccentric names. Due to its far-flung locations and bizarre characters, this novel should be far more exciting than it is. Overall, much like the hero, a reader can't get no satisfaction.