Rating: 
Summary: More Than I Expected
Review: As I have always been a huge fan of knights and chivalry, I expected to enjoy reading Don Quixote. I was ammused with the misadventures as well as the comedy of the novel. But what I enjoyed most about the novel was what I learned from it. I admired Sancho's devotion to his master dispite all their troubles and Don Quixote's look on his life. He knows who he is and who he may be if he chooses. I admire his taking his life into his own hands, even if he must be crazy to be happy.
Rating: 
Summary: Fresh, Exciting, and Funny!
Review: As this story is 400 years old, I expect this book to be dry and dull and written in difficult to understand language. I could not have been more wrong in my life! This story is totally engrossing and, more than once, will cause the reader to laugh out loud.
This is known as the world's first novel, and while reading it it was difficult to keep in mind that Cervantes did not have a blueprint to follow. Everytime I opened this book to read more, I felt like Cervantes was sitting there, spinning this tale for me. I've never been a fan of stories of knights and adventure stories, but this book kept me fully interested. I couldn't wait to finish it!
What is truly wonderful is this is a story for all ages: young, old, and everyone in between. The size of the book may intimidate some at 1,000 pages, but don't let that happen. When a reader becomes involved with Don Quioxte and Sancho Panza and all the characters they encounter, the reader simply doesn't want the story to come to an end.
In all fairness, this book was written in 2 parts. Once writing the 1st part, and seeing its popularity, Cervantes wrote part 2 just before he died. I have to admit that the 1st part is more compelling that the 2nd part, but not by a whole lot. There are adventures brought up in part 2 that one can only guess at in part 1. If one can only read some of this novel, then read part 1. But really, do yourself a favor and read the whole book. I doubt anyone would be disappointed.
I seldom re-read books, but this is one I plan on re-reading in the future. Thoroughly enjoyable!
Rating:
Summary: Greatest book ever written
Review: Don Quixote is a classic piece of literature. If someone could produce a more up to date, vernacular translation, it would rival any comedy made today. This is a story about one man caught up in so many chivalry books that he becomes insane and starts traveling through Spain acting as a heroic knight while fighting made up villains and monsters. By his side is his gullible yet loyal servant Sancho.It's nice to know that during the Renaissance period such humor existed. The first part of the book deals with him traveling throughout and mixing up inns for castles, random people as kings or knights, and a random woman as his unrequited love for which all of the world must know. It's a tragic comedy where one man's insanity and futility provide worry for a few, concern for others, and great entertainment for most of the characters. What's interesting is the "twist" in the middle that leads to the second part, where after one man wrote a book about Don Quixote's wild adventures, a rich family, upon seeing the actual man who was in the book, decide to play along in probably the cruelest hoax in history. Claiming there Duke and Duchess, and promising the most absurd things. One of which was giving Sancho an actual province to rule over. The one thing that irked me about this book was that even though it needs to be translated for English readers, no translator has yet made the book as fluid or readable as it deserves to be. All in all, it's a good book, but hopefully a general author, and not some stuffy scholar, could translate it what it should be - a really funny and tragic story.
Rating:
Summary: A comic masterpiece about truth and illusion
Review: Don Quixote is a comedy, which could only have been written by the hitherto obscure genius later in life after he had suffered injury on the battlefield and was subject to periods of harsh confinement in prison. The comedy is bittersweet about this everyman who lives strictly by a code of ancient ethical ideals that inspire him to fits of lunacy, folly and madness. Lucid, indeed inspired, when the subject is anything but knight errantry, Quixote's commitment to his ideals brings him insult, injury, poverty and ridicule. This knight is duped by his convictions into waging war on windmills, galley slaves, funeral processions, pilgrims, shepherds, herds of bulls and countless chimeras invoked in the name of love for his Dona el Toboso. This most chaste of knights cannot see the realities of human nature and worse cannot accept them. His endless brutal punishments for his idealistic blindspots plague him and his squire, Pancho Panza, wherever they aspire in the personal quest to right an injury, assist a noble cause, protect the weak and innocent, and slay evil demons of every imaginable stripe. When I first read this novel, I thought Quixote a fool who was duly punished for being so out of touch with reality. By the end of the novel I saw that Don Quixote was no less than an everyman whose noblest instincts were doomed to bring suffering upon him as he was driven to confront the baser powers of existence. What Crusader fails to risk madness in the wake of the futility of human action in a vast, overpowering and hostile universe? In Quixote and Sancho I caught a glimpse of Vladimir and Estragon in "Waiting for Godot." One man's truth is another's falsehood. One man's reality is another's illusion. One man's ideal is another's folly. Yet Quixote rides out in his quests across Spain, nevertheless, without fear for the chaos he engenders nor the futility of his cause nor the danger to himself or his best friend. For his nobility Don Quixote becomes not only famous and truly beloved but also earns immortality. Read this "father of the modern novel" for its wit and genius and classical construction to understand the Quixotic ideals that stir within you and the possibilities for real victory of the human spirit.
Rating:
Summary: DON'T FOOL YOURSELF
Review: DON QUIXOTE is a masterpiece and Smollet's translation is also a masterpiece--the best possible, as it reads like an original. Want DQ in modern English? Don't fool yourself--you'll never get the same feeling--DQ is even difficult for Spanish-speakers to read! The raves on the back cover are not misleads.
Rating:
Summary: Where to begin?
Review: How do I, a literary amateur, rate a book nearly 400 years old that has been acclaimed by not a few scholarly experts as the greatest novel ever written? I feel a bit like the boy who had the temerity to point out that the emperor was naked, for I have failed to award Don Quixote five stars. Judged by modern-day standards, Cervantes could be accused of sloppiness. He confuses the chronology of his own storyline in several places, though this is as charming as it is perplexing. Seeking to satirically skewer the tales of chivalrous knights-errant popular at the time, Cervantes presents us with Quixote, a loveable madman, and his squire, Sancho Panza, who fluctuates between utter naivete and admirable sagacity throughout. The pair are nothing if not endearing. Sallying forth to right wrongs, assist the down-trodden, and punish the wicked, the two find themselves in a pragmatic and cynical world, astonished and humored by the lunatic idealism of Quixote and the simpleminded fealty of his squire. Over the course of 5 weeks I read Don Quixote and the experience was varied. At times enthralled, at times merely mildly amused, I looked eagerly forward to resuming the book and, on occasion, half-heartedly attempted to avoid it. To be blunt, there is much in the book that borders on childlike innocence, but there is much as well that strikes a deep chord of love, idealism, perserverence, and grace. On the surface, Don Quixote and Sancho Panza could be regarded as fools. Beneath this foolishness, however, lie the hearts of lions and an unconquerable spirit which provide the ultimate reward to the reader. The book ends abruptly and badly. After so many adventures through so many pages it was disappointing to behold the manner in which Cervantes opted to close. However, this should by no means dissuade the potential reader. Indeed, Don Quixote, for everything wonderful contained within it, should be read by all. For those who choose to do so, the Putnam translation is outstanding and footnoted with excellent detail.
Rating:
Summary: silly, serious, funny, tragic, exciting, tedious and sad
Review: I adored this book. Very long, at times very slow, Don Quixote basically tells us that the noble delusions of a madman can create a far more satisfying example of life than the bleak, grounded and urgently seriously expectations of scholars, the religious and politically minded as well as the everyday drone who keeps a tight reign on what they will allow themselves to believe. Don Quixote himself (as so many other reviewers either trumpet and proclaim or allow themselves to admit) is a flat out wonderful creation; a man so clearly out of his mind and yet one we cannot help but root for and hope to be never disuaded from his insanity, that he becomes something of an aspiration for all of us dreamers and imaginative souls. Here is a man who believes on in good, in what is noble and decent (let us ignore the occasional lapses into seeming intolerance, taking the early 17th century into account and contrast that with both Don Quixote's treatment of the so-called scourge as well as the identity of the fictitious author of this work within the work) and in an essential love for all of humanity. None of us--and that includes no one--can ever hope to even reflect the nobility of this grand character. His truth, filled with wizards and monsters and dreams coming true, is more like a place we all wish we could be than the sad and head-wagging tragedy it might be in our own realities. This book is a thing of beauty, a hope screaming in a bottomless well of scorned dreams that make up all of our lives and to condemn such flights of fancy and such obvious ranting lunacy makes one resemble the sad, defeated figure at the end of this book. The lesson to be learned is that once we give up on our dreams, all that is left is death. Recommended very highly. The length should not intimidate or put one off as it is a quick-paced narrative filled with adventures and excitement and all told with a cool-headed satirical view. Give it a chance and do not take anything like logistical errors and clear and obvious mistakes to heart as Cervantes was wise enough to catch himself later on and comment on all the misunderstandings that any academic and humorless mind might see fit to whine about and then tell that person they are a fool because they cannot relate to the Don's point of view.
Rating:
Summary: Don Quijote, by a spanish author
Review: I read this book in its original language, spanish (since it is my first language too), and I found Don Quijote's adventures fascinating, comical, and sometimes even slightly pathetic.
"El Ingenioso Hidalgo Don Quijote de la Mancha" is about a man, Alonso Quijana, who reads so many books of knights from the middle ages (this was written in the baroque times, NOT the renaissance or the enlightement as other reviews say) that he loses his mind and decides to become a knight as well. This anacronysm is the first clue of the comic life Don Quijote leads from then on.
The whole novel is a mockery of other books about knights (although not about the knights themselves), as Don Quijote continually struggles to do justice and to right wrongs, but is met with nothing but sad defeats.
Overall, although it is very long and uses somewhat complicated language (it is written in spanish from the 1600s, although I suppose that the translation makes it simpler as it is to modern day words), Don Quijote and his adventures are something that I'd reccomend to anyone with the patience to read it.
Rating:
Summary: The beauty of the Spanish
Review: If you were two pick only two books written in Spanish, one would certainly be "Don Quijote" and the second most likely would be
"Cien Años de Soledad". In the adventure of acquiring a new language, in my case the English, one uncosnciously forget about the richness of his own language. Reading this book has helped me to remind myself about the beauty of the Spanish as a literaly vehicle. Although most of the reviews here focus on the characters and the story, my own reading of Cervantes is about the writting and the beauty of the literature by itself.
The story is just an excuse to reinvent and define what the ideal Spanish language is. That's why when reading the book in Spanish one is more prone to forgive the excursions from the main story. This book makes worth to learn Spanish just to be able to read it.
Rating:
Summary: timeless
Review: living according to antiquated books of chivalry is dated. after a few hundred years, the rules change, the old practices seem absurd thus humorous to some while aggravating to others. it seems to me that cervantes makes himself timeless by pointing out this principle. his satire shows how silly one can seem to be by blindly applying the accepted principles of the day. not all principles are silly, of course. cervantes shows that the hook line and sinkerisms of the world are the most entertaining to see in action. at the same time, cervantes aptly puts into question the definition of true nobility, of true courage, of truth itself. does the fact that don quixote intends to do the right thing by "following the rules" make him noble and courageous? or, does the fact that his perceptions are less than real make his nobility even more fictitious than his world? given the amount of times that homo sapiens has erred [couldn't resist that one] from the truth, this reader prefers to side with intent, not content, and i suspect that those who enjoy this novel agree, while those who don't, don't. it certainly makes the read more entertaining to be able to love the hero while laughing at his mistakes -- to be able to "love the sinner" but still be able to "hate the sin".
|
