Cold Mountain : A Novel

Rating:
Summary: Best Book I've read this year, except for A FINE BALANCE
Review: This book was compelling to read (could not put it down), good story, beautiful language, exquisite detail, interesting characters, and brought me face to face with history, both of the country, and my own family history. Having grown up on a farm in the early 50's I still have memories of my grandmother wringing the necks of chickens, canning vegetables and killing hogs. Putting dinner on the table in those days meant a lot more personal investment of effort than now. Thank you, Mr. Frasier for filling out this thread of history in such a believable way. I actually lived in this time and place during my reading of this book, and these characters will never leave me. Ada could have been my great grandmother.

Rating:
Summary: Frazier could have used an editor
Review: Something is seriously wrong with a novel in which most of the text is devoted to the detailed description of food and scenery, apparently in an attempt to convince us that we are reading "literature." The voice of the narrator is most uneven, sometimes 19th Century, sometimes not. Inman and Ada are strangely cold and one-dimensionsal, so that it is difficult to care what happens to either of them. Ruby is a bit better but altogether too good to be true. And the character of the fat-assed moron Pangle, who just happens to be a musical genius on the banjo, is an obvious steal from "Deliverance." Apparently, Frazier did not have the services of a competent editor, who would have cut the text by half and evened out the narrator's voice, among other things. However, those poor souls who were seduced by "The Bridges of Madison County" may well regard this book as another literary masterpiece.

Rating:
Summary: Cold Mountain is a brutal distillation of truth.
Review: Cold Mountain is a brutal distillation of truth surrounded by human frailty and courage. Inman is an everyman who rejects the killing and realizes that the only truth is one free from politics, nationalism and polemnic coercion. After 40 years of novel reading, this emerges as one of the best. This book has a Dickensian quality and flavor.

Rating:
Summary: What a read! What a walk!
Review: "Cold Mountain" is a wonderful story, wonderfully told. Ada's developing strength and Ruby's pragmatism are a perfect counter to Inman as he trudges through the mountains toward home. Goatwoman is full of wisdom and even Stobrod redeems himself. Frazier's language and descriptons are exquisite. Loved the ending and it was far from what I'd anticipated.

Rating:
Summary: A story of desolation and redemption.
Review: Charles Frazier's wonderful first novel is the story of a soldier's recovery from the devastation of war. In a parallel story, his beloved grows from sheltered innocence to independence. Along the way, the reader is treated to the natural beauty of the landscape, a picture of life on the home front, and a variety of well-drawn characters. A beautifully written, powerful tale. The best new fiction I can remember.

Rating:
Summary: interesing and well written but somewhat tedious
Review: i think i expected more-although the background research is expansive and impressive , the storyline dragged and i wanted to see inman and ada end up together. on the other hand , it was very true to life as things don't always have a happy ever after ending, and the epilogue reflected on the fact that life does go on. some of the diction at times appeared pretentious but that was the language of the day and frazier was right on for the 1860's i feel that sooo much work went into this book that it deserves a higher rating than the 7 i gave it, but i just didn't get the same high that so many others seem to have gotten. one thig for sure , it certainly made me think of the effect of war on the everyday people--what a waste of so many lives as is the case in any war--and not just the battlefield wars--so many lives are impacted even tho they may be far removed from the front.

Rating:
Summary: Storyteller in spades.
Review: I am amazed at some of the panning this book has received. With out a doubt this book ranks way up there with the likes of - well, name them all. Mr Frazier shares with us not only vivid snapshots of his 200 year old mountain legacy, he also paints word scapes. Each character is a microcosm of us all. This is the real deal. I havn't read anything as indelible for many years.

Rating:
Summary: COLD MOUNTAIN is a fresh view of the Civil War in the South
Review: There is no glory for the South in this love and Civil War story by Charles Frazier. In speaking at a recent book reading, Mr. Frazier said he didn't want to write another Civil War story. He didn't. He has given us a tale of love left behind and a soldier returning home to that love. The love he left embodies both the fauna and flora of Cold Mountain and the girl named Ada. On his long walk home Inman experiences mans inhumanity to man as well as an occasional unexpected gesture of kindness. This is a well written tale of love and war that you will enjoy.

Rating:
Summary: A true literary masterpice. Great fiction is alive in 1997.
Review: This book does for me what only one other author did. William Faulkner could slowly draw you in, wring you out, and you felt good to be alive after you finished reading. Frazier's two characters will be an indelible part of my consciousness, just as I remember Quentin Compton, whom I still think of fondly 25 years after first reading The Sound and the Fury.

Rating:
Summary: Reached the warning track
Review: Frazier is of enviable talent. The grace in his storytelling (though a bit marbled) and the visual potency in his scenes are inspiring. The story grips you; it is worth wading through a bucket's worth of details and asides, which sometimes seemed more like attempts to classify his work as "literature." I wished there had been more emphasis given to progressing the story, and perhaps a little humor to add another human dimension. But a truly touching and often-engrossing book, nonetheless.