Rating: Summary: The Mother of Dark Prognostication Review: What simpleton compares "1984" to "Brave New World?"New World is a simple morality tale about a world forced into conspicuous consumption. Yawn. 1984 is the frightening tale of a future gone awry, and a brutal government well aware of its intention to maintain power at all cost. We follow Winston, an editor with an odd job, rewriting history. Wiston is forced to "double think" his way through a life he knows is contrived to forever remain stagnant. As Winston ponders the present, the war weary remains of Oceania's capital, London, he is forced to deal with memories of a very different past - and he fails to reconcile the two. Orwell's eye is a magic thing. A reporter at heart, his eye for detail in fiction and reportage is awesome. While reading 1984, one feels Orwell IS Winston, in his head and in his world. With any imagination it becomes easy to allow 1984 to become real, and Winston's desperation your own. Orwell side steps silly sci-fi detail (that dopey Huxley embraces too readily. What is it with all the helicopters in "Brave New World," anyway?)and creates a desperate world that, though written 50 years ago, seems perfectly plausible now. This chilling masterpiece is a must read for anyone who ponders the delicate balance of power and politics. More so, this dark tome considers the loss of individuality in an increasing global society. At first blush, it is easy to dismiss 1984 as completely off the mark, but after some consideration, one is forced to concede that maybe nothing here is really improbably. A must read.
Rating: Summary: More than a great novel Review: 1984 by George Orwell is the frightening classic about the loss of freedom of thought in a totalitarian society. Judging from the luminous exposition of the world of 1984's structure, found in latter bit of part 2, Orwell scholarlily traced the history of organized society to date and decided upon a strictly terrifying and inhumane future. The author's vision of 1984 (conceived in 1949) is a cold, shocking and quite believable one. The Americas and England are united under the banter of Oceania. Big Brother is the godlike icon that leads Oceania. The Party is its governmental body. Anything the party says, any moral it promotes, any record of the past (including who has died or who has ever been born) it keeps is correct. One is monitored by the Party at all times and should not find that uncomfortable. If one shows any sign of unorthodoxy, anything but love and obedience to Big Brother and the Party, he or she must doublethink it, let it submerge into the unconscious and be replaced by more appropriate feelings or else he or she has committed thoughtcrime. With the almost omnipotent Party's stringent regulation of thoughts, 1984's protagonist, Winston Smith, feels like a dead man before the narration even begins. Orwell takes readers along Smith's gloomy, hopeless path of deviation, from scribbling of "Down with Big Brother" in a furtive diary to his falling in love with the spirited, young rebel, Julia to his active mutiny to finally his inevitable detainment and terrifying rehabilitation, a process which takes readers to the black heart of the Party. Not only is 1984 a well paced, masterfully executed narrative, the concepts and principles it explores are awfully universal and still utterly relevant. One could apply Orwell's hypothesis's to both the adulation of figures from the American Revolution and how unquestionable we consider their policies and current events in the U.S. as explained by the exceptional review posted by Jim Brett on October third. 1984 is more than just a superb novel. It is a warning.
Rating: Summary: outstanding Review: this was an excellent book. the plot is great; it has suspence, and lots of other good things like that.
Rating: Summary: 1984 and counting! Review: Required reading. Unfortunately Orwell was not obvious enough. 1984 was not a prediction of what was to come. Orwell was writing about what already existed. As I read some reviews and talk to "educated" people, I'm amazed at how many believe that Orwell was not talking about America but rather some "evil" empire like Russia, China or Cuba. Wake up Winston! Big Brother has been alive and well for HUNDREDS of years. Could terrorism be our present "outside threat"? It depends on whether outside means inside. Ask Emperor Clinton. Does sex mean sex? Does Is mean is? Newspeak is here to stay. If you'd like to read something clearly written about government and society look for HOW TO SAVE AMERICA AND THE WORLD: The Elimination of Terrorism, Greed and Other Evils. (Available January 2002)
Rating: Summary: Another great book by Orwell... Review: This is THE most depressing book I have ever read. It's just so hopeless. It actually made me CRY at the end. It's a really good insight into collectivism and totalitarianism. Just an all around good book.
Rating: Summary: Frightening when we see how this is what some plan for us Review: More relevant than ever over 50 years after it was written.It is more frightening than any Steven King novel because this is where we are heading if we are not vigilant. Too many on the left are still hellbent in plunging us into a worldwide Orwellian nightmare. Just observe their obsessive Orwellism, where aggressors are defenders and defenders are aggressors, where justice is injustice and injustice is justice, where war is peace and peace is war, where freedom fighters are terrorists and terrorists are freedom fighters, and with its total lack of interest in facts and truth. Despite the chilling socio-political warning the book still shows us an endearingly poignant portrayal of humanity and love struggling to survive in totalitarian society which will not stop at anything to stamp out all that is good and compassionate. Next time you hear anyone refer to anything disparagingly as 'borgeois' think of the alternative to love,honour,fair play and all the noble things that some brand 'bourgeois' and therefore plan to destroy
Rating: Summary: Absolutely not for optimists and fairly tale seekers. Review: If you are looking for a story in which the 'good' always gets their way in slayering the 'evil', then this book is not for you. With some knowledge of Orwell's critism, political beliefs, views on society, and hatre towards totalism, from having to have read some of his political essays, it seems like Orwell was expressing his outcry towards the world through this chilling, hatefull novel, astonishingly. Kudos to Mr. Orwell for sending his vision out in a 'story' form, in which is more efficient in getting out to the people. I pray that his fear would become the fear of every person in the world, and work together to stay away from it. Turn "Freedom is Slavery" into Freedom is Liberty, and all shall deserve it.
Rating: Summary: This is where we're headed folks Review: The ideas in this book are ones that are as appropriate now as when Orwell first wrote them. In this time (2001), we have our "Two Minutes Hate" with Osama bin Laden. Many of the principles that Orwell writes about (e.g., thought control) are done in a quite blatant way in the book. In the real world of the 20th/21st century they're done, only much more subtly. That way, we don't know they being perpetrated on us. Here's how 1984 applies to current events: WAR IS PEACE The new "War on Terrorism" is being sold as a guarantor or our safety. While this war is being waged, we're to accept permanent war as a fact of life. As the unavoidable slaughter of innocents unfolds overseas, we are told to go back to "living our lives." FREEDOM IS SLAVERY "Freedom itself was attacked," Bush said. He's right, though here's the twist: Americans are about to lose many of their most cherished freedoms in a frenzy of paranoid legislation. The government wants to tap our phones, read our email and seize our credit card records without court order. Further, it wants authority to detain and deport immigrants without cause or trial. To save freedom, we have to destroy it. IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH America's "new war" against terrorism will be fought with unprecedented secrecy, including press restrictions not seen for years, the Pentagon has advised. When you read this book, you'll be better able to see the signs around you. The world portrayed by Orwell may well come to pass by the end of this century.
Rating: Summary: Too bad it's coming true... Review: thanks to right wing Republicans and Christians in this country. Great book! He was truly a visionary, how he predicted this coming. Good bye civil liberties!
Rating: Summary: Where to begin? Review: I wouldn't know. I don't even know how to rate this book, 1 star for the spectacularly morose and hopeless ending, or 5 stars because of the wondrous writing and story-telling ability of Mr. Orwell. I've always read books to hear a story, sort of a movie for the mind if you will. In those books I pick one or more characters that I can understand and develop sympathies with, as I did almost immediately with Winston in this book. As the setting opens, I saw this bleak, horrible future where there is no hope, where all thoughts are literally monitored by the Thought Police, where individuality is crime. And as Winston trudges through life I followed along, pulling for him, hoping for the guy, always in the back of my mind that it *will* get better for him and all the others, only if a way is found to make that happen. I recognized Big Brother as evil, and I wanted and still want to see him overthrown in my mind...the setting of the book practically demands his/thier downfall. And then Orwell gives you hope, as Winston and newly acquired lover Julia join a resistance movement to attempt to undermine the current regime and set in place one that will better itself and more importantly it's citizens. I hoped for these people, I suffered with them. Orwell's writing is magnificent in that he makes you care about the characters he writes about as if you know them personally, which is why what he does at the end of this book is nothing short of criminal. Even after thier capture by the Thought Police and thier torture and incarceration I couldn't help but think that somehow Winston would manage to escape and help throw down the shackles of Big Brother, but in the end all hope is ripped away. I still shake my head sadly when recalling this book feeling as though I've been cheated by the experience, with only the warning that socialism and communism do not work. Ironic that Orwell himself was a socialist, and that the ultimate bane to the world he describes is and always will be capitalism. Recommended only for someone who will take this book and digest it as a worst case scenario for human life, and learn from it.
|