Rating: 
Summary: Excellent, yet empty
Review: This book was an excellent read, and well worth it. And, in one way, the resolution of the fates of Dr. Lecter and Clarice Starling is satisfying, as are all fairy tales. However, taken in the context of Harris's earlier books, I feel a bit let down. This ended up just fluff, not the gritty substance we expect from Harris. It almost feels to me as if Harris wrote the book to cave in to years of pressure, and then rounded it all out and presented it as neatly and prettily packaged as one of Hannibal Lector's beribboned box lunches from Fauchon. The paperback romance reader in me applauds it. However the tough FBI wannabe in me, the one who admired and applauded Starling in "Lambs" kind of cringes. Seems this one was written with the silver screen in mind.
Rating: 
Summary: Disappointing
Review: Great, the Phantom Menace of the printed word. A book with some great ideas, some beautiful prose, but one that fails to satisfy and has, to use a prosaic word, a dumb conclusion. Harris needs a good editor. Harris is a very, very good writer, but he should have resisted the pressure and written something else--not bowing to the moneymen who wanted a sequel to "Silence." He must have known--why else did it take him 11 years to produce a sequel?
Rating:
Summary: Not as scary as RED DRAGON and SILENCE, but still compelling
Review: The third in Harris' Lecter trilogy, HANNIBAL is not up to the quality of the first two novels. More "yucky" detail than scary suspense, it was still compelling, if only to see what happened to its two main characters, Hannibal and Clarice. I bought it the day it was published, read it that day, and donated it to my local library; I'm keeping my hardcover copies of his first two books.
Rating: 
Summary: Not for the squeamish!
Review: Whoa! Definitely worth the wait... I was gasping in astonishment and shouting "Oh no!" a dozen times. Outdoes both Red Dragon and SotL many times over. Sure, the plot is pretty far-fetched (like that of its predecessors), but Harris's writing skill makes it believable.
Rating:
Summary: Disturbing, Intricate, Horrific
Review: I, like everyone else, was first in line at the bookstore this week, anxiously waiting for my copy of the continuing saga of our favorite doctor. I read it in a day (as I am sure the rest of you did) and ended the book exhausted. Complex plot, various locations, old and new characters. I greatly enjoyed the work, but question the ending - it was a bit hard for me to swallow.
Rating:
Summary: Not exactly what I expected, but a great read.
Review: I too have read and thoroughly enjoyed Harris' three previous thrillers. As for Hannibal: I can't wait for the movie! If Jodie Foster and Anthony Hopkins are cast again in the lead roles they should be a cinch for Oscars. Not only are there opportunities for scary stuff, but they'll also get to play some dark and delicious comedy. As some readers have commented, Harris may have pushed the envelope a bit beyond credible. But I've got to believe that his tongue was buried very deep in his cheek while writing some of the more incredible scenes. Foster and Sir Anthony will be challenged when playing the near-the-end dinner scene to avoid giggling and coming across as the Adams family. And that's not a putdown, I really enjoyed the book!
Rating: 
Summary: Pleasantly Surprised
Review: My 8 year thirst for Hannibal has been quenched this week! I read this book in two days and enjoyed every second of it! Mr. Harris brilliantly created a story that only certain kinds of readers would like. I learned a side of Hannibal that allowed me to confidently root for him, and I also realized that there are "monsters" worse than he is. The suspense of his abduction, and coming to understand the reason *why* Hannibal is what he is, makes this book so worthy to read.The supporting characters and the conclusion were pleasant surprises, however, I am not sure how this book will translate on the screen, unless the viewer has read this book, and anticipates serious editing and some deviation from the book. In any event, if "Hannibal" does become a movie... I'm so there!!!
Rating:
Summary: pageturner at best.
Review: red dragon still gives me the chills. silence of the lambs was a worthy sequel. this has the feel of an author inspired by contractual obligations in lieu of artistic license. i did finish it quickly, but it leaves no lasting impression other than your average page turner.
Rating:
Summary: Harris still does it better than anyone else
Review: Hannibal is kind of like "The Two Jakes." Jack Nicholson's sequel to "Chinatown" couldn't measure up, but I thought it was a pretty damn good movie. Harris' characters are once again vivid, but Silence of the Lambs had the most engrossing plot for both a book and a movie with which I have been enticed. Hannibal was more grossing than engrossing, but still I ate it up quicker than a certain bad boy's brains got consumed. Margo is a particularly vivid character. Cast Demi Moore in the movie. The aforementioned Jack Nicholson could have a lot of fun with Mason.
Rating: 
Summary: A sad dumbing down of intelligent, diabolical Dr. Lecter
Review: This book was a tremendous disappointment. The intelligence of Red Dragon and Silence of the Lambs is no where to be found in this tepid, stupid, gory for no reason sequel. Life's too short to waste your time on this one.
|
