Rating: Summary: Slow moving and tedious Review: Although I was impressed by the author's intellect and encyclopedic knowledge of diverse topics, the characters and narrative were less than engrossing. The storyline progressed at a snail's pace as I kept waiting for an interesting plotline to develop. Although I learned more than I ever wanted to know about the Knights Templar, I find most history text books more engrossing.
Rating: Summary: Amazing what Eco inspires others to write... Review: I am once again amazed at how intelligent people sound after reading a well written book. I'm not going to spout any big words pretending to be some quasi-literary scholar. Its a good book. Read it. You'll like it.
Rating: Summary: A fascinating yet overdrawn novel Review: Eco is a brilliant storyteller, and this novel conveys very powerfully how some people are drawn into a spiral of insanity and destruction by their fascination with the possibility of achieving arcane knowledge. Well written and at some points hilariously funny, the book succeeds as a rationalist's take on occultism. But Eco should have stuck to that story. The intermittent allusions to Belbo's childhood in fascist Italy and the main character's university days are interesting in their own right but do not always fit well into the novel and at times rendered it disjointed and tedious. In the end we get a novel that tries to cover too much ground but gets to raise some wonderful points about humanity's benighted quests for ultimate meaning.
Rating: Summary: An amazingly intelligent author writes a dull book. Review: Eco is a brilliant man who did a tremendous amount of research in order to produce this book. But he tends to drag, sputtering fact after fact. This can get very tiring in a 500+ page book.
Rating: Summary: A sequel to "The Name of the Rose" Review: Dazzling book, and a natural (if geographically and chronologically shifted) sequel to "the name of the rose." If in the first novel the underlying question was the role of the sign as an intermediary between the subject and the object of knowledge (the overquoted--yet here quoted--stat rosa pristina nomine, nomina nuda tenemus), the topic of this second book is the use of the sign to create reality. In other words: if everybody says that a tree fell in the forest but nobody can confirm it, did it really happen?The relevance for our world of media-mediate (excuse the alliteration) reality is immediate. From the pentagon control over the news of the gulf war, to Nixon's "big lie," the dangers of the sign run amok are all too real and magnificently represented in the book. The overflowing stream of connections that Casaubon, Belbo, and Diotallevi are able to justify sound as incredibly real in a world of UFO abductions, Millennial Cassandras, and New Age theorists. I won't comment on the style, since I read the Italian version and many comments seem to refer to the English translation. Like others, I found the finale a little weak. I wanted to withold one star for this, but then I wondered is, in spite of my best efforts, I had been ruined forever by despicable Hollywood habits. Are the last 10 pages of a book really more important than the other 690?
Rating: Summary: informative Templar stuff Review: THE knowledge anyone can get in history books and literary works about 10 different nations and culture could be learned in just ONE copy of Foucault's Pendulum. Eco is just one heck of a demigod.
Rating: Summary: Think Twice Review: In a profusion of pages, Eco's prosaic prose delivers a multitude of recondite, hermetic minutiae, but little style and a disappointing resolution to a provocative premise. Despite its drawbacks, the intricate story line wholly immerses the reader in an intriguing international, cabalistic plot. The mystery spans millennia of history, and its implications are nothing less than fantastic. Fans of secret societies, ancient mysteries, historical fiction, or world-domination plots must read this. However if, like me, you are the casual reader captivated by the synopsis, think twice - you will spend many hours to finish this convoluted novel.
Rating: Summary: Divine madness Review: I skimmed the rest of the reviews, and here's my summation: First, like many other great, challenging, sometimes inaccessible works of art, this one tends get polarized responses... you're gonna love it or hate it. And second, not everyone responds well to the particular brand of fantastic historical puzzle that Eco spins here. And let's face it: the plot, the characters, the historical references are DEEP. Navigating some of the "back story" jumps is definitely an effort, and I can see where some people's minds just won't engage with Eco's beautifully crafted, diabolically brainteasing yarn. This book is WORK. With that said, I LOVED it. Yeah, it can be work to get through, but it's SO worth it. Eco is the ultimate pimp when it comes to building his sentences, and the beguiling gossamer with which he weaves his dark fantasy ultimately ropes you into his style and leaves you begging for more. Eco's style is almost as seductive as his substance: the synthesis of the secret societies, the Masons, Templars, Rosicrucians et al makes for a beautifully researched alternate reality which is so compelling that it'll have you turning your worldview upside down. If you buy in to Eco's universe the way I did, this will be one of the best, most maddening, most terrifying reads of your life. One more earlier review comment worth repeating: If you have poor self-control, wait until you have a few days off to read this book. The last 100 pages took over my life... lucky it wasn't a school night.
Rating: Summary: Exasperating and spellbinding at the same time Review: _Foucault's Pendulum_ is amazing and deranged book that appealed to my senses.I bought it out of curiosity and found myself pulled in to the plot.It is a great book and has a few lines that I'll never forget.This is a must buy book!
Rating: Summary: Wonerfully thought provoking. Review: This book, with all of the travels it takes you on, especially the intillectual explorations ranks up there for me at least to be one of the greatest books ever written. Second, of course to The Magic Mountain
|