<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: Well done picture history of an elite German division.
Review: God, Honor, Fatherland is an excellent pictoral study of one of the Whermacht's truly elite divisions. The author covers "GD" from 1942 to 1944. Although I have a fairly extensive collection of books covering the German Army on the Eastern front, most photos in this book were new to me. The author made contact with numerous "GD" veterans and got many previously unpublished photos, many of which the people in them are listed by name and sub-unit. The author also gives 1 to 2 page narratives of the various major battles GD participated in during this time frame. As well as descriptions of the various sub-units that made up GD, including rarely covered support/maitenance units. My favorite part of the book were the biographical sketches of various GD personalities. These include not only senior and company grade officers, but several NCO's as well. I recomend this book to anyone interested in German units or the Eastern front of WW2, particularly armor buffs and modelers.
Rating:
Summary: More than a photo history
Review: In addition to the precious period photos of the elite of the Heer, the GD division in action, you also get to know of all the petty jealousies, discriminations, nepotism that existed between the founding regiment of the division the Grenadier Regiment, with its sister, and much despised, Füsilier Regiment, which certainly affected the division's performance, despite it being the most lavishly equipped panzergrenadier division (with a 3 Abteilungen Regiment) and that its recruits came from the best Reichdeutsche all over Germany.
Rating:
Summary: Unbelievably good captions
Review: Not just another mundane collection of photos, this book is perhaps one of the best volumes in English regarding German soldiers, and especially the GD Division. The captions cast light on many arcance areas of study - uniforms, organization, history, tactics - and all the details are consistently correct and well researched. The only minor nit I was able to find is the mis-captioning of an NCO equivalent beamten as a "Hauptmann" - (p. 114) Overall, a thoroughly excellent photographic record, with emphasis on naming photo subjects (a very nice touch). Of course, as with any collection of WW II photos, most of the pictures in this book are obviously posed, and there is nothing in the way of "real action" shots. This is not a drawback, and few "real action" shots were taken during the war by any of the combatants. There are also some excellent biographical sketches of Knight' Cross winners and unit commanders.
Rating:
Summary: Unbelievably good captions
Review: Not just another mundane collection of photos, this book is perhaps one of the best volumes in English regarding German soldiers, and especially the GD Division. The captions cast light on many arcance areas of study - uniforms, organization, history, tactics - and all the details are consistently correct and well researched. The only minor nit I was able to find is the mis-captioning of an NCO equivalent beamten as a "Hauptmann" - (p. 114) Overall, a thoroughly excellent photographic record, with emphasis on naming photo subjects (a very nice touch). Of course, as with any collection of WW II photos, most of the pictures in this book are obviously posed, and there is nothing in the way of "real action" shots. This is not a drawback, and few "real action" shots were taken during the war by any of the combatants. There are also some excellent biographical sketches of Knight' Cross winners and unit commanders.
<< 1 >>
| 
